Why Can't Anyone Dig Up This Buried Treasure? The Bizarre Mystery of Oak Island's Lost Treasure

The world is full of mysteries. What, if anything, is hidden inside Area 51? Why did McDonald’s think a terrifying clown was the right choice for a mascot? And most baffling of all, what on earth were they thinking when they made the final season of Game of Thrones?

But today’s enigma takes us beyond questionable TV finales and fast-food mascots into a mystery so perplexing that people have spent hundreds of years trying to solve it. It’s a tale of buried treasure, booby traps, and an unexpected twist that would make Indiana Jones take notes.

When it comes to treasure hunts, the hardest part is usually figuring out where to dig, right? But in this case, we already know where the treasure is—getting it out of the ground, however, is a whole other story. And for over two centuries, nobody has figured out how.

Hundreds, possibly thousands, of treasure hunters—including, randomly enough, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Errol Flynn, and John Wayne—have tried. Some have even died trying. But the treasure of Oak Island remains stubbornly out of reach. Why, you ask? Well, that’s going to take some explaining. So, grab a seat and settle in for one of the longest-running treasure hunts on earth: the Lost Treasure of Oak Island.

A Farm, A Depression, And A Pirate Legend

Our story begins in 1795 when a man named Daniel McGinnis was exploring Oak Island, a small, unassuming speck off the coast of Nova Scotia. McGinnis wasn’t looking for treasure—he was just trying to find a good spot to build a farm. But what he found was something far more exciting: an odd circular depression in the ground.

Like many men of his time, McGinnis had grown up hearing tales of buried pirate treasure, specifically the legend of Captain Kidd, who was said to have hidden a fortune worth two million pounds on an island somewhere east of Boston. Seeing that Oak Island was, in fact, east of Boston and the depression in the ground looked a bit too suspicious, McGinnis figured it was time to grab a shovel.

Digging Up Trouble

McGinnis returned the next day with a couple of friends, and the digging began. The ground was surprisingly soft, but about three meters down, they hit something hard—not treasure, but a solid oak plank. A few more meters down, they found another plank, and then another. They also noticed evidence of pick and shovel marks on the sides of the hole, meaning someone had dug and filled in this pit long before them.

Now, Oak Island is pretty remote, and there’s no reason anyone would dig such a massive hole unless they were trying to hide something valuable. The hunt for Captain Kidd’s lost treasure was officially on!

But after digging down 10 meters (the height of a three-story building!) with no treasure in sight and no more resources to go deeper, McGinnis and his friends had to abandon their search. Their pit—later named the Money Pit—was left as a mystery for the ages.

Enter The Onslow Group

Three years later, a group of 30 men from nearby Onslow decided to pick up where McGinnis left off. Armed with shovels and high hopes, they excavated the pit to a depth of 27 meters. Along the way, they uncovered wooden platforms at regular intervals and even found a stone inscribed with a cipher. When decoded, the stone supposedly read: "Ten feet below, two million pounds are buried."

Excited, the men prepared to unearth the treasure, only to return one morning to find the pit flooded. There’d been no rain, and yet the pit was suddenly underwater. Undeterred, they tried digging a second shaft next to the Money Pit, hoping to approach the treasure from the side. But that pit flooded too, and with no more funds, they gave up and went home.

The Mysterious Flood Traps

Why Can't Anyone Dig Up This Buried Treasure? You'll definitely enjoy this!

It would be another 50 years before another group tried their luck. In 1849, a company from Truro arrived with the intent of finally getting to the bottom of the Money Pit. They re-excavated both the original pit and the secondary shaft, only to face the same issue: flooding. But this time, they noticed something strange—the water in the pit was salty, and it rose and fell with the tide.

It turned out the Money Pit was connected to the ocean by a man-made flood tunnel, a clever booby trap designed to protect whatever treasure lay beneath. This discovery only fueled the hunt, as many believed such an elaborate defense must mean something valuable was hidden down there.

But despite the use of steam pumps, boring equipment, and divers, no one has been able to bypass the flood tunnels to this day. The treasure, if it exists, remains out of reach.

Modern-Day Treasure Hunters: The Lagina Brothers

Today, the hunt continues under the leadership of brothers Rick and Marty Lagina, whose search is documented in the History Channel’s long-running series, The Curse of Oak Island. Now in its ninth season, the show has followed their efforts to uncover the island’s secrets.

While the Lagina brothers have found plenty of interesting artifacts—coins, military gear, maritime relics, and even some jewelry—they have yet to find the fabled treasure. And with each passing year, the question becomes harder to ignore: What if there was never any treasure on Oak Island to begin with?

What If It’s All Just A Legend?

The story of Oak Island’s treasure is essentially a legend, and like most legends, the details are murky. McGinnis is said to have discovered the Money Pit in 1795, but the first written account of the event didn’t appear until 1857. And depending on who you ask, the story varies.

There’s also no solid proof that Captain Kidd ever buried treasure on Oak Island—or anywhere else, for that matter. In fact, the whole idea of pirates burying treasure is more fiction than fact, popularized by books like Treasure Island.

So, What’s The Truth?

Well, here’s the twist: Captain Kidd did bury treasure—just not on Oak Island. In 1699, he buried loot on Gardiner Island, about 500 miles south of Oak Island. And while that treasure was dug up and used as evidence against him during his trial, the fact that Kidd buried treasure once means we can’t completely rule out the possibility that he did so again, perhaps on Oak Island.

But if he did, why would he go through the trouble of digging a 30-meter booby-trapped pit to hide it? Wouldn’t a shallow hole have worked just as well?

In the end, we may never know if Oak Island hides a treasure trove or just a series of unfortunate holes. But one thing’s for sure: the mystery keeps digging itself deeper into the annals of history.