Psyche logo

The Weight of Labels

How identity politics silences the soul and divides the human spirit

By Peter Thwing - Host of the FST PodcastPublished 3 months ago 5 min read
The Weight of Labels
Photo by Simran Sood on Unsplash

I did not get angry because I was attacked. I got angry because I felt invisible.

That is what labeling does. It reduces a human being—a soul with thoughts, experiences, and convictions—into a set of categories that can be dismissed before they even speak.

It used to be that people wanted to be known for their character, their ideas, and their actions. Now people are defined by what group they belong to. Race, gender, sexuality, and political alignment have replaced integrity, effort, and virtue as the metrics of identity. It is not enough to be a good person anymore. You have to be the right kind of person according to whoever holds cultural power at the moment.

I know this because I have lived it.

The New Hierarchy of Victims and Villains

There was a time when equality meant treating everyone the same. Now equality means treating people differently until the outcomes are equal. Somewhere along the way, compassion turned into condescension. We built a hierarchy of victims where moral worth is assigned based on who has suffered the most.

I am told that because I am a white, heterosexual, Christian male, my opinion is less valid. That I am privileged by nature of my birth and therefore unqualified to speak about injustice. I am told that I benefit from systems of oppression I have never supported and that my faith automatically makes me dangerous or intolerant.

None of these accusations are personal in the sense that they come from people who know me. They are personal in that they erase who I actually am. They take the image of God in me and replace it with a caricature drawn by politics.

The cruel irony is that the same society that condemns stereotyping now thrives on it. The same people who preach empathy practice exclusion. The same voices that claim to fight prejudice build entire worldviews upon it.

When Labels Replace Logic

Identity politics has replaced moral reasoning with emotional accounting. Instead of asking, “Is this true?” the world now asks, “Who is saying it, and what group are they from?” The credibility of an argument no longer depends on evidence but on demographics.

If a woman says something, it is “her truth.” If a man says the same thing, it is “mansplaining.” If a Christian defends biblical morality, it is “hate speech.” If a secular activist says the opposite, it is “courage.”

This is not justice. It is manipulation. It is a cultural system designed to silence dissent by attacking identity instead of addressing ideas. Once you can brand someone with a negative label, you no longer have to engage with their reasoning.

We see it everywhere. People are called racist for quoting crime statistics. They are called bigoted for believing in biological sex. They are called phobic for defending moral boundaries that have existed for thousands of years. The labels do the heavy lifting that logic once did. The goal is not understanding. The goal is control.

The Erosion of Dialogue

Labels destroy conversation. When everything you say is filtered through what others think you represent, dialogue becomes impossible. Instead of two people seeking truth together, you have two sides guarding territory. Every discussion becomes a battle for moral superiority.

This is why so many people remain silent. It is not that they lack opinions. It is that they know any honest statement can be weaponized against them. The marketplace of ideas has been replaced by a courtroom where guilt is presumed and redemption is rare.

But silence has a cost. The more people retreat, the smaller the space for truth becomes. Lies fill the vacuum left by fear. And those who once believed in fairness start to believe that fairness itself is weakness.

Identity Without Soul

The obsession with identity has hollowed people out. We have trained generations to build self-worth on categories that shift with every social trend. No wonder anxiety and depression are rising. You cannot build a lasting identity on something as unstable as victimhood.

True identity is not self-invented. It is God-given. You do not have to be born into the “right” group to have value. You were created in the image of God, which means your worth is fixed, eternal, and untouchable by human approval.

That is why the constant fight for validation never ends. When you remove God from the equation, the only thing left to worship is self. And the self is never satisfied.

The Spiritual Root of Division

At its core, identity politics is not just a political weapon. It is a spiritual rebellion. It says, “I will define who I am,” instead of “I am who God says I am.” It rejects the idea of universal morality and replaces it with tribal morality, where right and wrong are determined by group loyalty.

The enemy of truth has always used division as a weapon. The more divided people become, the easier they are to control. That is why this war is not simply about race or gender or politics. It is about erasing the shared image of God that once bound society together.

We were meant to see each other as brothers and sisters, not as statistics or categories. We were meant to judge character, not chromosomes. But when people lose sight of the Creator, they begin to fight over creation.

The Way Out

The only way out of this chaos is to return to a moral vision that transcends identity. We must remember that truth is not limited to one group, and moral law is not optional. Every human being is accountable to the same standard because every human being was made by the same God.

We can disagree on politics and still share the same foundation if that foundation is truth. But we cannot build peace on lies. We cannot build unity on resentment. We cannot build justice on partiality.

The world tells you to find your identity in your feelings, your body, or your social group. God tells you to find it in Him. The first leads to exhaustion. The second leads to peace.

Freedom Beyond the Labels

The labels will not stop coming, but we can stop believing them. We can choose to speak truth even when it costs something. We can choose to love people without affirming falsehood. We can refuse to participate in the theater of division.

Freedom begins the moment you realize that no label defines you except the one God gave you. You are not the sum of your demographics. You are a person made with purpose, endowed with reason, and called to courage.

The world may call that dangerous. . .

I call it human.

addictionadviceanxietyartbipolarbook reviewscelebritiescopingdepressiondisordereatingfamilyhow tohumanityinterviewlistmedicinemovie reviewpanic attackspersonality disorderphotographypop cultureproduct reviewptsdrecoveryschizophreniaselfcaresocial mediastigmatherapytraumatreatmentsvintageworksupport

About the Creator

Peter Thwing - Host of the FST Podcast

Peter unites intellect, wisdom, curiosity, and empathy —

Writing at the crossroads of faith, philosophy, and freedom —

Confronting confusion with clarity —

Guiding readers toward courage, conviction, and renewal —

With love, grace, and truth.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.