The Cheshire Cat: A Reflection of Alice’s Unconscious Mind

The Cheshire Cat has always been an enigmatic and curious character, but his role in American McGee's Alice and Alice: Madness Returns takes on a deeper psychological meaning. In these games, he isn’t merely a quirky, grinning guide but a manifestation of Alice's unconscious mind—her fears, doubts, and instincts given voice.

The Cat as Alice's Ally

In both games, the Cheshire Cat serves as a guide, leading Alice through her shattered Wonderland. He appears when she most needs him, offering riddles that seem nonsensical but are actually loaded with insight. This reflects how the unconscious mind often communicates—through dreams, symbols, and elusive patterns rather than direct, linear thoughts.

When the Cat speaks to Alice, he speaks to her instincts, embodying the part of her psyche that understands what her conscious mind denies. This can be seen most clearly in Alice: Madness Returns, where the Cat reminds her of the destruction she’s caused in Wonderland, as the real-world destruction of her own mind has lead to the Infernal Train’s rampage through Wonderland.

Similarly, when Alice faces the Red Queen near the end of the game, the Queen’s line “What you claim not to know is merely what you’ve denied” mirrors the Cat’s warnings that the destruction of Wonderland is directly related to Alice’s real-world suffering and ignorance. The directness of these statements force Alice to confront the parts of herself she has repressed—the trauma, guilt, and memories of the fire that destroyed her family, as well as the ignorance she has exhibited towards the suffering of other orphans at Houndsditch Home for Wayward Youth.

The Weight of His Words

Though he sometimes speaks in riddles, the weight of his words cannot be ignored. The Cat’s dialogue in this universe is full of cryptic wisdom, making him a mirror to the darker recesses of Alice’s psyche. His riddles, like the unconscious mind, require Alice to work through her confusion, just as one would with buried emotions or unresolved trauma. His tendency to shroud himself in mystery adds to this parallel—much like the unconscious itself, he is ever-present yet difficult to pin down or fully understand.

Same Character, Different Approach

In the first game, the Cat is whimsical and elusive, embodying the chaotic nature of Wonderland. He offers riddles, plays tricks, and acts as a detached observer of Alice's journey. But in Madness Returns, he has evolved into a more cynical, philosophical, and blunt figure. This shift reflects the change in Alice’s mental state; though deemed “socially sane” after ten years in Rutledge, her madness has deepened due to her current circumstances—mainly via the influence of Dr. Bumby—and the Cat, as her unconscious voice, has become more direct. He no longer dances around the truth but instead confronts her with it: the destruction of Wonderland is her doing. He is no longer content to let her deny reality.

His shift from whimsical to blunt also mirrors Alice’s progression from avoiding her trauma to facing it head-on. The Cat’s role is pivotal here, pushing Alice to confront the darkness she’s buried. His cynicism and wisdom act as the harsh truths we often suppress in our waking lives—truths that only come out when we’re ready to deal with them.

The Cat as Alice's Alter Ego

Interestingly, in the extra content of Madness Returns, Alice refers to the Cat as her “alter ego,” suggesting that he is more than just a guide. He represents her id—the inaccessible part of the psyche that contains our most basic instincts and desires. For Alice, this means the Cat embodies her desire to escape insanity, to claw her way back to normalcy even when it feels like everything is falling apart.

At the game’s end, when Wonderland has merged with London, the Cat’s claim to “our Wonderland” underscores this connection. He doesn’t just guide Alice through Wonderland; he claims ownership of it alongside her. This hints that he and Alice are one and the same, that her unconscious mind—the part of her that understands the madness and the trauma—holds as much power in Wonderland as her conscious self does.

Fear and Paralysis: The Final Lesson

One of the most profound lines the Cat delivers is, “If fear paralyzes you, we are lost.” This isn’t just a piece of advice for navigating Wonderland; it’s a reflection of Alice’s internal battle. Fear is paralyzing Alice, keeping her from fully confronting the trauma of her past. The Cat, as her unconscious mind, recognizes this paralysis and warns her that unless she faces her fear, she will be trapped in her madness forever—or worse, become a shell of what she once was.

In many ways, the Cheshire Cat is Alice’s internal compass, guiding her toward self-awareness and urging her to face the darkest parts of herself. He’s the voice in her head that can’t be ignored—the one that nudges her toward healing, even if it means facing the pain she’s tried so hard to bury.

~*~