Amy (1981): Disney’s Surprising Grown-Up Drama About Teaching the Deaf

Amy (1981) sits in a peculiar corner of Disney history. Most people think of the studio as a purveyor of cartoons, fairy tales, and family comedies, but here’s a twist: Disney took a quiet, earnest television drama about a woman teaching speech to deaf children and released it in theaters. Originally titled Amy on the Lips, the movie caught the attention of Walt Disney Productions executives, who felt the story was “so powerful” it deserved a wider audience. That decision alone makes the film a fascinating footnote in the studio’s output — a grown-up story in a catalog better known for child-friendly fare.

What's Amy About?

Set in 1913, the film stars Jenny Agutter as Amy Medford, a woman who leaves a controlling marriage after the death of her deaf son. Seeking purpose, she takes a position teaching speech to deaf children at a rural school. The story explores the tension between early-20th-century educational ideals and the ethical questions surrounding oral instruction for deaf students. Amy believes children can be taught to speak, while some faculty favor sign language and challenge the notion of forcing children into speech. This central conflict gives the film moral depth, even if some moments lean sentimental.

Disney's Unusual Decision

Disney’s decision to release Amy theatrically via Buena Vista was unusual for several reasons. First, it was a made-for-TV movie, not a traditional studio production. Second, it tackled adult themes — disability, personal loss, and social reform — that didn’t fit Disney’s standard fare. The studio had a long-standing connection to educational programming, and sequences from Amy were later excerpted for classroom use under Disney Educational Services. Still, the theatrical release signals that the studio believed in the story’s emotional and prestige potential, offering a rare grown-up experiment for audiences accustomed to Disney’s family-focused brand.

Real Deaf Students Co-Starred in Amy

The production included real students from the California School for the Deaf in Riverside, lending authenticity to the performances. Nanette Fabray, who herself had hearing loss, consulted on the project, and the cast and crew aimed to represent the students’ experiences with sensitivity — though by modern standards, the narrative still centers largely on Amy’s perspective rather than the children’s. Contemporary critics noted the film’s occasional sentimentality and melodramatic score, but Agutter’s performance, combined with the studio’s unusual backing of a story about service, independence, and female agency, makes the movie a unique artifact of its time.

A Historical Curiosity

For today’s viewers, Amy functions less as a masterpiece and more as a historical curiosity: a Disney film straddling TV and theatrical distribution, education and melodrama, family branding and grown-up subject matter. It received modest theatrical attention in 1981, later appeared on home video, and is now available as a manufactured-on-demand DVD. While it may not thrill viewers expecting horror or high adventure, the film rewards those interested in studio history, early disability representation in film, and Jenny Agutter’s eclectic career.

What Hooks Audiences Today About Amy?

Ultimately, the hook for modern audiences is simple: Disney, usually safe and predictable, released a quiet adult drama about teaching deaf children to speak — a story both earnest and slightly out of step with the studio’s image. Pair that with Agutter’s natural, understated charm, and Amy becomes a small but fascinating window into a side of Disney rarely seen in 1981 — or anywhere else.

Subscribe to Movies of the 80s here on Vocal and on our YouTube channel. We are doing daily videos and written pieces on every 80s movie we can get our hands on. We love the movies of the 80s and are eager to share that love with you.