Horror logo

A Tale of Horror and Survival

"The Stranger Behind the Door"

By D A R KPublished 8 months ago 4 min read


Barron, Wisconsin, was a peaceful small town of fewer than 4,000 residents, the kind of place where everyone knew each other and crime was rare. That peace was shattered on the night of October 15, 2018, when tragedy struck the Closs household in a way no one could have imagined.

At around 12:53 a.m., a 911 call came from the Closs residence. No one spoke on the line, but commotion and yelling could be heard. By the time deputies arrived, they found the front door kicked in and a horrifying scene inside: James Closs, 56, and Denise Closs, 46, had both been shot dead. Their 13-year-old daughter, Jayme Closs, was missing.

There was no sign of forced entry beyond the door, no fingerprints, no shell casings left behind. It seemed like a professional hit, but who would want to hurt a quiet, hardworking family?

The community rallied, holding vigils, fundraisers, and search parties. The FBI got involved. Billboards went up across the country with Jayme's face. For months, there were no credible leads. Theories ran wild — maybe it was someone from school, a stranger, or even a family acquaintance.

But the truth was far more chilling.


---

The Predator in Plain Sight

The man responsible was Jake Thomas Patterson, a 21-year-old from the nearby town of Gordon, Wisconsin. He had no criminal record, no online presence, and was barely noticed by his neighbors. He didn’t know the Closs family, had never met them, and had no prior connection — except one fateful day.

While driving to work at a cheese factory, Patterson stopped behind a school bus and saw Jayme Closs get on. In that fleeting moment, he decided he would take her. He didn’t know her name, her family, or anything about her life. He simply saw a girl and made a monstrous decision.

He spent days planning the kidnapping meticulously. He shaved his head to avoid leaving DNA, removed license plates from his car, and chose the time of night to strike. On October 15, armed with a shotgun, he approached the Closs house in the dark.

James Closs came to the door. Patterson shot him on sight. He then found Denise and Jayme hiding in the bathroom. Forcing Denise to duct-tape her daughter, he then murdered Denise in front of Jayme. He shoved the terrified 13-year-old into the trunk of his car and drove off.

Jayme Closs had just lost her parents and was now a captive of a complete stranger.


---

Eighty-Eight Days of Terror

Patterson brought Jayme to his remote, rundown cabin in the woods. He told her that if she tried to escape, something worse would happen. He kept her under his bed for hours or even a full day at a time, barricaded with weights and boxes so she couldn’t move. He’d play loud music to mask any noise. When guests came, he’d force her to hide silently, threatening her each time.

Despite the psychological torment, Jayme remained alert. She studied her surroundings, memorized details, and waited for a chance to escape.

Her opportunity came 88 days later, on January 10, 2019.

Patterson had left the house for a few hours, and for the first time, Jayme wasn’t locked up. Seizing her chance, she put on shoes that were too big for her and ran. She encountered a woman walking her dog — Jeanne Nutter, a social worker who immediately recognized Jayme and took her to a nearby home.

The call to 911 was electric: “I have Jayme Closs!” It was the break authorities and her family had been praying for.


---

Justice and Aftermath

Just minutes after Jayme’s escape, Patterson was pulled over and arrested. He confessed almost immediately, describing the murders and kidnapping in chilling detail.

He was charged with two counts of first-degree murder and one count of kidnapping. In May 2019, he pled guilty and was sentenced to two life sentences without parole, plus an additional 40 years.

The judge described his crime as “the most dangerous kind” — premeditated, calculated, and devoid of empathy.

Jayme Closs, meanwhile, became a symbol of strength. Despite her trauma, she was brave enough to escape and help bring her captor to justice.

Her statement at Patterson’s sentencing shook the courtroom:
“He thought that he could own me, but he was wrong. I was smarter. I watched his every move and I took back my freedom. I will not let him define who I am.”


---

Impact and Legacy

Jayme's case stunned the nation not only because of the brutality, but because of her resilience. Experts and law enforcement praised her courage and composure. Her escape remains one of the most remarkable stories of survival in modern American true crime.

The case also raised serious questions about how someone with no prior offenses could carry out such an elaborate, horrific act. It highlighted the randomness of some crimes and the need for vigilance even in small communities.

In the years since, Jayme has largely stayed out of the public eye, living with relatives and trying to heal. Her story has been featured in books, documentaries, and podcasts, but she has declined interviews, choosing privacy and peace over publicity.


---

Conclusion

The kidnapping of Jayme Closs is one of the most haunting true crime cases in American history. It’s a story of a cruel predator who planned a senseless act of violence — and a brave young girl who endured unspeakable terror but never gave up hope.

In a world where many true crime stories end in tragedy, Jayme’s tale is one of rare survival and triumph. Her courage not only saved her own life but brought justice to her family — and a small town forever changed by evil.

fictionfootagehalloweenmonsterpop culturesupernaturalmovie review

About the Creator

D A R K

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.