The Algorithm of Us
“When a Swipe Right Rekindles a Forgotten Love”

Maya Kapoor had always thought online dating was a game of chances—swipe left on bad jokes, swipe right on cute dogs and sharp jawlines. It was a routine she followed more out of habit than hope. After a string of coffee dates that fizzled into awkward silences or ghosted texts, she was ready to call it quits.
Until "Jay_43" popped up on her screen.
He wasn’t her usual type. No shirtless gym photos or pouting selfies. Just a clean-cut profile with a short bio: "Book hoarder. Amateur cook. Believer in second chances." Something about it made her stop scrolling.
She swiped right.
Within seconds: “It’s a match!”
They started talking that night. Jay wasn’t just charming—he was thoughtful, funny, curious. He asked about her favorite books, her weird habit of organizing books by color instead of genre, and even listened as she vented about her chaotic job as a marketing exec for a fashion brand in Mumbai.
What surprised her most was how comfortable it felt. There was no pretense, no pressure. Just conversations that went on until 2 AM and left her smiling like a teenager.
By their third week of chatting, Jay suggested meeting in person. “Coffee? Or something stronger?” he texted, with a wink emoji that somehow didn’t feel cringe.
They decided on a quiet café tucked away in Bandra, known for its moody lighting and even moodier barista.
Maya arrived early, her heart doing a weird rhythm she hadn’t felt in years. She ordered two cappuccinos and sat at the window, nervously checking her phone.
“Hey, are you the one who color-codes their bookshelf?” a voice said.
She looked up.
And froze.
Standing in front of her was not Jay_43.
It was Aarav Mehta.
The same Aarav she had gone to college with. The Aarav who used to be her best friend. The one who had moved to the U.S. after graduation and completely vanished from her life without a goodbye.
“You’ve got to be kidding me,” she said, standing up in disbelief.
Aarav looked just as stunned. “Maya?! Wait… you're BookMuse_27?”
They stared at each other, laughter and shock bubbling into an awkward hug.
“So, you’re Jay_43?” she asked as they sat down. “Why the fake name?”
“I thought it sounded more mysterious,” he said, grinning sheepishly. “But you? You really color-code your bookshelf?”
They both burst out laughing, the tension slowly melting into nostalgia.
The café date turned into dinner. Dinner turned into a walk along Carter Road, reminiscing about college, favorite professors, and that one time they both got locked in the library during finals week.
“You disappeared,” Maya finally said as they sat on a bench overlooking the sea.
“I know. I shouldn’t have. Life got… intense. My dad got sick, and I had to take over the family business in New Jersey. I didn’t handle things well. And I didn’t think you’d care.”
“I cared,” she said softly. “You were my best friend.”
“I never stopped thinking about you, Maya.”
The honesty in his voice made her look away. Part of her wanted to stay mad, but another part—stronger, more hopeful—wanted to believe in second chances.
Over the next few weeks, Aarav became a part of her life again. Slowly, organically. Not like a whirlwind romance, but like something that had always been there, waiting to bloom.
He helped her set up a home library, even though he insisted on organizing it by genre. They debated plot twists over late-night pizza and recreated their college tradition of reading poetry under fairy lights.
People on Instagram started noticing. Maya’s subtle couple posts, Aarav’s cheesy captions. Her DMs flooded: “Wait, is this THE Aarav from college?” and “This is better than any Netflix rom-com!”
But things weren’t all perfect.
Aarav’s work was still in New Jersey, and Maya had just gotten promoted. The distance loomed like a storm cloud.
One night, over takeout and half-drunk glasses of wine, Aarav asked, “What if we try long-distance? At least for a while?”
Maya looked at him, then at the city skyline beyond her window.
“I don’t want to lose you again.”
“Then don’t,” he said simply. “We’ll figure it out.”
They did.
A year later, Aarav relocated to Mumbai permanently, opening a boutique bookstore café—named “Second Chapters.” Maya helped him design the logo.
The grand opening was small but cozy, with handwritten quotes on the walls and their college photo behind the counter.
“Remember that time we said we’d open a book café when we ‘grew up’?” Maya teased.
“We did grow up,” Aarav replied, handing her a cappuccino. “Just took a detour.”
She smiled, taking a sip. It tasted exactly like the one from their first unexpected date.
Sometimes, love doesn’t come with fireworks or dramatic gestures. Sometimes, it comes with a second chance. A swipe. A shared past. A future built one page at a time.



Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.