The Circleville Letter Writer: A Mystery of Threats and Murder

The small town of Circleville, Ohio, might seem like an unlikely setting for a twisted mystery, but in the 1970s, it became the center of a bizarre and unsettling series of events that still captivates true crime enthusiasts today. The story of the “Circleville Letter Writer” is one filled with anonymous threats, a tragic murder, and a series of questions that remain unanswered.

It all began in 1976 when the first of many anonymous letters arrived in the mailbox of Mary Gilligan, a resident of Circleville. The letter, written in block letters, accused Mary of having an affair with a local man named Gordon Massie, who was married. The letter was threatening and explicit, accusing both Mary and Gordon of immoral behavior and warning Mary to stop the affair or face serious consequences. But what started as one letter would soon spiral into a terrifying pattern.

Soon, more letters began arriving, not just at Mary’s home, but to numerous other residents of Circleville. The letters were all eerily similar in tone and style — threatening, accusatory, and disturbing. They targeted various individuals in the community, with some being accused of infidelity, others of corruption, and some of criminal activity. The letter writer seemed to have intimate knowledge of the town’s private affairs, and the letters were designed to ruin lives and stir up trouble.

The situation escalated when the letters turned into a more dangerous and physical form of intimidation. In 1977, the first of what would become many bizarre and disturbing incidents occurred. Mary Gilligan, the original recipient of the letters, found a homemade, crude booby trap designed to harm her. The trap was set up near her home, and it was clear that someone wanted her hurt, or at least terrified.

Despite this, the letter writer’s identity remained elusive. Police and local authorities were baffled. Every attempt to trace the letters or the calls went cold. The mysterious writer even seemed to have a connection to the town’s politics, which led many to believe that this wasn’t just a random act of revenge but something much more deliberate, and potentially tied to local power struggles or long-standing grudges.

But things took an even darker turn in 1983 when the letter writer’s actions culminated in murder.

On the night of August 19, 1983, the body of a woman named Mary’s husband, Gordon Massie, was discovered in a car on a rural road just outside of Circleville. He had been shot in the head. The car, oddly, was positioned in a way that seemed to suggest it had been tampered with, and there was evidence that the shooter had known the victim well. The initial investigation revealed that Gordon had been the recipient of several of the mysterious letters, and the accusations within them had been centered around his affair with Mary.

The investigation into Gordon’s death quickly turned into a complex web of theories and suspicions. The police initially suspected that Mary had been involved in the crime, but they couldn’t find enough evidence to prove it. However, the most significant clue came when investigators found an odd, almost unbelievable connection: the Circleville letters had continued even after Gordon’s murder.

The authorities became convinced that someone in Circleville was using the letters to manipulate and control the residents, and they began to suspect that the killer was still out there, possibly continuing to send the letters. As time went on, however, the case seemed to stall. There was still no solid evidence, and the letter writer remained anonymous. It was as though the person behind the letters had disappeared into thin air.

Then, in 1984, a strange twist occurred that would cast suspicion on someone very close to the case. In what seemed like a turn of fate, a man named Paul Freshour, Mary’s former brother-in-law, was arrested. Paul was a local man who had been married to one of Mary’s sisters and had been living in Circleville for many years. He had also been a recipient of the mysterious letters, and investigators found that his handwriting matched the block lettering used by the Circleville letter writer.

Paul Freshour was charged with the attempted murder of Mary, after a letter sent to her indicated that the writer was threatening her life once again. However, despite the handwriting match, there were still doubts about his involvement in Gordon’s death, and Freshour maintained his innocence throughout the trial. In a shocking turn of events, Paul was convicted of attempted murder and sentenced to prison, though he consistently insisted that he was being framed.

It was only years later, in the early 1990s, that Paul was released from prison after new evidence surfaced. Despite this, the letters didn’t stop. The anonymous writer continued to send them sporadically, though they were never able to conclusively identify the culprit.

In the end, the identity of the Circleville Letter Writer remains a chilling mystery. Was Paul Freshour, a man who had long been a suspect, actually guilty? Or was he the victim of a conspiracy, a scapegoat in a much larger, darker plot? The disturbing letters, the unexplained murder of Gordon Massie, and the eerie trail of fear that spread through the small town of Circleville left a stain on its history. Even as the years have passed, no one has been able to definitively solve the case of the Circleville Letter Writer.

And so, Circleville’s dark chapter continues to haunt its residents, as the question lingers: who was behind the letters, and why did they do it? The twisted story of anonymous threats, attempted murder, and a life lost to a sinister plot still holds the town in its grip, unsolved and unresolved.

Thank you for reading!

If you find this piece interesting, please leave a heart, comment, or even subscribe! Your support means a lot to me!