In episode eleven, Nathan struggles to figure out who he is outside of a basketball player and decides to quit the team, leading to many an empty afternoon spent in Haley's company. Brooke struggles in her relationship with boyfriend Lucas, who brings art and books to the table while she has different interests. Finally, we are introduced to Larry, Peyton's father, while he is in between jobs.
BEHIND THE TITLE
The episode is entitled The Living Years, a song by the band Mike + The Mechanics, a British band formed in the 1980s as a side project for Genesis drummer Mike Rutherford. The primary reason I have heard of the band was through One Tree Hill, so it is my first occasion diving into their lyrics. The song's opening line, "Every generation / Blames the one before / And all of their frustrations / Come beating on your door" highlights well the conflict between adults and teenagers in this episode, especially between Nathan and his parents, Deb and Dan. The song in general deals with themes such as lack of communication and being on different wavelengths, which are central to the episode as well.
GENERAL OPINION.
I love the perfect mixture between the sense of fun present in this episode and the tough subjects it deals with. On one side, we see Nathan figuring his identity as a human as opposed to simply an athlete, and he does so by allowing himself to have fun with his girlfriend, the usually serious Haley. It is implied she has never skipped a class nor drunk liquor, and she goes through common teenage experiences for the first time. On the other side, we discover Peyton's tendency to sacrifice her well-being for others, specifically her father, who we meet for the first time, as well as Brooke's struggles with her first serious relationship, Lucas being the "first great guy" she's ever dated, and the first one she "gives a rat's ass" about. The blend of these two atmospheres is done so wonderfully and makes for a fantastic viewing experience.
SOUNDTRACK
- Harder To Breathe by Maroon 5
- Simple Again by Bua
- I Met A Girl by Wheat
- Everywhere She Goes by Across The Sky
- She's So Pretty by Kyf Brewer
- Ship Of Fools by World Party
- Avalanche by Ryan Adams
- The Shadowlands by Ryan Adams
I remembering touching upon my love of Maroon 5's Songs About Jane, and few things remind me of it more than the first season of One Tree Hill. It truly is one of the best indie-pop albums of the century.
QUOTES
"Dan and counseling, it's kinda like Hannibal Lecter at a salad bar."
Rewatching the show and analysing it led me to remember Keith's witty and sassy comebacks. His sarcastic tone is truly underrated.
"And the little prince said: 'Grownups never understand anything by themselves and it is tiresome for children to always be explaining things to them'".
The voiceover in The Living Years comes from Antoine De Saint-Exupéry's The Little Prince, a French classic from the 1940s. It comes into the conversation in this episode while Haley tutors Nathan and he tells her he cannot get into it.
THE BEST BITS: A DEBORAH SCOTT APPRECIATION SOCIETY.
This episode opens on a family therapy scene. Deb, Dan, and Nathan are all in the therapist's office, and the doctor asks questions about the relationships and dynamics between everyone, trying to paint a picture of the Scotts and to figure out why they are in her office. While Dan doesn't take the experience seriously and is vindictive and aggressive, both towards his wife and the doctor, and Nathan simply looks unbothered and bored, Dan is entirely involved in the process. She is a woman who wants to take care of her family and save it from the wreckage it is headed to, and if it takes uncomfortable therapy sessions, she will do it. She is level-headed, concise, clear, and mature, and manages to express her opinion without being mean towards her husband or using belittling words. She has a clear picture of where she wants her family to go and what she wants it to be, and she is determined to make it happen.
Throughout the years, many fans of the show have celebrated strong women portrayed in the Tree Hill universe, and Deborah Scott on season one is one of the most underrated ones. The class she exudes, the thought and effort she puts into it, and the deep love she shows for her only son are fantastic to watch. She steals the show in these scenes, and she is a marvelous woman- a true testament to the writing in the series.
THE LITTLE THINGS
- In the library scene, after Lucas asks Peyton if he can read while she draws because he doesn't get a lot of peace and quiet otherwise, he shows her the book he is reading: The Winter Of Our Discontent by John Steinbeck. It's the same novel he gave Brooke to read before they officially started dating. (On a side note, the concept of performing activities quietly side by side is my idea of a dream.)
- When Nathan and Haley are in the tutoring center, talking about The Little Prince, Nathan tells her he has watched the movie instead. At the time of writing, there were only two film adaptations of the French novel: a Lithuanian one from the 1960s, and a musical film released in the 1970s, both very unlikely to have been watched by a seventeen-year-old American boy in the early 2000s.
- We see Lucas send an email to his mother while she is in Italy, and the email address on the screen is "karen'[email protected]" Karen is not likely to receive anything with an apostrophe placed in the middle of her email address.
- The Travis album Peyton gives to Brooke, and then Brooke gives to Lucas, is their 2003 record entitled 12 Memories. "Tracks eight and eleven" are Love Will Come Through and Walking Down The Hill. The former is a love song including lines such as "So take me, don't leave me / Take me, don't leave me / Baby, love will come through / It's just waiting for you." The latter also deals with revealing feelings to someone and includes lines such as "Look into my heart, oh baby / Don't become a part of the past / You can be a part of the key" and "We're in love, make your peace / Wasting time is all you need."
THE MOST 2000s MOMENT
It could have been a detail as it is such a small part of the episode and irrelevant to the plot and, again, it revolves around the moment when Lucas emails his mother while she is away. Seeing the old Hotmail website layout, with the Times New Roman font and the grey and white boxes, as well as hearing the heavy sound of the keyboard keys, was a throwback of the highest order. Remember the times before we had flat and quieter keyboards? Truth be told, I love loud keyboards with thick keys. I think it stems from my love for typewriters.
NATHAN AND BASKETBALL: A COMPLICATED RELATIONSHIP
One of the main plot points and narratives in The Living Years is Nathan's relationship with basketball. From what is understood, he has been playing the game since he could walk and hold a ball, and he has always been part of a team of some sort, up until the varsity team in Tree Hill High. When practice was announced to be cancelled for the foreseeable future in 1x10, he was one of the only two players who sounded relieved. As we can see in this episode and in the way he seeks advice from Keith, who he has never had a relationship with, Nathan is trying to figure out who he is as a human being, as a young man, as a person, outside of being a talented basketball player who seems promised to a bright future.
A large part of his relationship with his father revolves around the sport too, as it is something that has been transmitted to him from Dan, who we know used to be a talented player in his youth, "maybe the best one" Coach Durham has ever known. Due to the way Dan acts towards his son, belittling him, his needs and ambitions, Nathan never feels allowed to exist out of his father's plans, and he is constantly worried he will never measure up, as he says towards the end: "I'm not sure I'll ever be the player you were." Nathan's inner turmoil is galaxies away from the typical "father relives his youth through athlete son and vicariously lives through son's exploits" trope we often see in teenage fiction and truly shows a young man's search for a sense of self and identity beyond what he has believed was his during his whole life. Nathan's questioning goes far beyond basketball in general. It is a battle most of us will have faced in our lifetime.
SELF-SACRIFICE.
This episode introduces us to a brand new character: Larry Sawyer, Peyton's father, who works on dredging boats and is often at sea. He was originally mentioned in 1x05, All That You Can't Leave Behind, when Peyton opens up to Lucas about the death of her mother and her family life. In this episode, he is in between jobs and is offered a long contract in New Zealand, which is on the other side of the planet from Tree Hill, North Carolina.
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to notice Peyton's despair at the idea of seeing her father go away for so long, it is written all over her face, and it is sprinkled all over her art, as Larry notices when he is installing her brand new webcam. What is evident too is the way Peyton never puts herself or her needs first, and she comes across as immensely selfless. She is in a lot of pain, she feels unbelievably lonely without her father, and she looks happier than ever to have him home. However, when he asks her whether she is okay with him taking the New Zealand contract, she doesn't say anything. She sacrifices herself and her feelings for him, because working helped him after his wife's passing, and simply because he loves his job, and she doesn't want to take something he loves away from him.
Peyton also evidently acts this way with the relationship between Brooke and Lucas. She evidently still has feelings for Lucas and would rather be the one he dates, but her best friend is happy, and it is more important to her than her own happiness and well-being. Never once she comes clean about how truly awful she feels, and instead lets Brooke experience the joy of being in a great relationship.
BROOKE, LUCAS, AND SELF-CONFIDENCE.
All throughout the first half of this season, cheerleader Brooke Davis has come across as unapologetically self-confident. She is attractive and she knows it, and she knows how to use her assets to seduce the boys she likes. However, now she is in a relationship with Lucas, her exterior comes falling apart, and we discover a whole new side of her. The first half of the season showed us a character that could be bitchy when she didn't get her way, definitely petty, and sex-obsessed, but Brooke in love is an entirely different person.
As she says towards the end of The Living Years, Lucas is the "first great guy" she's ever dated, and she "gives a rat's ass about him." She likes him, and she is emotionally invested in their relationship, which is why her hidden fears float back towards her surface. After she sees Lucas talk about books with Peyton's father, she finds herself feeling self-conscious. She doesn't feel like she has a lot to bring to the relationship whereas Lucas shares books he loves and music he likes- things he also happens to share with Peyton. This could also be seen as the start of Brooke thinking of redefining herself. Who is she when she is not a cheerleader, when she falls for someone, and when she has to go underneath the surface? She doesn't seem like she knows.
When she is talking to Peyton about her self-consciousness and the inadequacy she feels, Brooke says: "I think he's trying to get the best of both worlds (...) He uses you for some sort of intellectual/emotion thing, and me he just uses." If we exclude the part of me that believes her analysis is right, it shows that she needs to learn to trust herself more. She is more than an attractive girl, and she is more than just a body- she just doesn't know it yet, and she doesn't know how to bring the intellectual and emotional part of herself to the forefront.
FOR FUTURE REFERENCE
As we see Larry accepting a shorter contract that doesn't send him all the way to New Zealand, we can ask ourselves the question: are we going to see more of him? Does Peyton finally get to not live alone and have a constant father figure around?
About the Creator
Char
Sad songs, teen films, and a lot of thoughts.Tiny embroidery business person. Taylor Swift, Ru Paul's Drag Race, and pop-punk enthusiast.
Silver Screen Magic with Mae West
American actress and singer Mae West became a popular film actress during the Great Depression. She started entertaining in vaudeville, then performed on Broadway, and finally went to Hollywood. She signed up with Paramount Pictures and made her debut in the 1932 film “Night After Night.” She also starred in musicals, comedies, and crime dramas. The American Film Institute named her one of the best classic Hollywood actresses.
By Rasma Raisters5 days ago in Geeks
Federal Reinforcements and Rising Tension in Minneapolis
Tension in Minneapolis has risen sharply in recent days as the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) announced plans to deploy hundreds more immigration officers to Minnesota following the fatal shooting of a local woman by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent. The move comes amid nationwide protests and deepening polarization over federal immigration enforcement efforts. The decision to send additional officers was publicly confirmed by DHS Secretary Kristi Noem, who said the reinforcements are meant to “ensure the safety” of ICE and Border Patrol personnel already in the Minneapolis–St. Paul area. Officials noted that more than 2,000 federal officers have already been stationed in the region as part of what the administration describes as its largest immigration enforcement operation ever. What Sparked the Deployment? The deployment follows the Jan. 7 fatal shooting of 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good by an ICE officer during an enforcement action in south Minneapolis. Good, a mother of three, was struck and killed by gunfire as she sat in her vehicle. Federal authorities have characterized the incident as a defensive action, saying the driver’s conduct endangered officers. However, local political leaders and community members strongly dispute that narrative. Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey and other officials have criticized federal accounts of what happened, pointing to bystander videos that they say contradict the claim that Good posed an active threat when she was shot. They have also condemned the broader federal immigration operation in the city, saying it has fostered fear and mistrust in local communities. The legal and investigative aftermath remains complicated. Minnesota authorities sought to investigate the shooting, but federal officials asserted exclusive jurisdiction, citing constitutional protections for federal officers. This has deepened frustration among state leaders who want greater transparency and local involvement in the inquiry. Protests and Public Reaction The shooting ignited protests in Minneapolis almost immediately and spurred demonstrations across the country. Over the weekend following the incident, more than 1,000 rallies were organized in cities nationwide, drawing tens of thousands of participants. Protesters have framed their actions as a call for accountability and change in how immigration policy is enforced. In Minneapolis, large crowds gathered near the site where Good was killed to march and call for an end to what they see as an aggressive federal presence. Many protesters have chanted slogans critical of ICE and the broader administration’s immigration agenda. Scenes from protests have been varied. In some locations, demonstrators have remained peaceful, holding signs and vigils in memory of Good. In others, confrontations between some protesters and law enforcement have occurred, with reports of officers deploying crowd control tactics. Supporters of the federal response argue that a strong enforcement posture is necessary to uphold U.S. immigration laws and to address alleged crime tied to illegal immigration. DHS officials also stressed that the officers being sent to Minnesota are there to protect their federal personnel and keep operations running despite protests. The Broader Context of Immigration Enforcement This episode is part of a much larger national debate over immigration policy and enforcement tactics. The Trump administration’s recent focus on interior enforcement — including deportations and raids — has been a defining pillar of its second term. Minneapolis, a city with a diverse population and sizable immigrant communities, has become a focal point for that strategy. Critics say that such heavy federal deployment in city neighborhoods undermines community trust and disproportionately affects non-violent immigrants and long-standing residents. Advocates for immigrant rights argue that punitive tactics fuel fear, discourage cooperation with local authorities, and erode civil liberties. Supporters counter that rigorous enforcement is essential for national security and upholding the rule of law. They argue that federal agents must be backed by sufficient resources, especially when facing hostile demonstrations or resistance. Voices from Minneapolis Local sentiment in Minneapolis remains deeply divided. Many residents expressed grief and shock over the death of Renee Good, while also expressing concern about the scale and nature of the federal response. A number of community members have organized vigils, public gatherings, and faith-based services to provide mutual support and to call for justice. Conversely, Minneapolis leaders have urged calm while also criticizing federal policies they claim escalate tensions. Mayor Frey has been vocal in his rejection of the federal narrative, insisting that the city deserves transparency and a fair process to understand what led to Good’s death. Looking Ahead As hundreds more immigration officers make their way to Minneapolis, the city and the nation find themselves at a critical juncture in the ongoing debate about immigration enforcement. The coming days will likely see continued protests, political clashes, and legal challenges as both sides defend their interpretations of events and advocate for their visions of public safety and justice. For now, Minneapolis stands on edge — a city caught between federal authority and local calls for accountability, grieving a woman’s death, and questioning how far immigration enforcement can go before it deepens divisions even further.
By Saboor Brohi 6 days ago in Geeks
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.