The Island That Vanished Without a Trace: Bermeja Island

Bermeja Island is one of the strangest mysteries in maritime history. For centuries, it appeared on maps of the Gulf of Mexico, a small, reddish island that was marked by explorers as early as the 16th century. However, when modern scientists and explorers set out to find Bermeja, they discovered a startling truth—it simply wasn’t there. What happened to this island? Was it erased by natural forces, or is something more sinister at play? Let’s dive into the baffling tale of Bermeja Island, a landmass that disappeared without a trace.

This Strange Island Suddenly Disappeared From Every Map. You'll definitely enjoy this!

The Origins of Bermeja Island: A Spanish Cartographic Mystery

Bermeja Island first appeared on maps drawn by Spanish cartographers in the 1500s, located at 22.55° N, 91.3667° W, far off the northern coast of the Yucatán Peninsula. The island was named after its reddish hue (bermeja means “reddish” in Spanish), and for centuries, it seemed to be a common feature on numerous maps, drawn by various explorers, including those from Spain, France, and Britain. By all accounts, Bermeja should have been a small but noticeable landmass—roughly 80 square kilometers.

In the 18th and 19th centuries, Bermeja continued to be referenced in cartographic records, and no one questioned its existence. But as the centuries passed and mapping technology improved, doubt began to creep in. By the late 20th century, something strange was afoot: modern explorers could not find Bermeja Island.

The Great Search: Where Did Bermeja Go?

In 1997, a group of Mexican fishermen ventured to the coordinates where Bermeja was supposed to be located—and found nothing but open ocean. They were puzzled but assumed it was a navigation error. However, this was only the beginning of Bermeja’s mystery. In 2009, Mexico took the search to a new level, commissioning a large-scale investigation by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM). They used advanced sonar and imaging technologies to scan the seafloor for any remnants of the island. The result? No island, no submerged landmass—just endless water.

Bermeja’s disappearance left scientists and researchers stumped. How could an island that had been documented for centuries simply vanish? Theories began to swirl, and soon, the mystery of Bermeja Island attracted international attention.

Why Bermeja Island Mattered: Politics, Oil, and the EEZ

Why does Bermeja’s existence (or lack thereof) matter so much to Mexico? The answer lies in the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), a 200-mile territorial boundary established by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) in 1982. Every coastal country has rights to the natural resources (such as oil and fish) within its EEZ, extending 200 nautical miles from its coastline. If Bermeja Island truly existed, it would have significantly extended Mexico’s EEZ, giving the nation rights to a larger portion of the Gulf of Mexico—an area known to be rich in oil reserves.

Without Bermeja, the boundary between Mexico and the United States remains further south, meaning Mexico loses out on valuable oil-drilling territory. This raises the stakes in the search for Bermeja, making the island’s existence or non-existence a matter of economic and geopolitical importance.

What Happened to Bermeja? Theories and Speculation

There are several theories to explain the disappearance of Bermeja Island, ranging from natural causes to far-fetched conspiracy theories. Let’s take a look at the most prominent ones:

1. Rising Sea Levels and Erosion

One of the more logical explanations is that Bermeja was simply swallowed by the ocean. Rising sea levels, combined with erosion, may have caused the island to slowly submerge over centuries, leaving no trace. However, the UNAM study in 2009 found no evidence of a submerged island at the given coordinates, casting doubt on this theory.

2. Cartographic Error

Could it be that Bermeja never existed in the first place? Cartography in the 16th century was not an exact science, and mapmakers often relied on secondhand accounts from explorers. It’s possible that early Spanish cartographers made an error, placing Bermeja on maps where no island existed. Over time, this mistake could have been copied from one map to another, cementing Bermeja’s place in history despite its nonexistence.

3. A "Trap Island"

Another possibility is that Bermeja was a “trap island”—a fictitious island deliberately placed on maps by early cartographers to catch rivals copying their work. By including a fake island, cartographers could easily identify plagiarism when other maps featured the same nonexistent landmass. This practice was common in the age of exploration.

4. Conspiracy Theories

As with any good mystery, there are those who believe that Bermeja’s disappearance was no accident. Some conspiracy theorists suggest that the CIA or other U.S. agencies deliberately destroyed the island to prevent Mexico from extending its EEZ and gaining access to valuable oil reserves. While this theory makes for an entertaining story, there’s no evidence to support the idea that an entire island was blown up or removed by government forces.

The Legacy of Bermeja: A Modern-Day Enigma

To this day, the mystery of Bermeja Island remains unsolved. Despite multiple expeditions and advanced technology, no trace of the island has been found. It continues to live on in maps and records from the past, but in the real world, it has vanished without a trace.

Bermeja’s story is more than just a geographical oddity—it’s a reminder of how much we still have to learn about the world around us. Whether it was a cartographer’s mistake, a victim of natural forces, or something more conspiratorial, Bermeja Island holds a unique place in history, as a phantom island that once was—and then wasn’t.

Conclusion: The Island That Wasn’t There

The mystery of Bermeja Island captivates the imagination, blending history, politics, and intrigue into one enigmatic tale. Its existence—or lack thereof—has sparked debates, launched expeditions, and even influenced international politics. While we may never know exactly what happened to Bermeja, its story continues to fascinate, serving as a reminder of how much we still don’t know about our world—and how easy it is for the lines between fact and fiction to blur on the high seas.

In the end, Bermeja may have disappeared from the maps, but it will never vanish from the annals of mystery.