Best Oak Island Gifts for Fans in 2025: Treasure, Mystery, and Must-Have Memorabilia

For the Oak Island fan in your life — or for yourself (we won’t tell) — the right gift isn’t just a souvenir.

It’s a connection to the legend.

A way to hold a fragment of the centuries-old search in your hands.

Whether it’s a Templar cross pendant, a replica Spanish coin, or a piece of map-inspired wall art, every Oak Island gift carries the weight of mystery, obsession, and hope.

Here’s our curated guide to the Best Oak Island Gifts for Fans in 2025 — perfect for birthdays, holidays, anniversaries, or just because the Swamp might actually be hiding a ship.

🎁 1. Templar Cross Replica Necklace

For the true believer in the legend.

Modeled after one of the show’s most iconic finds, this pendant symbolizes the Templar theory at the heart of Oak Island lore. Usually crafted in lead-toned pewter or aged silver, it’s a wearable mystery.

🗝️ Why fans love it: It’s subtle enough for daily wear — but fans recognize it instantly.

📜 2. Aged Oak Island Map Scroll

For the theorist who needs a wall-sized clue board.

This full-color replica of the island map is printed on weathered parchment or faux-aged canvas. It features key locations like Borehole 10-X, Smith’s Cove, the Money Pit, and the Stone Road.

🗝️ Why fans love it: Makes any room feel like a command center for uncovering buried secrets.

🔍 3. The Oak Island Research Compendium

For the lore-hungry historian.

This hardcover (or digital) book compiles all the major theories, dig records, symbols, maps, and analysis from decades of Oak Island research.

🗝️ Why fans love it: It’s like holding the search team’s field notes — without the mud.

🧤 4. Team Lagina Work Gloves

For the fan who likes to get their hands dirty.

These heavy-duty gloves are branded with the Oak Island logo and inspired by the real gear used by the Lagina brothers and their team on-site.

🗝️ Why fans love it: Perfect for gardening, building, or just cosplay in the garage.

🧱 5. Money Pit Mini Excavation Kit

For the hands-on treasure hunter (kids or adults).

This dig kit includes a clay “pit” embedded with replica relics — Spanish coins, leather fragments, aged wood, and a mystery artifact.

🗝️ Why fans love it: It’s an immersive experience that captures the spirit of the hunt.

✍️ 6. Oak Island Leather Journal with Templar Emblem

For the armchair researcher or fanfic writer.

Bound in distressed leather and embossed with a Templar-style seal, this journal is a great companion for note-taking, theory sketching, or keeping your own dig diary.

🗝️ Why fans love it: It looks like something that could’ve been found in a vault under the Swamp.

💻 7. Digital Oak Island Timeline Tracker (Interactive Download)

For the data-obsessed fan who loves connecting dots.

A downloadable, interactive timeline of Oak Island events, discoveries, theories, and dig operations — color-coded and updated as new information is revealed.

🗝️ Why fans love it: Makes it easy to track every borehole, anomaly, and artifact in one place.

🧢 8. Official Oak Island Cap

For those who want to rep the mystery out in the world.

This signature cap — often seen on Rick Lagina — is embroidered with the Oak Island logo and available in classic red, black, or camo.

🗝️ Why fans love it: It’s simple, iconic, and makes for great conversation in line at the hardware store.

9. Collector’s Coin & Relic Set (2025 Edition)

For the completist.

This limited-edition collectible box includes replicas of coins, metal objects, and stone fragments tied to Oak Island’s legend — plus lore cards for each.

🗝️ Why fans love it: Feels like your own mini museum exhibit.

🧭 10. Oak Island Mystery Board Game

For family game night — with secrets.

Solve the mystery together, build tunnels, dodge flood traps, and uncover artifacts while racing to unlock the vault first.

🗝️ Why fans love it: It blends historical facts with immersive gameplay, perfect for treasure-minded minds of all ages.

🎉 BONUS GIFT IDEA: “Oak Island Experience” Tour Voucher

For the ultimate fan pilgrimage.

Give the gift of an actual visit — with many tours including guided walks, dig site overviews, and exclusive behind-the-scenes access.

🗝️ Why fans love it: There’s nothing like standing where the legend lives.

🧭 Final Thoughts: The Gift of Mystery

Oak Island fans don’t just love the show — they love the story. The chase. The clues. The possibility that the next discovery will change everything.

These gifts let fans bring that energy into their homes, their shelves, their journals, and their everyday lives.

So whether it’s for a birthday, anniversary, or just a well-deserved surprise…

Give the gift of mystery.

Because sometimes, the real treasure is sharing the obsession.