Criminal logo

The Menendez Brothers

When Privilege Works Against You...

By Kendria WhitePublished 8 years ago 3 min read
The brothers' mugshots

I remember hearing about the Menendez brothers on the news and how I dismissed it because, in my head, they were white, rich and had killed their parents. It sounds like a Lifetime movie (and of course, it ended up being one...), right? I've watched documentaries and made for TV-movies, and every depiction showed jurors and lawyers smirking and saying how heartless these kids were because they were rich and lived this privileged life. The more I watch things regarding this whole case, even decades later, it's like...wow....

Everyone kept saying that they just wanted their parents' money because they were rich kids who wouldn't have survived on their own. People looked past the claims of abuse because they'd shot and killed their parents. I get that they lied to the police, but no one believed the claims of abuse. That happens. Abuse does happen, even in rich and famous Beverly Hills homes. As I write this now, I am watching a docuseries on the case and the mentality of everyone involved is....I am at a loss for words! There are people who were, and are still relieved, that the father was murdered. A mother who knew but didn't fight for her babies. A mother who was angered because SHE took part in conceiving these children and then looked around and got angry because now this is the life she has. A father hated by many forcing his son from a very young age to perform sexual acts on him...and these kids, now men, almost in their fifties will never see regular life again. On top of that, one brother claimed that the mother would molest him! Yes, some people have more, sometimes a lot more than others; it doesn't always mean they are undeserving.

I point out often to anyone who listen that we are individuals and that will mean that we all have different realities. Just because one assumes something doesn't make it true. The disadvantage to all of this was the fact that the jury is your "peers." These people had opinions so very similar to the people investigating the case. This was a lose/lose for the brothers. Despite the people who knew the true Jose Menendez, their accounts of the person he was, these guys were still treated as if they were as heartless as their father was always portrayed. The same goes for the people who knew "Kitty," the mother. She was no peach!

I follow true crime a lot. The first case I started following was the Manson trial. When I spoke out saying that Manson was merely a schizophrenic mastermind, people's heads exploded, but let's be real...did he physically kill anyone? Maybe, but was there proof? No! But there was so much proof that those girls did. He needed to be locked away in a psych ward, not prison.

Long story short, I just don't think that the brothers deserved the end that they are getting. It was honestly self-defense. I sort of feel the rage certain people felt about the O.J. trial. I laughed about that, I knew he would get away with that...I guess I had the attitude that the justice system had about the brothers. He was a star athlete with too many connections and was loved by the masses, there was no way he could've done this, right? Eric and Kyle Menendez had no case to win. The people had already decided that these kids had too much already and they would do everything in their willpower to snatch it away from them. It goes back to what I've said so often lately, people are so wrapped up around themselves that they forget to see the big picture. No, they didn't come right out and say they were abused; most abuse victims don't. I don't think it was an act. If they weren't as privileged as they were, would they be able to get their trial retried in the new millennium? It is a case that people are still talking about, hence the miniseries and the documentaries that are popping up all over the place. Why not take that into consideration?

celebrities

About the Creator

Kendria White

Fashion designer/fashion lover/image junkie/random break into dancer/child of the 80's/teen of the 90's/seer of sounds/listener of colors/sister/daughter/wife/bestie/auntieextraordinaire!

Reader insights

Nice work

Very well written. Keep up the good work!

Add your insights

Comments (1)

Sign in to comment
  • Joanna about a year ago

    Anyone who was of age, and followed has an opinion, we all saw the same thing, but as everything else we interpret things how we see them. I believe the boys were abused by dad, mom may or may not have, clearly she was aware, I believe it happened, possibly their whole life. I don't think that fact is deniable. So many are abused physically or sexually, these were not children, they were young men, I don't think they were prisoners, they had freedom, if the trauma was so severe, why not leave, get away, I think they stayed, and put up with with the horror partly fear, partly their life style. Self defense? I don't agree, they ambushed their parents, and some say over kill, and the obvious behavior after the murders. I say pissed off, tired of their pedifile parents, It may have been kill them before one or both does it again, I question self defense, my opinion is Lyle was the ring leader, he may have gotten the worse of the abuse, Erik would not have done it on his own, he was the follower, but they both participated in this gruesome act. Not every kid whose molested blows away their abusers, I don't think they were out of their minds, fighting for their lives, they were smart, involved in life, friends, and hobbies. It was a decision, planned, and executed. Why should they be released? My mom used to say, you can think whatever you want, say or do what you want in your thoughts, but don't you act on it, there's always consequences. I know times are changing, taking a life? Thats never ok, unless you are defending yourself in the moment. Murder is murder. So with all that being said, it's my opinion. I have watched the tv documentaries, made for tv movies, and done some reading, none of which has made think in anyway they are innocent, should be released, or were misjudged🫤

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.