Fantasy Cast for The Challenge All-Stars: Real World vs Road Rules vs Are You The One vs Fresh Meat

The Challenge: All-Stars finally had a themed season on season 5 with Rivals. They should continue that tradition. The original shows for this frnachise was Real World and Road Rules. They eventually brought Fresh Meat in as a theme for one of the seasons for The Challenge. This season would bring some of the MTV shows together to see who is the best.

Team Real World

Jonna Mannion

Original Show - The Real World: Cancun

Jonna is a two-time Challenge Champion of All-Stars winning All-Stars 2 and All-Stars 3. If there is a Real World team she needs to be on it. I'd love to see how she would perform on a team season.

Sarah Rice

Original Show - The Real World: Brooklyn

Sarah has finally said she will return for All-Stars. This theme would be perfect as she would have to work with other Real Worlders to get to the end. I'd love to see how she would play again after all of these years.

Marlon Williams

Original Show - The Real World: Portland

Marlon was on Rivals II and got 3rd place with Jordan Wiseley. Jordan has went onto win 5 seasons of The Challenge but Marlon hasn't been since. This would be another perfect season for a return. I really don't know how Marlon would be on a new season.

Landon Lueck

Original Show - The Real World: Philadelphia

Mark Long is pulling out a bunch of big names for this season since All-Stars is on the brink of being cancelled. Why not Landon then? Landon is the one of the best male challengers of all-time and could win this season too.

Team Road Rules

Susie Meister

Original Show - Road Rules: Down Under

If we're getting Sarah back it only makes sense that we get Susie back too. These two are best friends and would definitely play together. I wonder if they could both get to the end on different teams like they did on The Ruins.

Katie Doyle (née Cooley)

Original Show - Road Rules: The Quest

Katie has been on a few different seasons of All-Stars but she's iconic so she deserves a call for this season too. She would be in her element with other Road Rulers but I don't know if that comfortability would transfer to success.

Shane Landrum

Original Show - Road Rules: Campus Crawl

Shane came back for All-Stars: Rivals and got all the way to 2nd place with Da'Vonne Rogers. Shane deserves to be on the flagship and all-stars as he made great TV and made it far on the show.

Darrell Taylor

Original Show - Road Rules: Campus Crawl

Another Campus Crawl cast member. Darrell and Shane got into it back in the day but made up on Invasion of the Champions. He would instantly make this team one of the teams to beat but how he would be against Landon Lueck.

Team Are You The One?

Amanda Garcia

Original Show - Are You The One? 3

Amanda is must see TV and that's why they always cast her. This season with other Are You The One? members would be perfect ofr her because she would have people to protect her.

Kam Williams

Original Show - Are You The One? 5

Kam is a beast who has been documenting her journey back to Challenge shape as she has had 2 kids. Kam would make this team an instant threat. People are threatened by her and how she runs the game but also how she can back it up.

Hunter Barfield

Original Show - Are You The One? 3

Hunter hasn't been seen since War of the Worlds where he made the final. This was after winning Final Reckoning but not getting any money since Ashley Mitchell took the whole $1,000,000 for herself. This might be the first season Hunter gets money.

Dario Medrano

Original Show - Are You The One? 2

Dario impressed me on All-Stars: Rivals. He won an elimination and got into some arguments. I think that deserves another call. He would probably be the most boring personality on All-Stars which says a lot to who is on this team but that might get him to the end.

Team Fresh Meat

Cara Maria Sorbello

Original Show - The Challenge: Fresh Meat II

Cara Maria is the face of Fresh Meat. Forget that. Cara Maria is the face of The Challenge. She was on a Fresh Meat team once before on Battle of the Seasons II and they were taken out so quickly. This team might be able to change that though.

Theresa Jones (nèe Gonzalez)

Original Show - The Challenge: Fresh Meat II

Theresa was last seen on Double Agents but before it was a long time and it was Exes II. Theresa brings it every season and knows how to get people to watch. I don't know how she would get along with Cara Maria after all these years but it would be great to watch.

Brandon Nelson

Original Show - The Challenge: Fresh Meat II

Brandon was last on The Challenge: Battle of the Era's but was taken out first. I think he could make it sneaky far on this season especially with all of the bigger personalities.

Ryan Kehoe

Original Show - The Challenge: Fresh Meat

Ryan needs to be on this season. His ex-boyfriend, Shane Landrum, is also here and that would be fantastic to watch. I'm not sure if they get along now or not but anytime exes are brought back on a season.