Premium Gas Is Draining Your Wallet — Unless Your Engine Needs It

Have you ever wondered whether premium fuel could actually help your engine?

Fuels rated at 91–93 octane do resist detonation better than lower-octane fuels, and in some cases they can burn more completely. But does that mean your engine will run better, last longer, or get more power?

Not always — and in many cases, you’re wasting money.

As a Master Mechanic with 25 years of experience, I’ve seen this question misunderstood more than almost any other fuel topic. The real answer depends less on the fuel — and more on how your engine manages ignition timing.

________________________________________

The Key Player: The Knock Sensor

Modern vehicles use a device called a knock sensor (also called an anti-knock sensor). This sensor listens for abnormal vibrations inside the engine — the early signs of detonation, often described as:

• Knocking

• Pinging

• A “marbles in a can” sound

Beginning in 1996, all light-duty vehicles sold in the U.S. were required to meet EPA emissions standards monitored by OBD-II (On-Board Diagnostics, Generation 2) systems. That requirement made knock sensors standard equipment.

When knock is detected, the engine computer automatically adjusts ignition timing to protect the engine. Because of this, most modern engines are perfectly capable of running on regular 85–87 octane fuel without damage or performance loss.

________________________________________

So When DOES Higher Octane Help?

Let’s break it down by engine type.

________________________________________

1. Passenger Cars & Light-Duty Trucks

• Pre-1996 (especially carbureted engines):

Higher octane can help reduce knock and improve drivability.

• 1996 and newer:

If the manufacturer does not require premium fuel, using it offers no benefit. The knock sensor already does the job.

• Exception:

High-performance vehicles that explicitly require premium fuel (check in the owner’s manual or inside the fuel door).

*** If your owner’s manual doesn’t require premium, save your money.

________________________________________

2. Marine Outboard Engines

• Carbureted outboards can benefit from higher octane.

• Fuel-injected outboards may not — check manufacturer specs.

• High-performance marine engines often do require premium.

________________________________________

3. Inboard Marine Engines

• Older carbureted engines benefit from higher octane.

• Fuel-injected models usually do not, unless specified.

• If premium isn’t required, 87 octane is fine. (especially at dockside prices!)

________________________________________

4. Motorcycles

Most motorcycles benefit from higher octane fuel, especially:

• High-performance models

• Air-cooled or oil-cooled engines

• Engines that operate at higher RPMs

Many manufacturers recommend premium — and I agree.

________________________________________

5. Personal Watercraft

These engines operate under extreme conditions:

• High RPM

• Heavy loads

• Hot environments

Premium fuel is strongly recommended, especially for two-stroke engines.

⚠️ Tip: Never store two-stroke engines with fuel sitting in the carburetor — evaporated fuel leaves oil behind and gums up passages.

________________________________________

6. Portable Generators

• Usually carbureted

• Run fine on 87 octane

• Benefit from higher octane if stored for long periods

Higher octane fuel:

• Stores better

• Starts easier after sitting

• Helps engines run slightly cooler

________________________________________

7. Lawn Mowers

Air-cooled mower engines live hard lives:

• Heat

• Dust

• Constant load

They’ll run on regular fuel, but premium helps reduce heat stress and knock.

________________________________________

8. Weed Eaters & Trimmers (2- & 4-Stroke)

These small engines benefit greatly from higher octane:

• Tiny carburetor passages

• Long storage periods

• Extreme operating conditions

***Always run the carburetor completely dry before storage — especially on two-stroke engines.

________________________________________

The Bottom Line

• If your engine requires premium, use it.

• If it doesn’t, premium won’t help — and may just drain your wallet.

• Carbureted, air-cooled, or high-performance engines often benefit the most.

If you’re curious, try premium fuel for a few tanks and see how your engine responds — but always follow manufacturer recommendations first.