Critique logo

Oliver Twist is a sham

Dickens and his novel set among the great unwashed poor of Victorian London have been vastly over-rated

By Raymond G. TaylorPublished 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago 1 min read
Runner-Up in Critique Challenge
From an illustration by Cruickshank: public domain

Characters are wooden and two dimensional. The book imbued with Victorian hypocrisy. Oliver Twist, far from shining a light on inner city poverty and crime, is voyeuristic and nauseatingly sentimental. In the end, Oliver is plucked from London's 'wickedness' only to join his benefactor in a life of rural privilege.

O ~ 0 ~ o ~

My first Vocal Media runner-up prize, Yay! I am so pleased to have made the mark for the first time and super grateful to the lovely Vocal team for choosing my little literary critique. I am also grateful for all the support I have received from various other Vocal creators for this and other work. I am particularly pleased to have won a 50-word challenge, as 'ultra-brief' is one of things I love to do. If you would like some hints and tips about how to write a complete story/article in 250 words, 100 words or even 50 words, you might like to check out:

How to write a story in 100 words (or less)

I am also glad to have had my reviews recognised in this way. I have been writing book and other reviews for some 40 years, professionally for 10 years when I was a business journalist back in the 1980s/90s. I still write occasional book and other reviews. For example:

  • What we fear most (book about forensic psychiatry)
  • Lichtenstein: Whaam! (the pop-art painting)

Not to mention....

My "Art for our sake" regular roundup of Art community gems.

Despite the many non-fiction articles I have written and posted on Vocal, my main ambition now is to make some waves in short fictional story writing. Please check out some of my short stories, perhaps by starting with this little WWII story of one determined woman shining her own heroic light in what was very much a man's world of aviation.

Thanks for reading and 1,000 thanks again to the Vocal curation team for providing us all with some fantastic and inspiring challenges!

Congratulations to all the winners!

Ray

Novel

About the Creator

Raymond G. Taylor

Author living in Kent, England. Writer of short stories and poems in a wide range of genres, forms and styles. A non-fiction writer for 40+ years. Subjects include art, history, science, business, law, and the human condition.

Reader insights

Outstanding

Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!

Top insights

  1. Easy to read and follow

    Well-structured & engaging content

  2. Expert insights and opinions

    Arguments were carefully researched and presented

  3. Heartfelt and relatable

    The story invoked strong personal emotions

  1. Compelling and original writing

    Creative use of language & vocab

  2. Excellent storytelling

    Original narrative & well developed characters

  3. Masterful proofreading

    Zero grammar & spelling mistakes

Add your insights

Comments (16)

Sign in to comment
  • Testabout a year ago

    Great piece.

  • Testabout a year ago

    Congratulations!!

  • Rob Angeli2 years ago

    Yes indeed. I have my liking for Dickens and a sentimental attachment to that book. The child hero is not only wooden, but empty. As representation of the child psyche, he is nothing but a fragile an imperturbable blankness of innocence and silence. Kids on the London street of that time were not that. The Artful Dodger (only with more profanity) that was reality.

  • Mackenzie Davis2 years ago

    You raise an interesting point and perspective on this piece! I need to reexamine it. Oh, and congrats on your placement! I am going to read all about how to write 100 word stories now... :D

  • Congrats on making the shortlist!

  • Megan Malcolm2 years ago

    Very well done, congratulations!

  • Grz Colm2 years ago

    Congrats on your prize and your thoughtful mini critique! 😊👏

  • E.K. Daniels2 years ago

    Loved the hot take. Well done, and congrats!

  • Ava Mack2 years ago

    Congrats, Raymond! As someone who periodically tries to convince herself she likes reading Dickens, your critique of Oliver Twist really resonates, haha!

  • Lamar Wiggins2 years ago

    Congrats on your very honest and well-structured critique. Glad to see your work recognized. 💖🤩

  • Kendall Defoe 2 years ago

    Spot on...and I want some more... ;)

  • Dana Stewart2 years ago

    Congrats Raymond!

  • Mark Graham2 years ago

    This is one way of looking at this piece of classic literature, but to me 'Oliver Twist' is one of growing up and making choices that help us grow.

  • Darkos2 years ago

    That's a real critique!

  • Lol, I can sense how much you hate this! Loved your review!

  • L.C. Schäfer2 years ago

    Couldn't agree more, utter vomitworthy cack. At least Scrooge had some sort of arc that wasn't just "luck".

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.