Geeks logo

Deadly Musical Fun at Greater Boston Stage Company with "Murder for Two"

“Murder for Two” is a unique take on the traditional mystery-detective stories.

By Marielle SabbagPublished 2 months ago 3 min read
(Left to Right) Will McGarrahan and Jared Troilo in Greater Boston Stage Company's "Murder for Two." Photo Credit to Nile Scott Studio.

Shall we figure out the next clue through the key of song?

Greater Boston Stage Company presents “Murder for Two,” a dark comedy musical. When the celebrated novelist Arthur Whitney is shot dead, it’s up to Marcus, a policeman, to put the pieces together to solve a murder case - through song.

Murder, comedy, and song! Who knew that you could mix these genres? Greater Boston Stage Company’s “Murder for Two” shows that you can do anything with theater magic. “Murder for Two” is a funny, clever, and unique take on the traditional mystery-detective stories. The show is packed with laughs, tunes, and twists that will make audiences gasp.

Will McGarrahan and Jared Troilo are a fantastic duo, and the pair worked well together, igniting chemistry. They are each witty, musically talented, and have an energetic bounce in their step. I love watching actors have fun performing. Every laugh or applause increased their energy, shining their love for theater.

Troilo plays Marcus, an eager and somewhat clumsy policeman. He is desperate to prove that he has what it takes to be a detective. Troilo brings charm, warmth, and depth to this role. His character, Marcus, has a genuine heart and pays attention to clues. He is a leader who never stops trying to fulfill his dreams.

Marcus has several suspects to question - a prima ballerina, a bickering married couple, an eccentric psychologist, and even a precocious twelve-year-old boy. Suspects are always an important part of the story, but what if they are all played by just one person?

Yes, actor Will McGarrahan puts his Jekyll-and-Hyde skills to the test and performs as multiple characters throughout the show. McGarrahan switches between voices, mannerisms, and even walks on his knees to act as a child. He is very funny in his many transitions and razor-sharp comebacks.

That’s why you should pay attention to every character change. I enjoy a good murder mystery, but I really like it when there’s a unique quality. McGarrahan’s one-man show and the musical score are a superb part of “Murder for Two.”

Speaking of music, McGarrahan and Troilo's live playing on the grand piano is outstanding. The twinkling chime of the musical keys echoes throughout the auditorium, and a few people in the audience were bopping their heads. The music is a focal point in the story, adding to the comical levity, musical duets, and revealing twists.

Scenic designer Katy Monthel created a dynamic murder mystery setting: A glowing picture frame outlines the stage, inviting audiences a look into the secrets, and within it sits a clever cutout of a home that makes it feel like a cozy setting. The actors transform the space as they search for (or hide) clues.

Tyler Rosati’s clever direction makes exceptional use of the characters, story, and stage. Rosati has a profound love for theater, which is evident in this joyful musical production of a murder case (see the irony?) He wanted audiences to laugh, and yes, there was a full wave of laughter in the theater. Hearing audience laughter is my favorite sound!

What’s important is that Rosati invites audiences to laugh with the show, not just at it. This is a distinct kind of murder mystery show that we don’t see enough of. Its moral insinuates that it’s okay to think outside the box, like in Marcus’s distinct police procedures.

“Murder for Two” is a charming musical that makes for an excellent time out in the theater. It’s ninety minutes with no intermission; It’s like a cabaret, only with murder involved! Don’t miss a chance to see this delightfully unique mystery, playing at the Greater Boston Stage Company until Nov. 9.

celebritiescomedyentertainmentpop culturereview

About the Creator

Marielle Sabbag

Writing has been my passion since I was 11 years old. I love creating stories from fiction, poetry, fanfiction. I enjoy writing movie reviews. I would love to become a creative writing teacher and leave the world inspiring minds.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.