Journal logo

Unraveling the Mystery of Vermont's Bennington Triangle: A Legacy of Unsolved Disappearances

Why these cases remained unresolved

By KaizerPublished about a year ago 3 min read
Image from wikipedia

Nestled within the rugged terrain of southwestern Vermont lies a region steeped in eerie tales and unsolved mysteries. Known ominously as the Bennington Triangle, this area spanning 36 square miles of dense woodlands has gained notoriety for a series of baffling disappearances dating back to the mid-20th century. These inexplicable vanishing acts have left investigators and locals alike pondering whether foul play, natural elements, or something more mysterious lurks within these secluded forests.

The enigma began in 1945 with the disappearance of Middie Rivers, a seasoned woodsman who mysteriously vanished while guiding hunters through the forest. His disappearance set a precedent for a series of similar incidents that followed over the next several years, each one more confounding than the last.

Paula Jean Welden: The Trailblazer Lost

Perhaps the most famous case is that of Paula Jean Welden, a college sophomore who vanished in 1946 while hiking along the Long Trail near Bennington. Paula, described as an adventurous young woman, finished her shift at the cafeteria and set off for a hike after hitchhiking to the trailhead. She was last seen asking fellow hikers for directions, her departure marked by an optimism typical of a young woman eager to explore Vermont's scenic vistas. Despite extensive search efforts involving hundreds of volunteers and a temporary closure of her college, no trace of Paula was ever found.

The Ripple Effect: A Series of Mysterious Disappearances

In the years that followed, the Bennington Triangle claimed more victims: an elderly veteran who disappeared from a bus under peculiar circumstances, a young boy who vanished from his family's farm while wearing a distinctive red jacket, and a woman who disappeared while camping with her family. Each disappearance occurred under varying conditions, yet all shared the haunting characteristic of leaving behind no conclusive clues.

Speculation and Theories: Seeking Answers in the Shadows

Theories abound regarding these disappearances. Some speculate that the harsh and unpredictable weather of Vermont's mountains played a role, with sudden storms or temperature drops potentially disorienting the victims. Others suggest that natural hazards such as abandoned mine shafts or encounters with wildlife, including black bears prevalent in the area, could have been contributing factors.

Local lore has also entertained more supernatural explanations, drawing comparisons to the Bermuda Triangle due to the frequency and inexplicability of the disappearances. However, despite decades of speculation, no definitive answers have emerged, leaving families, investigators, and the community at large in a state of perpetual intrigue and unease.

Legacy and Exploration: The Modern-Day Bennington Triangle

Today, the Bennington Triangle continues to attract adventurers, hikers, and curious minds from afar, drawn by both the natural beauty of the Green Mountain National Forest and the enduring mystery that shrouds this secluded corner of Vermont. While the area has transformed from a mining and logging hub to a recreational haven, the shadow of its past lingers, reminding visitors of the enigmatic tales that have woven their way into local legend.

As visitors explore the trails and campsites of the Bennington Triangle, they tread upon ground that has witnessed inexplicable events—a place where the line between fact and folklore blurs. Whether driven by a thirst for adventure or a fascination with the unknown, those who venture here are met with a landscape that evokes both wonder and caution—a terrain that, for some, remains as enigmatic today as it did when the first whispers of disappearances began to echo through the forests nearly a century ago.

Conclusion: The Unanswered Questions

In the quiet solitude of Vermont's wilderness, the mysteries of the Bennington Triangle endure, leaving us to wonder: what secrets lie hidden within its depths, and will we ever uncover the truth behind its chilling legacy? Despite efforts to explain away the disappearances with logical theories, the allure of the Bennington Triangle persists—a testament to the enduring power of mystery in an age of answers.

History.com Editors. (2009, November 24). Paula Jean Welden vanishes in Bennington, Vermont. History. https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/paula-jean-welden-vanishes-in-bennington-vermont

Vermont Public Radio. (2020, August 31). The Bennington Triangle: Where people vanish into thin air. Vermont Edition. https://www.vpr.org/post/bennington-triangle-where-people-vanish-thin-air#stream/0

Wooster, D. R. (2006). Haunted northern New England. The History Press.

Glastenbury Historical Society. (n.d.). The Bennington Triangle. http://www.glastenburyhistory.org/benningtontriangle.html

Bennington Banner. (2020, December 1). The legend of the Bennington Triangle. Bennington Banner. https://www.benningtonbanner.com/local-news/the-legend-of-the-bennington-triangle/article_6b5844da-34b6-11eb-b6f6-8b62073c0a6f.html

These references provide a mix of historical accounts, local perspectives, and scholarly explorations of the mysterious disappearances in the Bennington Triangle.

fact or fiction

About the Creator

Kaizer

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.