Geeks logo

10 Times Rotten Tomatoes And I Disagreed

We've all been there... A new movie comes out, and we look up a review to decide whether it's worth the money. While I tend to trust Rotten Tomatoes' scores, there have been plenty of times I found Rotten Tomatoes got it terribly wrong. Let me know what you think!

By Madison "Maddy" NewtonPublished about 2 hours ago Updated 7 minutes ago 3 min read

***Disclaimer***

I will be ranking these movies in the following manner: The greater the divide between Rotten Tomatoes and I, the higher up on the list (and I am referring to the critic's score, not the audience score). I will also show Rotten Tomatoes' score on each one in addition to my score. I am curious to know what everyone thinks, please let me know in the comments below!

#1 - Brother Bear (70%)

This divide has always bothered me... It is criminal. Brother Bear is a spectacular film with a great message, and this Rotten Tomatoes score simply does not do it justice.

#2 - Divergent (70%)

I have never understood the hate toward Divergent, I have always considered this a solid film. And no, it is not just a Hunger Games rip off. Every time this movie was on TV, my family and I would sit down and watch. Though it is nice to see the audience score reflect my thoughts on this film, it definitely deserves more love.

#3 - The Pebble and the Penguin (60%)

A little cringey at times, but The Pebble and the Penguin is a beautifully animated film with some great music. A score in the 30s is ridiculous. I always wanted to wear a beautiful flower accessory in my hair just like the one Marina wore in the film!

#4 - Atlantis: The Lost Empire (70%)

I have known for quite some time that the critic score for this was low, but I never realized the audience score was poor as well. What is this madness? Atlantis: The Lost Empire was one of my absolute favorite movies growing up. The film was exciting and action-packed, and its interpretation of what Atlantis might have looked like and what happened to it and its people I always found super interesting. A severely underrated movie that deserves more respect.

#5 - Alice in Wonderland (70%)

While Tim Burton is a little heavy-handed with the use of CGI in this film, from a storytelling and creative perspective, this is my favorite version of Alice in Wonderland I've seen. The characters are intriguing, the whimsical world Alice finds herself in is immersive and the tension we experience every time Helena Bonham Carter appears on screen is palpable. Sorry Rotten Tomatoes, can't agree with you here!

#6 - FernGully: The Last Rainforest (85%)

Another excellent film that while appreciated by critics and audiences to a certain degree, is not as widely respected as it should be. FernGully: The Last Rainforest is an amazing movie with a great message, it deserves at least an 80%!

#7 - The Road to El Dorado (65%)

Not a great movie, but a classic I appreciated as a kid and still enjoy as an adult. At least the audience score is fair.

#8 - Balto (70%)

The audience score is right on the money when it comes to Balto. Again, I have no idea how such a heartfelt, beautifully animated film can receive such an average score from critics!

#9 - Les Mis (85%)

This bothers me quite a bit, as I consider Les Mis my favorite musical and a wonderful film, even making my top 10 list. The fact that it only scored in the 70s on both sides doesn't compute. It features an amazing cast, great singing and a unique cinematography style that always moves me to tears. Rotten Tomatoes, Les Mis deserves better!

#10 - The Greatest Showman (70%)

This is nowhere close to my favorite movie or musical, but there is a reason the critic score is so low while the audience score is very high: The Greatest Showman is an objectively good movie. A feel-good, sweet story, great cast, incredible music... At least a 65% to a 70% is a no-brainer!

entertainmentfan fictionfeaturemoviereview

About the Creator

Madison "Maddy" Newton

I'm a Stony Brook University graduate and a communications coordinator for the NYS Assembly. Writing is one of my passions, and Vocal has been a great creative outlet for me.

Follow me on Instagram! https://www.instagram.com/madleenewt120/

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments (1)

Sign in to comment
  • Lamar Wigginsabout 2 hours ago

    I need to see some of these on your list, especially Ferngully. Meant to watch it years ago but never did. I did enjoy Atlantis and Divergent. Wonderful review, Maddy! Not sure why critics are so hard to please. They focus too much on nit-picking instead of enjoying the flick.

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.