Humans logo

(Part 1) The Collapse of Duty: Reclaiming the Moral Order Between Men and Women

The Post-Marriage Paradox: When Love Becomes Lawless—Why Society Collapses When Duty Is No Longer Sacred

By Peter Thwing - Host of the FST PodcastPublished 2 months ago 6 min read
(Part 1) The Collapse of Duty: Reclaiming the Moral Order Between Men and Women
Photo by Eric Ward on Unsplash

For most of human history, marriage was not a lifestyle choice. It was a moral covenant. It bound man and woman to something higher than themselves, forming the foundation of family, community, and civilization. The vows were not about feelings, but about faithfulness. They were not written to protect comfort, but to produce character. And yet today, we live in a world where marriage has been emptied of its meaning, turned into a contract of convenience that can be broken “regardless of fault.”

This is the paradox of the modern age. People still crave love, but they no longer respect duty. They want intimacy without obligation, commitment without sacrifice, partnership without hierarchy. In the pursuit of freedom, they have built a culture that enslaves them to their own appetites.

The Death of the Covenant

Marriage used to mean permanence. It forced two people to grow beyond themselves. Now, it is a temporary alliance that survives only as long as it feels good. The system even rewards its collapse. Divorce is no longer shameful; it is often celebrated as liberation. Family courts punish men financially for the choices women make, even when those choices destroy the home. The child becomes a pawn in a moral vacuum where comfort replaces responsibility.

When the law removes fault from divorce, it also removes virtue from marriage. If there is no accountability for betrayal, there can be no meaning in promise. Marriage was never meant to be easy. It was meant to make us holy. By treating it as a contract of happiness, we turned a sacred bond into a financial risk that few rational men are willing to take.

And who can blame them? In the modern West, marriage offers almost no benefit to men. If he stays, he bears the cost of provision. If she leaves, he still bears the cost through the courts. The man who marries is expected to provide materially, emotionally, and spiritually, yet receives no protection for his sacrifice. A woman can end the covenant on a whim, and he will still be ordered to pay her for leaving.

This is not equality. It is moral absurdity.

The Economics of Broken Promises

Our laws incentivize failure. The promise of security has been replaced by a safety net that rewards irresponsibility. A woman who leaves her husband is often guaranteed financial support. A man who leaves is condemned as a coward. Child support is calculated as a percentage of his income, not based on the child’s actual needs, which means that the more he succeeds, the more he is punished.

Abortion follows the same moral logic. Women are told they have total control over whether a child is born, but men are told they have no say in the matter. Yet if the woman decides to give birth, the man is legally obligated to pay for a choice he was forbidden to make. The state has replaced moral order with moral contradiction.

When law divorces itself from truth, it ceases to be just. When society rewards immorality, immorality multiplies.

The Crisis of Masculine Purpose

A man cannot thrive without purpose, and purpose requires responsibility. But why would a man take on responsibility if society guarantees that it can be stripped from him at any time? Why build a life if another person can dismantle it through the stroke of a pen?

Men were created to provide, protect, and persevere. But the more society undermines their authority, the more it destroys their motivation. A man stripped of his respect becomes a man stripped of his will. He will still work, but not for his family. He will still survive, but not for a cause. He will become aimless, restless, and numb, seeking meaning in indulgence instead of legacy.

Women then look at these men and say, “Where have all the good men gone?” The answer is simple: they were never allowed to become men. They were told to be safe instead of strong, sensitive instead of steadfast, agreeable instead of grounded. They were raised by a system that teaches them to apologize for being masculine and rewards them for being passive.

A culture that mocks manhood cannot complain about the absence of men.

The Collapse of Mutual Duty

The tragedy is that men and women were designed to elevate one another. A man’s honor grows through a woman’s respect, and a woman’s security grows through a man’s honor. When one disappears, the other soon follows. Society has told women they owe men nothing, that independence is the new virtue. But independence without gratitude is pride, and pride is the seed of destruction.

Likewise, society has told men that women are unworthy of their protection, that masculinity is oppressive. But masculinity without direction is chaos, and chaos cannot build a family. The result is predictable: distrust, resentment, and loneliness. We are surrounded by people who crave connection but fear commitment, who want the fruit of covenant without the root of duty.

A relationship without duty is not love. It is a transaction.

Freedom Without Virtue

Modern society has mistaken liberation for progress. We tell ourselves that we are freer than ever, yet we are more anxious, more divided, and more spiritually bankrupt than at any point in history. Freedom without virtue always leads to slavery. When people are free to do anything but refuse to do what is right, they destroy themselves from within.

Marriage is the first and final test of this principle. It requires both man and woman to sacrifice their pride daily for something greater than themselves. That is why marriage produces maturity and why its absence produces perpetual adolescence. It forces men to grow up and women to grow wise. When that structure collapses, so does the culture that depends on it.

We are not living in a post-marriage society. We are living in a post-responsibility society. And the proof is everywhere.

The Hidden Cost of Liberation

Feminism promised women power. It delivered exhaustion. It told them they could “have it all” without sacrifice, and now millions are discovering that freedom without family feels empty. Many women hit their thirties or forties and realize they traded what they needed for what they were told they should want. They believed marriage could wait, that career was fulfillment, that family was optional. Now they find themselves lonely, resentful, and confused by their own unhappiness.

Men have suffered just as deeply, though in silence. They were told that if they just worked harder, achieved more, and provided better, they would earn love and respect. Instead, they are often discarded once they outlive their usefulness. Society tells men to sacrifice, but it never honors their sacrifice. It tells women to lead, but it never teaches them to respect leadership.

Both are victims of the same lie: that self-gratification can replace self-sacrifice.

The Moral Law Beneath It All

At the root of this crisis is not politics, but morality. Evil’s most effective strategy is not to make people hate truth, but to make them forget it. It convinces men and women alike that duty is oppression, that discipline is cruelty, and that freedom is the same as happiness. The result is chaos disguised as progress.

Every stable civilization has rested on one truth: order begins in the home. When homes are broken, the nation will soon follow. When marriages lose their meaning, society loses its memory. The decline of the West is not primarily economic or political. It is relational. We cannot rebuild our world until we rebuild our households, and we cannot rebuild our households until we restore duty to its rightful place.

The Way Back

The solution is not to return to the past but to return to principle. Marriage must once again be seen as a covenant before God, not a contract before the state. Men must reclaim the courage to lead, and women must rediscover the grace to respect. Children must be taught that freedom is not the right to do whatever you want, but the power to do what is right.

The restoration of marriage begins with a single word: duty. Not the duty imposed by law, but the duty born from love. The duty to protect, to respect, to forgive, and to endure. The duty that turns two selfish individuals into one selfless union.

---

A nation is only as strong as the promises its people keep.

adviceartbook reviewsbreakupscelebritiesdatingdivorcediyfact or fictionfamilyfeaturefriendshiphow tohumanityhumorinterviewlgbtqlistliteraturelovemarriagemovie reviewphotographypop cultureproduct reviewquotesreviewsatiresciencesinglesocial mediaStream of Consciousnesstraveltv reviewvintage

About the Creator

Peter Thwing - Host of the FST Podcast

Peter unites intellect, wisdom, curiosity, and empathy —

Writing at the crossroads of faith, philosophy, and freedom —

Confronting confusion with clarity —

Guiding readers toward courage, conviction, and renewal —

With love, grace, and truth.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.