Top 10 Must-Have Oak Island Collectibles: Bring Home a Piece of the Mystery

You may not have a treasure map, a borehole rig, or a centuries-old cipher to decode…

But you can own a piece of the most mysterious island in North America.

From ancient-styled coins to replica tools, the world of Oak Island collectibles is rich, imaginative, and filled with just enough mystery to make your bookshelf feel like a dig site.

Whether you’re a lifelong viewer of The Curse of Oak Island, a history buff with pirate leanings, or just a sucker for lost treasure lore — this list of the Top 10 must-have Oak Island collectibles is your personal vault of wonder.

1. Replica Spanish Coin Set

No item screams “hidden treasure” quite like a weathered silver coin from the Age of Exploration.

This collectible set includes accurate reproductions of 16th–17th century Spanish doubloons, styled after the real coins recovered on Oak Island.

They come aged, embossed with regal insignia, and nestled in a rustic pouch — ready to toss onto your desk or bury in your backyard for the kids to find.

Why it matters: Spanish coins were among the earliest real artifacts discovered on the island — proof that the Oak Island legend wasn’t just fantasy.

Bonus points: Some sets come with accompanying lore cards and “dig log” parchment.

🧭 2. The Official Oak Island Map Poster

This one’s for the wall — and the imagination.

An illustrated, old-world-style map of Oak Island, featuring all major dig sites, anomalies, and historical landmarks like the Money Pit, Smith’s Cove, Borehole 10-X, and the Swamp.

Printed on faux-aged parchment and detailed with compass roses, Templar markings, and notes, it’s as much a conspiracy board as it is art.

Why it matters: This is your guide. Fans use it to follow theories, mark discoveries, or just admire the layout of one of the most debated landscapes on Earth.

⛏️ 3. Miniature Money Pit Shovel

Not just a novelty — a symbol.

This scaled-down, hand-forged Oak Island shovel replica is modeled after the kind used by early searchers in the 1800s. Many are made from real metal and wood, mounted on plaques, or presented in collector’s boxes.

Some are even stamped with “1795” — the year the mystery began.

Why it matters: The Money Pit started with a shovel in dirt. Now, you hold that same spirit in your hands.

🧱 4. The Swamp Puzzle Box

Inspired by the enigmatic shape anomalies and buried secrets beneath the swamp, this handcrafted puzzle box mimics the mystery.

Slide compartments, secret triggers, and coded engravings protect a small hidden compartment — just big enough for a ring or coin.

Why it matters: It’s part riddle, part relic. Fans of the show will love how it mirrors the layers of deception on the real island.

Great gift idea for mystery lovers.

5. Aged Wood Fragment Display (From Island Debris)

No, it’s not from the actual Money Pit.

But some Oak Island vendors offer authentic wood fragments collected from legally approved shoreline drift, storm debris, or permitted excavation offshoots.

Presented in small glass frames or resin displays, they’re a subtle, powerful memento — nature touched by legend.

Why it matters: Holding ancient-feeling wood from Oak Island has an almost mythic weight — especially when paired with a certificate of origin.

✝️ 6. Templar Lead Cross Replica

One of the most iconic discoveries on Oak Island was a small lead cross — its design eerily similar to medieval Templar insignia.

This collectible is a faithful replica of that cross, cast in lead-tone pewter or oxidized silver. Often worn as a pendant, keychain, or even mounted in a shadow box.

Why it matters: Whether you believe in the Templar connection or not, the cross is a symbol of the island’s most controversial — and fascinating — theories.

📖 7. The Oak Island Lore Compendium

For the theorists and lore junkies, this leather-bound or hardcover guide is a treasure chest of history.

Compiled by researchers and superfans, it typically includes:

Theories from pirates to Freemasons

Timeline of discoveries

Templar connections

Site diagrams and journal excerpts

Unofficial dig records and folklore

Why it matters: It’s the deep dive. The legend in print. Essential for any collector who wants the story behind the souvenirs.

🔎 8. Oak Island Dig Kit (For Kids & Big Kids)

Complete with a sand block, mini tools, replica coins, and hidden “treasure,” this interactive kit lets fans play searcher at home.

Some premium versions include a “Money Pit challenge”, where players follow clues to dig in specific spots and uncover secrets — a perfect rainy day activity or educational gift.

Why it matters: Fun. Engaging. And great for passing the obsession to the next generation.

🧢 9. Team Lagina Gear: Hats, Tees, and Gloves

No Oak Island collection is complete without official show apparel.

From Rick’s iconic red “Oak Island” cap to the heavy-duty Marty-style work gloves, fans can gear up like the team — or just show their devotion at the next mystery convention.

Why it matters: It’s not just fashion. It’s fan armor.

Plus, it’s the fastest way to spot fellow believers at airports and coffee shops.

💰 10. The “Cursed Coin” Mystery Box

Part myth, part merch, this item taps directly into the spirit of Oak Island.

Each box contains a mystery coin or relic, themed insert cards, and occasionally, a rare “cursed edition” with a hidden message or special finish.

No two boxes are exactly the same — making this a highly collectible, thrill-of-the-hunt-style item.

Why it matters: It’s the treasure hunt, delivered to your door.

Conclusion: Own the Legend

Oak Island may still hold its greatest secrets below ground, but that doesn’t mean you can’t own a piece of the adventure.

Each collectible is a symbol — of history, mystery, obsession, and hope.

From weathered coins to cross pendants, from dig kits to lore tomes, the best Oak Island merchandise lets fans connect with the legend in a tangible, emotional way.

Because whether or not the treasure is ever found, the hunt lives on — in our homes, our hands, and our hearts.