Geeks logo

The Challenge 10 Best Male Challengers 5-1

Jordan, CT, or Bananas? Who will be #1?

By Dylan DeckardPublished 8 months ago 4 min read
Jordan and Bananas / Photo by MTV

I recently made my list of the 10 best female competitors ever on The Challenge. It only made sense for me to make a list of the top 10 male competitors next. This list is a little harder because there are so many male challengers with at least two championships. I know this list will irritate some people too but hopefully everyone understands where I'm coming from.

Here is list 10-6:

      5. Darrell Taylor

        Original Show - Road Rules: Campus Crawl

        Daily Wins: 38 (Flagship) 4 (All-Stars) 1 (World Tournament)

        Elimination Record: 7-5 (Flagship) 1-1 (All-Stars) 1-1 (World Tournament)

        Seasons: 11

          • The Gauntlet (1ST PLACE)
          • The Inferno (1ST PLACE)
          • The Inferno II (1ST PLACE)
          • Fresh Meat (1ST PLACE)
          • The Ruins - DQ Fighting
          • Fresh Meat II
          • Invasion of the Champions
          • Dirty 30
          • Double Agents
          • Ride or Dies
          • Battle of the Era's

          Spin-Offs: 4

          • All-Stars 1 (2nd)
          • All-Stars 2 (2nd)
          • All-Stars 3
          • World Championship

          Challenge Championships: 4

          • The Gauntlet
          • The Inferno
          • The Inferno II
          • Fresh Meat

          Darrell has 4 Challenge Champions and was #1 on this list at one times. Since then he hasn't done anything great. He was disqualified on The Ruins for punching Brad Fiorenza in the face. He was then eliminated 6 seasons in a row. He was close on two seasons of all-stars which might have helped if he would have won.

4. Landon Lueck

Landon / Photo by MTV

Original Show - The Real World: Philadelphia

Daily Wins: 24

Elimination Record: 5-1

Seasons: 4

  • The Inferno II (1ST PLACE)
  • The Gauntlet II (1ST PLACE)
  • The Duel II
  • Fresh Meat II (1ST PLACE)

Challenge Championships: 3

  • The Inferno II
  • The Gauntlet II
  • Fresh Meat II

Landon might be the most efficient challenger of all-time. He has a 75% winning percentage which is pretty good. The only loss he has was on The Duel II and that seemed like a fluke win for Brad Fiorenza. Landon could have kept going and had at least 10 championships by now.

3. Chris "CT" Tamburello

CT / Photo by MTV

Original Show - The Real World: Paris

Daily Wins: 56

Elimination Record: 6-6

Seasons: 20

  • The Inferno (2nd)
  • The Inferno II (2nd)
  • The Duel
  • The Inferno III - DQ Fighting
  • The Gauntlet III (2nd)
  • The Duel II - DQ Fighting
  • Rivals
  • Exes (2nd)
  • Rivals II (1ST PLACE)
  • Free Agents
  • Exes II - Partner Medical
  • Invasion of the Champions (1ST PLACE)
  • Dirty 30 (3rd)
  • Final Reckoning
  • War of the Worlds
  • War of the Worlds II (1ST PLACE)
  • Total Madness
  • Double Agents (1ST PLACE)
  • Spies, Lies, & Allies (1ST PLACE)
  • Battle of the Era's

Challenge Championships: 5

  • Rivals II
  • Invasion of the Champions
  • War of the Worlds II
  • Double Agents
  • Spies, Lies, & Allies

I will definitely listen to an argument that CT should be #1. The only issue is that he only has 5 wins and the cast let him skate to the end on Double Agents and Spies, Lies, & Allies. If CT would have won a couple in the beginning when he was a hot head he would be #1.

2. Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio

Johnny Bananas / Photo by MTV

Original Show - The Real World: Key West

Daily Wins: 70 (Flagship) 3 (World Tournament)

Elimination Record: 15-14 (Flagship) 1-1. (World Tournament)

Seasons: 22

  • The Duel
  • The Inferno III (2nd)
  • The Gauntlet III
  • The Island (1ST PLACE)
  • The Ruins (1ST PLACE)
  • Cutthroat
  • Rivals (1ST PLACE)
  • Exes (1ST PLACE)
  • Rivals II (2nd)
  • Free Agents (1ST PLACE)
  • Exes II
  • Bloodlines
  • Rivals III (1ST PLACE)
  • Invasion of the Champions
  • Dirty 30
  • Vendettas
  • Final Reckoning
  • War of the Worlds
  • War of the Worlds II
  • Total Madness (1ST PLACE)
  • Ride or Dies (2nd)
  • Battle of the Era's (3rd)

Spin-Offs: 2

  • World Tournament
  • USA 2 (3rd)

Challenge Championships: 7

  • The Island
  • The Ruins
  • Rivals
  • Exes
  • Free Agents
  • Rivals III
  • Total Madness

Johnny Bananas has the most Challenge Championships out of anyone in the history of the show with 7. I thought long and hard about putting him at #1 but there are so many seasons where he leaves early. 7 Championships is great and all but it's been 22 seasons. He doesn't have the winning rate that #1 on this list has.

1. Jordan Wiseley

Jordan / Photo by MTV

Original Show - The Real World: Portland

Daily Wins: 29 (Flagship) 0 (All-Stars) 1 (World Tournament)

Elimination Record: 10-5 (Flagship) 1-1 (All-Stars) 1-0 (World Tournament)

Seasons: 8

  • Rivals II (3rd)
  • Free Agents
  • Exes II (1ST PLACE)
  • Dirty 30 (1ST PLACE)
  • War of the Worlds II (1ST PLACE)
  • Total Madness
  • Ride or Dies (3rd)
  • Battle of the Era's (1ST PLACE)

Spin-Offs: 2

  • All-Stars 3
  • World Championship (1ST PLACE)

Challenge Championships: 5

  • Exes II
  • Dirty 30
  • War of the Worlds II
  • World Championship
  • Battle of the Era's

Jordan Wiseley is the best challenger of all-time. He has done 8 seasons of the flagship and won 50% of them. He made the final in 2 of the others and probably would have won if he had a different partner. I think Jordan will start taking more and more seasons off and there's a good chance he retires all together. In that case there is a chance someone could pass him for the #1 spot.

celebritiespop culturesocial mediatventertainment

About the Creator

Dylan Deckard

Chillin with Dylan Podcast on all podcast platforms.

Charleston, South Carolina

@thedylandeckard on Instagram

@dylan.deckard on TikTok

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.