Medieval Europe
Medieval Europe has a terrible reputation. It is often associated with disease and famine, which was true. Children were said to marry at very young ages, like six, eight, or ten. However, this was not common. People did start marrying younger, partly because they died younger. Knights were thought to slaughter indiscriminately, but they followed a chivalric code, which was in decline at that time. It is also said that it was unsafe to drink water, so people drank beer instead.
Today, we will focus on these so-called "Middle Ages." Regarding beer, people did drink beer and ale. These drinks were nutritious, and they are still considered so today. However, they also consumed other beverages, such as milk and water.
In the 14th and 15th centuries, there were wells with safe and delicious drinking water. However, many negative events occurred during this time. The Black Death, the Great Schism in the Catholic Church, and the Hundred Years War were significant issues. Additionally, the Little Ice Age began in the 14th century. This led to cooler temperatures and declining harvests, which caused stunting and starvation.
Let's focus on the Black Death. This massive pandemic was caused by the Bubonic Plague, which spread to Europe from Asia. Experts believe the plague originated in Tibet. It started as a localized epidemic but then spread due to rats, mice, and fleas. These animals traveled with humans, highlighting the growing interconnectedness of society.
Bubonic plague is a terrible disease. It is caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis. Infected individuals experience swollen lymph nodes that can burst. They also suffer from high fevers and may vomit blood. Gangrene can turn extremities and facial features black, leading to the term "the Black Death." Depending on the strain, 50 to 60 percent of infected individuals may die. Today, bubonic plague can be treated with antibiotics, which have only existed for a few decades. However, in the 20th century, outbreaks in India and China killed over 12 million people. The Black Death of the 14th century was even worse.
By 1347, around 25 million people had died in Asia from the plague. When it reached Constantinople, it spread rapidly to Europe. Within four years, a large number of Europeans had died from it. Many succumbed to the disease within just two days of being infected. Families faced a tough choice: care for a sick loved one or risk their own health. In some areas, population loss reached up to 80 percent. Studies suggest that about half of Europe’s population perished. The toll of death was overwhelming. Imagine losing half of your community to an unknown illness in just a few years.
Giovanni Boccaccio noted the tragic scenes: "Many died in the open street." Others passed away in their homes, their bodies decomposing and creating a terrible smell. Burial spaces ran out. Bodies were piled in mass graves, much like cargo in a ship.
Now, after 650 years, how different life is. The bacterium that caused the Black Death is now available as a plush toy. They are cute and do not seem dangerous, but this is Yersinia pestis, turned into a stuffed animal.
Amid this devastation, the Hundred Years War added more chaos. It was fought between England and France over control of parts of Europe. The conflict lasted at least 116 years, starting in 1337.
One interesting question in history is whether war leads to instability or if instability leads to war. The answer may be both. Poor harvests and disease outbreaks can increase the likelihood of war. However, war can also worsen these conditions. During the Black Death, the Hundred Years War created instability in food supplies and cultural beliefs, such as The Code of Chivalry.
Chivalry involved treating knightly opponents with respect on the battlefield. Knights would capture their opponents instead of killing them, holding them for ransom in good condition. This behavior distinguished knights from common archers and mercenaries. However, English kings began hiring mercenaries from Europe. These mercenaries often looted and plundered without following chivalric codes.
Some knights for hire found fighting so profitable that they continued to raid even during truces. The Hundred Years War also brought innovations in warfare. Non-aristocratic soldiers from England and Wales used the longbow, known for its speed and accuracy. This weapon helped the English win at the Battle of Agincourt. Before this war, the French had innovated by using cannons on ships. The English later adapted these cannons for land battles.
Both types of cannons relied on gunpowder. This was a Chinese invention. The Hundred Years War featured the rise and fall of Joan of Arc. She was born to a prosperous French peasant family in 1412. By the time she was sixteen, England had taken control of the French throne, as confirmed by the 1420 Treaty of Troyes. France appeared to have no strong leader.
Joan had visions that guided her to lead the French forces. She aimed to drive out the English so Charles, the rightful heir, could be crowned. Remarkably, she succeeded. By 1429, Charles became Charles VII of France. However, the Burgundians captured Joan. They handed her over to the English, who executed her by burning in 1431. It was a tragic outcome, but there are no easy endings.
Life in 14th and 15th century Europe was difficult. Murder and violence were likely more common than today. Dying in battle was a routine risk. Malnutrition and stunted growth were widespread. Child mortality was alarmingly high; about 50% of children did not reach the age of five. People sought solace in religion, but it was lacking in comfort for many.
In 1300, Pope Boniface VIII was the leader of the Catholic Church. He was also a significant political figure in Europe. A key question of the time was whether the Church had authority over all Catholics or if kings held ultimate power in their realms. For example, did King Philip IV of France have the right to tax Catholic clergy? Pope Boniface believed he did not.
He came from a powerful family. At the start of the 14th century, he asserted influence over the papacy. In 1302, he declared that the Pope had supreme authority over everyone. This was problematic because kings were also seeking more power. They wanted tax revenue from the Church to grow their administrations.
In response, Boniface threatened to excommunicate Philip. In retaliation, Philip had the Pope kidnapped. Boniface was reportedly tortured while in captivity and died shortly after his release in 1303.
By 1305, Philip arranged for the election of a French Pope who was installed at Avignon. This move made it seem as though the papacy was under French control and distant from its spiritual mission. In 1377, Pope Gregory XI decided to return to Rome, but he died soon after.
The Cardinals elected an Italian pope, which caused the French Cardinals to regroup and elect a French pope to lead the papal court in Avignon. This resulted in two popes and the Great Schism.
The Great Schism significantly harmed the Church's claims of spiritual leadership. It coincided with the Black Death, during which the clergy struggled to provide guidance. Priests, monks, and nuns faced the same fears of death as everyone else.
Now, it was unclear which pope was the legitimate one or which church was the true Church. This disunity, along with stories of unspiritual indulgences, weakened the Church's authority.
Spiritual direction came from common people, not just the powerful. For example, Catherine of Siena was an ordinary young woman with strong religious faith. She successfully urged Pope Gregory XI to return to Rome, although he later died. Before Catherine died in 1380 at age 33, she took on several diplomatic missions between the Church and Italian cities. She traveled widely, urging clergy to reform and strengthen their spiritual ministry. Eventually, a council was called to end the Great Schism, leading to the election of a single pope, Martin V, in 1417. Before that, a third pope was even elected for a while.
In the late Middle Ages, your chances of becoming Pope were quite high. This period marked a decline in European Christendom's power. In 1453, the Ottomans captured the Byzantine Empire's capital. They were aided by a Hungarian munitions expert who understood cannons. The Byzantine Emperor thought this expert's fees were too expensive. The Ottomans already controlled parts of southeastern Europe, but taking the Byzantine capital was significant. They beheaded the Emperor, marking the final fall of the Roman Empire. Islam then replaced Christianity as the main religion in Constantinople, and the famous Cathedral became the Hagia Sophia mosque. Control of Constantinople was crucial for trade routes and other reasons, as it was one of Europe's better cities at the time.
Meanwhile, the use of mercenaries weakened the feudal system. Loyalty was supposed to be owed to a lord, from knights to serfs bound to the land. The Black Death and ongoing warfare contributed to this change as well.
There were significantly fewer humans. This led to a reduced workforce in agriculture. As a result, serfs could demand their freedom. Their labor became more valuable. Peasants rebelled against the nobility for better conditions. The Peasants Revolt of 1381 in England saw nobles murdered and castles sacked. In cities, urban artisans also sought higher pay and lower taxes. In 1378, The Ciompi in Florence protested against harsh debt prosecution and extra taxes. They marched, declaring, "Long live the little people." The push for rights for artisans and farm workers would take time. However, their rising power marked a significant change in Europe, coinciding with the decline of feudalism. Warfare evolved too. People no longer fought for ethics or divine glory. They fought for fame and careers, as noted by a French chronicler. A proverb summarized warfare: "Sometimes you win, sometimes you lose." Daily life included sayings like "There's nothing more certain than death," with someone adding "and taxes." Other proverbs reflected a zero-sum mentality: "The big fishes eat the smaller." "Men are good so long as it saves their skin." Amidst these views, new ideas emerged. This included the thoughts of The Ciompi, peasants, artists, philosophers, and architects. They contributed to Europe’s rebirth, known as the Renaissance. The Great Renaissance Cathedral of Florence was completed before the Hundred Years War ended. Next week, we will focus on Florence, the center of this revival.