The UNSOLVED Mystery of The Mary Celeste

Introduction

The Mary Celeste, often referred to as the quintessential ghost ship, remains one of the greatest maritime mysteries of all time. Found abandoned and adrift in the Atlantic Ocean on December 4, 1872, the brigantine was discovered without its crew, leaving behind a tale that has fascinated and puzzled historians, sailors, and mystery enthusiasts for over a century.

The Fateful Voyage

The Mary Celeste set sail from New York City on November 7, 1872, bound for Genoa, Italy. Commanded by Captain Benjamin Briggs, the vessel carried a cargo of 1,701 barrels of denatured alcohol. Onboard were Briggs, his wife Sarah, their two-year-old daughter Sophia, and seven crew members, making for a total of ten people.

Background of Captain Briggs and Crew

Captain Benjamin Briggs was an experienced and respected mariner with a reputation for being thorough and meticulous. Born into a seafaring family in Wareham, Massachusetts, Briggs was a devout Christian known for his temperance and dedication to duty. His wife, Sarah, and their young daughter, Sophia, accompanied him on this voyage, highlighting his confidence in the journey.

The crew comprised seven men, all handpicked by Briggs for their reliability and experience. First Mate Albert Richardson, Second Mate Andrew Gilling, and steward Edward Head were among the key crew members, each with years of maritime experience. The rest of the crew, including four seamen, were known for their competence and good conduct.

Discovery by the Dei Gratia

The British brigantine Dei Gratia, commanded by Captain David Morehouse, discovered the Mary Celeste in a state of disarray, yet seaworthy. The ship’s last entry in the log was dated ten days earlier, on November 25, near the Azores. Notably, the ship’s lifeboat was missing, suggesting the crew had abandoned the vessel in haste.

Condition of the Mary Celeste

Upon boarding the Mary Celeste, the crew of the Dei Gratia found the ship deserted but largely intact. The sails were partially set, and the ship appeared to be seaworthy. However, there were some odd details: the ship’s single lifeboat was missing, one of the pumps was disassembled, and a makeshift sounding rod was discovered on deck. The ship’s cargo, consisting of 1,701 barrels of denatured alcohol, was largely untouched, though nine barrels were empty. Personal belongings, including the crew’s valuables, remained undisturbed, and there were no signs of violence or a struggle.

Theories and Speculations

1. Alcohol Explosion Theory

One popular theory suggests that fumes from the denatured alcohol might have led to an explosion or the fear of one. Some researchers, like Dr. Andrea Sella from UCL, propose that a pressure wave from an explosion could have scared the crew into abandoning ship without causing a fire or significant damage.

According to this theory, the alcohol vapors could have seeped out of the barrels, creating a highly flammable atmosphere. A small spark or flame could have ignited the vapors, causing a minor explosion or a pressure wave. The crew, fearing a catastrophic explosion, might have hastily abandoned ship in the lifeboat, intending to return once the danger had passed. However, something might have gone wrong, preventing their return.

2. Seaquake Theory

Another plausible explanation is a seaquake, a type of underwater earthquake. Captain David Williams proposed that such an event could have caused the ship to jolt violently, leading the crew to believe the ship was about to sink or that it was damaged beyond repair.

A seaquake could have caused the Mary Celeste to lurch suddenly, dislodging cargo and creating a sense of imminent danger. The crew, already on edge from the strange occurrences, might have decided to abandon ship temporarily. The disassembled pump found on board suggests they were dealing with water ingress, which might have compounded their fears of sinking.

3. Faulty Instruments and Rough Seas

Documentarian Anne MacGregor suggested that a combination of rough seas, a faulty chronometer, and a clogged pump might have led Captain Briggs to misjudge the ship’s seaworthiness. Believing the ship was taking on more water than it was, and spotting land, Briggs might have decided to evacuate as a precaution.

MacGregor’s theory hinges on the idea that the ship’s chronometer was malfunctioning, leading Briggs to miscalculate their position. Rough seas and the clogged pump would have added to the sense of urgency, prompting a hasty evacuation. The crew might have believed they were closer to land than they were, planning to return once the situation stabilized.

4. Mutiny and Piracy

Speculation has also leaned towards mutiny or piracy. However, there was no evidence of violence or struggle, and the personal possessions of the crew and their valuables were untouched, making this theory less convincing.

Despite the lack of physical evidence, some theorists suggest that mutiny or piracy cannot be entirely ruled out. The crew might have staged a mutiny, forcing Captain Briggs and his family into the lifeboat. Alternatively, pirates might have taken the crew captive, though the lack of looting seems to contradict this scenario.

5. Natural and Supernatural Theories

More outlandish theories include the possibility of an attack by a giant squid or sea monster, alien abduction, or even a rogue wave sweeping the crew away. While these theories capture the imagination, they lack substantial evidence.

Giant Squid Attack

One of the more sensational theories involves an attack by a giant squid. This theory posits that a massive cephalopod could have snatched the crew off the deck, leading to their mysterious disappearance. While there are historical accounts of giant squid sightings, there is no concrete evidence to support this theory in the case of the Mary Celeste.

Alien Abduction

Another fringe theory suggests that the crew was abducted by aliens. Proponents of this theory argue that the sudden and unexplained disappearance of the crew fits the pattern of other alleged alien abductions. However, this theory remains purely speculative and lacks any scientific backing.

Rogue Wave

A more plausible natural explanation involves a rogue wave. These massive, unpredictable waves can appear without warning and are capable of sweeping crew members overboard. If a rogue wave had struck the Mary Celeste, it might have taken the crew by surprise, leaving no time to deploy lifeboats or issue a distress signal.

Investigative Efforts

Why Was this Huge Ship Found With Nobody On-Board? You'll definitely enjoy this!

Over the years, many have attempted to solve the mystery of the Mary Celeste. Notable efforts include:

Arthur Conan Doyle’s Fictional Account

The famous author penned a sensationalized account that popularized the mystery. In his story "J. Habakuk Jephson’s Statement," Doyle fictionalized the events, suggesting that the crew fell victim to foul play. This story, though purely fictional, captured the public’s imagination and cemented the Mary Celeste’s place in maritime lore.

Anne MacGregor’s Documentary

Using modern forensic techniques and historical weather data, MacGregor aimed to reconstruct the ship’s journey and possible reasons for abandonment. Her documentary, aired on the Smithsonian Channel, explored various theories, including the possibility of a faulty chronometer and a clogged pump, leading to the crew’s hasty evacuation.

Scientific and Historical Research

Experts have analyzed the ship’s logs, the condition of the vessel, and the historical context to piece together likely scenarios. Research has included examining weather patterns, seaquake activity, and the physical condition of the Mary Celeste at the time of its discovery. These efforts have provided valuable insights but no definitive answers.

The Aftermath

Salvage Hearings

The Dei Gratia crew brought the Mary Celeste to Gibraltar, where salvage hearings were conducted. The hearings, led by Frederick Solly-Flood, were lengthy and contentious. Solly-Flood was initially suspicious of foul play by the Dei Gratia crew, suspecting insurance fraud or collusion. However, no evidence was found to support these claims, and the Dei Gratia crew was eventually awarded salvage rights, though the amount was significantly less than expected.

Legacy and Cultural Impact

The Mary Celeste has left an indelible mark on popular culture. The mystery has inspired numerous books, films, and television shows. It has become a symbol of the unknown and the unexplained, capturing the imagination of generations.

The Ship’s Later Years

After its abandonment, the Mary Celeste changed hands several times, continuing to sail under different names and owners. Its final voyage ended in 1885 when it was deliberately wrecked off the coast of Haiti in an attempted insurance fraud scheme. The wreck was later discovered, and the Mary Celeste’s remains rest in obscurity, far from the limelight that once surrounded its name.

Conclusion

The Mary Celeste continues to intrigue and baffle to this day. Despite numerous theories, no definitive answer has been found. The story of this ghost ship remains a captivating mystery, embodying the enduring allure of the unknown in the maritime world.