Are collar bells bad for dogs?

Are Collars With Bells Bad For Dogs?

As a dog owner, you want to ensure that your furry friend is safe, comfortable, and stylish. One accessory that many people love to use is a dog collar with a bell. These collars can be cute, functional, and even provide some added protection for your dog. But are collars with bells actually bad for dogs? Let’s take a deeper dive into the pros and cons of using collars with bells and what you need to consider before adding one to your pup’s wardrobe.

Why Do We Use Dog Collars?

Collars are more than just an accessory—they serve several important purposes. For one, collars are used for identification. Most dog collars will have your dog's name, your name, and your contact details. This is vital in case your dog gets lost. Collars also serve as a practical tool for restraint and control, especially when you need to attach a leash for walks.

But beyond functionality, dog collars can also be a fashion statement! Just like humans, dogs can sport collars that reflect their personality. Bright colors, cool patterns, and even customizable tags are popular choices for pet owners who want to showcase their dog’s style. When it comes to collars with bells, the primary question is: do they benefit your dog, or do they cause more harm than good?

Free e-book you will learn how to play “The Airplane Game” designed to improve your dog’s ability to pay attention to you despite distractions, click HERE

What Are Dog Collars With Bells?

A dog collar with a bell is exactly what it sounds like—a collar with a small bell attached to it. These collars are quite popular, especially among dog owners whose dogs love to roam freely. The bell rings every time your dog moves, which allows you to hear where they are at all times. This can be especially helpful if your dog is always on the move, or if you live in a larger home or outdoor area and need to track their movements.

But, as with most things in life, collars with bells come with both pros and cons. Let’s break them down.

Pros of Collars With Bells

1. Safety First

One of the biggest benefits of a bell on your dog’s collar is safety. If your dog likes to wander off, the bell can act as a sort of auditory leash, letting you know where they are. This can be especially useful if you have a dog that tends to sneak out of sight, like a Beagle or a Treeing Walker Coonhound, which are known for their incredible prey drive.

Imagine this: you’re walking through the woods, and your dog decides to chase a squirrel or a rabbit. With a bell on their collar, you’ll immediately hear it jingling in the distance, so you can track them down before they disappear into the wild blue yonder. If your dog is hard to recall, especially when they’re in “hunt mode,” a bell is a lifesaver.

2. Training Aid

Some dog trainers suggest using the bell as part of your training regimen. If your dog learns to associate the sound of the bell with their owner, it can be used as a tool to encourage them to come back when called. This is particularly useful for dogs with recall issues. Over time, they may start to understand that when they hear the bell ring, it’s time to return to you.

3. Protection from Predators

In certain situations, having a bell on your dog’s collar might even protect them from harm. There have been reports from pet owners in rural areas where snakes and other predators would flee upon hearing the sound of a dog’s bell. In areas where wildlife poses a threat to your dog, a collar with a bell might just give them an added layer of protection.

4. Keeps Prey Safe

If you have other pets in the house, like rabbits or birds, the bell can also serve as a warning system. Dogs are natural hunters, and even if they don’t mean harm, their instinct to chase and capture can put smaller animals at risk. The bell serves as an early alert for those animals to get out of the way.

Free e-book you will learn how to play “The Airplane Game” designed to improve your dog’s ability to pay attention to you despite distractions, click HERE

Cons of Collars With Bells

1. Discomfort for Sensitive Dogs

Not all dogs are fans of the bell. For some, the constant jingling can be irritating. Dogs with sensitive hearing might experience anxiety or distress from the sound. If your dog is especially noise-sensitive, the sound of a bell might actually make them more anxious rather than providing any benefits.

2. Risk of Ear Damage

While there are no widespread reports of ear damage from collars with bells, some veterinarians raise concerns about the bell’s proximity to the dog’s sensitive ears. For dogs who wear the collar for extended periods, the constant jingling might cause discomfort or even lead to ear irritation.

3. Choking Hazard

For smaller dogs, a bell can also pose a choking hazard. Some dogs are chewers, and there’s a risk that they might chew on the bell, swallow it, and end up choking. Even if the risk is low, it’s something to consider, especially for puppies and smaller breeds.

4. Physical Discomfort

If the collar itself is too heavy or poorly fitted, it could cause discomfort or even physical harm to your dog. Collars that are too tight can restrict airflow, damage the skin, or cause other physical issues like tracheal collapse. On the other hand, collars that are too loose can slip off and potentially cause your dog to get caught on something, leading to an injury.

Real-Life Experiences

Some dog owners swear by the bell collar, especially for hunting breeds. Take, for example, the Beagle or the Treeing Walker Coonhound. These dogs have a high prey drive and will often follow their quarry for miles without stopping. A collar with a bell can help their owners track them down before they get too far. In areas where these breeds are used for hunting, it’s common to use bells to ensure that the dog can be found easily.

Veterinarians in the South, where these breeds are common, often hear of rescues being flooded with lost dogs. The dogs have followed their prey so far that they’ve become disoriented and lost. The bell collar, in this case, might just save the dog from a night in animal control.

Key Takeaways

The decision to use a collar with a bell depends largely on your dog’s behavior and comfort level. Here’s a quick summary of what to consider:

• Safety: Collars with bells can alert others to your dog’s presence, potentially preventing accidents or helping you locate them more easily.
• Training: The bell can be a useful tool for recall training or teaching your dog to return when called.
• Prey Drive Protection: In areas with wildlife or other pets, the bell may help keep animals safe by warning them of your dog’s approach.

• Comfort and Health: If your dog doesn’t like the sound or has sensitive ears, a bell could cause more harm than good. Make sure the collar fits properly and doesn’t cause discomfort.

Ultimately, if your dog seems comfortable with the bell and it serves a practical purpose—like improving safety or aiding in training—it can be a valuable tool. But if it causes distress or discomfort, it may be best to reconsider using it. Always observe your dog’s behavior and consult with a veterinarian or professional trainer if you’re unsure about whether a bell collar is right for your pet.

Free e-book you will learn how to play “The Airplane Game” designed to improve your dog’s ability to pay attention to you despite distractions, click HERE

Conclusion

Collars with bells may seem like a simple accessory, but they can have a significant impact on your dog’s safety, comfort, and well-being. Whether they are a good fit for your dog depends on a variety of factors, including their personality, breed, and overall behavior. By weighing the pros and cons, and observing your dog’s response, you can decide if a bell collar is the right choice.

Remember, every dog is unique, and what works for one dog might not work for another. If you're on the fence, take a step back, evaluate the situation, and talk to a professional if needed. After all, our dogs depend on us to make the best choices for their health and happiness.

Thanks for your reading.