Why Can't Anyone Find This Mysterious Country? The Great Gregor McGregor's Poyais

If you happened to be living in London in May 1821, you would have witnessed something strange: a flurry of unseasonably late snow on the 27th. Considering it was almost summer, such miserable weather could easily dampen spirits. But what I’m about to tell you isn’t a weather forecast from two centuries ago. No, I’m actually using a technique known as pathetic fallacy. By attributing human emotions (in this case, misery) to non-human elements like the weather, we can reflect the gloomy feelings of the people of London.

But why, you might ask, were the people of London feeling so down? The answer lies in the aftermath of 20 years of conflict in continental Europe, including the Napoleonic Wars and the Battle of Waterloo. The British economy, much like the dreary weather, was depressed. For the privileged classes of early 19th century England, there was little to look forward to besides raising a few glasses of brandy at the coronation of King George IV in July 1821.

Enter General Gregor McGregor, an exotic character who arrived in town just in time to lift the gloom, at least temporarily. McGregor introduced himself as the “Cazique” or prince of a far-off land called Poyais, a bountiful paradise in Central America. The name may not ring a bell, but don’t worry, neither had anyone else heard of it.

According to McGregor, Poyais was a tropical utopia where the rivers sparkled with gold and silver, crops like maize could be harvested three times a year instead of twice, and hunting or fishing for just one day could provide a family with food for a week. As if that wasn’t enough, Poyais boasted a fully functional democracy, a civil service, a military, and a thriving capital city named Saint Joseph, complete with grand boulevards and an opera house. McGregor even claimed that his government was seeking investors for what he called “the opportunity of a lifetime.”

If this all sounds too good to be true, congratulations—you’re likely not from the 19th century. But back then, the world was far more innocent, and McGregor’s tale of paradise found plenty of believers. Hundreds of investors and settlers staked their fortunes on McGregor’s grand vision of an undiscovered utopia. Sadly, they would soon discover the harsh truth.

A Man Born for Deception

Before we dive into the details of this audacious scam, let’s rewind a bit and look at Gregor McGregor himself, the man who orchestrated one of the boldest cons in history. McGregor was born on Christmas Eve in 1786 to a distinguished Scottish family. His father was a sea captain in the East India Company, and his ancestors included notable military figures like Rob Roy, the legendary Scottish rebel.

With such a lineage, it was no surprise that young Gregor was drawn to military life. At the age of 16, he joined the British Army, but not in the way you might expect. His family purchased him an officer’s commission, a common practice at the time that allowed well-connected young men to skip the hard work and simply buy their way into positions of leadership.

Despite lacking real experience, McGregor quickly rose through the ranks, reaching the position of lieutenant within just a year. He seemed to be on the fast track to military and social success, and at 19, he married Maria Bowater, the daughter of an admiral. With his new wealth and connections, McGregor purchased yet another promotion—this time to the rank of captain.

But McGregor wasn’t satisfied with playing the traditional game of climbing military ranks. He wanted more—much more. After a brief stint in the army during the Peninsular War, McGregor left and tried to reinvent himself as a man of importance in Scottish high society. Claiming to be a decorated war hero, McGregor settled in Edinburgh. Unfortunately, the city didn’t buy his lies, and after being shunned by the elites, he and his wife returned to London.

Soon after, Maria passed away, leaving McGregor without his primary source of income. Desperate to maintain the lifestyle he’d become accustomed to, McGregor decided it was time to reinvent himself yet again—this time in the New World.

The Rise of a “Hero”

In the early 19th century, wars of independence were being fought all across South America, and McGregor saw an opportunity. He set sail for Venezuela, where he introduced himself to General Francisco de Miranda, one of the leaders of the rebellion against Spanish rule. Naturally, McGregor inflated his credentials, claiming to be a colonel in the British Army. Eager to welcome any experienced military leader, Miranda immediately gave him command of a cavalry battalion.

Despite his lack of true experience, McGregor did show some natural talent for leadership and bravery. He was promoted to brigadier general and married Josephina, the cousin of the legendary revolutionary Simon Bolivar. His marriage certainly helped his career as McGregor continued to rise in prominence, eventually becoming a general of division in the armies of Venezuela and New Granada.

One of his greatest military successes was leading a retreat across Venezuela, outsmarting two royalist armies in the process. This feat earned him fame and a reputation as a skilled leader. However, as the South American wars of independence dragged on, McGregor’s fortune began to wane, and by 1820, he was in need of yet another reinvention.

The Conman Prince of Poyais

Why Can't Anyone Find This Mysterious Country? You'll definitely enjoy this!

McGregor’s next move was nothing short of genius in its audacity. He sailed to the Mosquito Coast, a remote area along modern-day Honduras and Nicaragua. After some negotiations involving rum and trinkets, McGregor “purchased” 8 million acres of worthless land from the local ruler, King George Frederick Augustus. But where others saw jungle and inhospitable terrain, McGregor saw an opportunity to spin a grand narrative.

By the time McGregor returned to London in 1821, he had transformed himself into the “Prince of Poyais,” ruler of a tropical utopia. He claimed that Poyais was a land of unparalleled natural beauty and wealth, where gold and silver littered the riverbeds, crops grew in abundance, and the people lived in democratic harmony.

To pull off his scam, McGregor went all out. He opened “consulates” for Poyais across Britain, printed his own currency, created a flag, and even designed military uniforms for his imaginary army. He gave interviews to newspapers, hired singers to promote his fake kingdom, and wrote a guidebook under the pseudonym “Captain Thomas Strangeways,” complete with illustrations of this fantasy world.

It worked. Investors bought up Poyaisian government bonds and land shares in droves. Ordinary families sold everything they had to buy a piece of this so-called paradise, and many even exchanged their pounds for McGregor’s worthless Poyais dollars. Seven ships were commissioned to carry settlers to this non-existent land, and on September 10, 1822, the first group set sail on the Honduras Packet.

The Unraveling of a Dream

When the settlers arrived in Poyais two months later, they quickly realized that something was horribly wrong. There was no bustling capital city, no government officials to greet them, and certainly no fields of gold. Instead, they found nothing but dense jungle and a few scattered huts.

Despite the settlers’ best efforts to make the most of the situation, life in the Poyais colony soon turned into a nightmare. Torrential rains brought disease, and many of the settlers succumbed to illness. Violence and suicide became common as hopelessness set in. Eventually, a passing British ship rescued the few survivors, while the remaining ships bound for Poyais were intercepted by the Royal Navy or turned back after seeing the grim situation for themselves.

McGregor, however, was long gone. By the time the settlers arrived back in London, he had fled to Paris, where he incredibly tried the same scam on the French. He raised even more money before French authorities grew suspicious, leading to his arrest. But McGregor, ever the survivor, managed to get himself acquitted and returned to Britain, where he continued to sell land in Central America on a much smaller scale.

Legacy of the Conman Prince

In the end, McGregor never faced real punishment for his actions. He eventually retired to Venezuela, where he was celebrated as a hero of the country’s independence movement, living out his final years on a military pension. He died in 1845 and received a full military burial, never paying for the lives he ruined or the economic havoc he caused.

McGregor’s scam didn’t just destroy individual fortunes; it contributed to the stock market crash of 1825, known as the Panic, the first modern financial crisis. Twelve banks collapsed, and even the Bank of England came close to ruin, all because of a country that never existed.

Though Gregor McGregor has been dead for over 170 years, his legacy lives on. His story serves as a cautionary tale about the power of deception and the devastating consequences it can have on innocent lives.