Should There Be A Mummy 4 With Brendan Fraser Back As Rick O’Connell

Do We Actually Want A Mummy 4 Or Just The Feeling Of One

The question hits a nerve right away. Do we really want The Mummy 4 with Brendan Fraser back in the saddle, or do we just miss that late 90s adventure energy and project it onto the idea of a sequel

The Mummy from 1999 is not just another CGI monster movie. It sits in that sweet spot between Indiana Jones and a Saturday afternoon matinee. It is scary enough to be fun, funny enough to be charming, and grounded enough that you buy Brendan Fraser as a rough around the edges hero who can get knocked down and still crack a joke.

That mix is why people are still talking about the idea of a fourth film. Fraser is back in the movie magic spotlight after The Whale. The original movie has aged into cult classic status. The Tom Cruise reboot tried to turn The Mummy into a grim shared universe. This simply did not go Tom Cruise's way. So now everyone is looking back at the old O’Connell version and asking if it deserves one more shot.

We would like to hear from you, our readers. We do not want names. Just a feel for the temperature of the audience for this Mummy 4 movie. If you would like to engage, please share with us what your thoughts are about another Mummy movie here:

What Brendan Fraser Has Actually Said About Coming Back

Brendan Fraser has not been out there begging for The Mummy 4, but he also has not slammed the door shut. In interviews he has been pretty open about a few things. He loved playing Rick. He loved the tone of those movies. He also knows they took a real toll on his body.

Check out minute 4:35 is where Brendan Fraser jumps into how much fun he had playing O'Connell.

He has talked about being held together with tape and ice by the time the third film rolled around. Multiple surgeries, long recovery, the whole grind. He almost got choked out in the hanging scene. So if he comes back, it is not going to be as the same punch taking stunt machine from 1999. It would have to acknowledge his age, his history, and the fact that you cannot just reset the clock and pretend nothing happened.

At the same time, when people ask him directly if he would do another one, his answer has basically been that he would be open to it if the script was right and the movie remembered to be fun. That last part is important. He has also hinted that one of the reasons the Tom Cruise reboot did not land is because it forgot to be fun.

Where The Original Team And Studio Seem To Stand

Stephen Sommers, who directed the first two Mummy films, has always sounded nostalgic about that period. He cast Fraser because he could throw a punch, take a punch, and still be funny. That is the whole DNA of those movies.

The studio side is trickier. Universal already tried to resurrect The Mummy as the launchpad for a huge, shared monster universe and had to scrap the whole plan when that version flopped. That failure actually helps the Brendan Fraser camp. It proved that the name alone is not enough. People wanted that specific blend of adventure and pulp, not just any movie with sand and a sarcophagus.

Right now, the data that we are seeing, especially from the movies currently coming out is that they are still in. Nostalgia sequels and legacy reboots are still everywhere. Studios like IP that already has an audience. Streaming has made mid budget genre films viable again. If Universal thought a Fraser led Mummy 4 could land in that sweet spot between nostalgia trip and fresh adventure, the math would not scare them.

What Fans And Critics Are Saying Now

The fan side is the easiest to read. Scroll through social media or comment sections and you will see variations of the same thing. People miss that specific version of The Mummy. They quote lines. They share gifs of Rick and Evelyn. They talk about how the movie is comfort food.

There are fan polls and threads where The Mummy regularly shows up as one of the best adventure movies of its era. It has been reappraised by a lot of critics too. Reviews that once brushed it off as a lightweight blockbuster now appreciate that it knew exactly what it was doing. No heavy mythology, no grim self importance, just a fast moving story with practical effects and actors who look like they are actually having fun.

That modern critical affection helps any talk of a sequel. People are not embarrassed by The Mummy anymore. It is not a guilty pleasure. It is just a pleasure. That makes it easier to sell the idea of checking back in on these characters.

How A Mummy 4 With Fraser Could Work Today

If a fourth film happens, it should not try to make Fraser do 1999 level stunt work again. That is not realistic and not fair to him. The smart move would be to lean into where he is now. An older Rick O’Connell who has seen too much, maybe retired from tomb raiding, dragged back into one last nightmare when something he thought was buried comes back to haunt his family.

You could anchor the movie around a new generation of characters while still letting Fraser be the emotional core. Less dangling from nooses and more using his experience, his scars, and his connection to the past to drive the story. The action can still be big, but it does not all have to land on his spine and knees this time.

On tone, it would have to feel like The Mummy again. Sunlight, humor, pulp horror, practical style set pieces backed up by modern effects, not replaced by them. And it would need to stay away from the heavy-handed universe building that sank the Cruise reboot. One movie, one story, one cursed problem to solve.

So Should There Be A Mummy 4

Honestly, if the choice is between another dark reboot with no connection to the original cast, or one last ride with Brendan Fraser that respects his limits and the tone of the first films, the second option is the only one that makes sense.

Fans clearly still care. Critics have come around. Fraser is beloved again and finally getting the respect he always deserved. The risk is real. You can always break the magic by going back to the well one too many times. But if there is a careful script, a director who understands why people loved the 1999 movie, and a studio willing to make something fun instead of just building another franchise machine, a Mummy 4 with Brendan Fraser in it is at least worth wanting.

Thank you for reading this article. Flip The Movie Script is a small behind the scenes movie facts website. If you would like to find some really interesting movie facts, that are well sourced, please check out our Movie Facts hub where we link you to some really cool facts that we spill the full breakdown.