Poets logo

Why?

By Lenora Altom

By Lindsey AltomPublished 10 months ago β€’ 2 min read
Top Story - April 2025
Why?
Photo by Caroline Hernandez on Unsplash

All I've ever wanted to know is why.

Just one simple question with an answer I'll never get.

Why am I different from my sisters?

Why do you love me differently?

I know you care, but it's not the same, and it never will be.

You give them your all.

I get what's left.

Why?

Did I do something?

Say something?

Am I too much like my daddy?

I've spent the majority of my life wondering why.

I've cried, I've screamed, I've wondered why you even brought me here if the one who gave me life didn't even want me.

I've learned over the years that my worth isn't found in you.

I have other people who love me, care for me, and are there for me in ways you never were and never will be.

Tell me why is it, though, that when you care for my sisters so deeply and it's something I've been through too, you weren't there for me.

Tell me, dear God, I want to know, why does it feel like you've sliced my heart open every time and poured salt straight into a fresh open wound?

A wound I swore I healed long ago.

Why won't this damn thing stay healed?

Comfort comes from knowing that my soul is loved by the Creator of the Universe.

I'm stronger than you and I'll keep going despite everything but damn if it doesn't still hurt.

I came from your womb, why am I treated like dirt?

Why am I treated as if I don't matter?

Why do your eyes light up when my sisters walk in the room, but they don't for me?

You think I don't notice, but I do. Everyone notices.

How many times have I questioned my worth because of you?

How many times have I wanted to die because I didn't think I needed to live if my mother didn't want me?

Too many...too damn many.

Why do I do this to myself?

Is it worth it?

No.

I can't seem to stop it, though, and I'm tired of fighting myself and telling myself I should know better and expect this, so quit crying over her.

The little girl inside me needs to cry.

She has always wanted you and needed you.

She always will, no matter how many times you hurt her.

But I'm here to reparent myself and let her know she can count on me.

I'm here, and it's ok.

It's ok to cry.

It's ok to feel this pain over and over.

You don't have to apologize.

You have every right to ask why.

I'm sorry that there is no good answer to your question.

Your why will fall on deaf ears.

So, instead, we ask, why not be kind to that little girl?

She deserves to cry and ask why as many times as she wants.

FamilyFree VerseMental Healthheartbreak

About the Creator

Lindsey Altom

For me, writing runs in the blood. I've written songs, poems and short stories ever since I was a little girl. I mostly like to write about my life experiences mixed with a little fiction or just things that come off the top of my head!

Reader insights

Outstanding

Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!

Add your insights

Comments (12)

Sign in to comment
  • Narghiza Ergashova7 months ago

    "Totally agree!"

  • Tales by J.J.9 months ago

    Truly powerful.

  • I solidly relate to this very raw feeling, the salt in the wound-ouch over and over. I usually write from that pain and although I can be snarky, cynical and silly I, too, feel this little girl pain. Brilliantly expressed. Congratulations on your T.S.!

  • Babs Iverson9 months ago

    Melancholy and heartwrenching!!! Congratulations on your Top Story!!!

  • Adriana Wilder 9 months ago

    I honestly feel you. Nobody should have to go through this. I'm young and have potential, and your poem made me realize nobody is stopping me.

  • πŸŽ‰ Congrats on your Top Story! πŸ“°βœ¨ Super proud of youβ€”so well deserved! πŸ’ͺπŸ‘ Keep shining! 🌟😊

  • Rowan Finley 9 months ago

    Questions from the heart and soul. Great job!

  • Ann β˜•οΈ10 months ago

    "But I'm here to reparent myself and let her know she can count on me." - the resilience, love and care in this sentence is admirable and speak volumes ❀️ Sending love, Lindsey~ πŸ’•

  • Tim Carmichael10 months ago

    Sadly, many kids feel this pain. I understand it all too well coming from an abusive father.

  • Jay Kantor10 months ago

    Dear Lindsey - Glad to see you back in the VocalBucket. Dad constantly called me "Stupid" - don't know "Why?" But, he's absolutely the only one that ever did...! j.in.l.a.

  • Margaret Brennan10 months ago

    oh wow!! that's so heartbreaking. no one should experience that and your writing brings out so many emotions. great piece.

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

Β© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.