The Disappearing Click and the New Rules of Being Found
Google’s new AI Overviews often answer questions directly on the search results page, reducing clicks to your site even if you hold the #1 spot. For local businesses, this can mean losing 15 to 30 percent of traffic overnight. The solution is AI Search Optimization to ensure Google’s AI cites your business in its answer.
The Day the Traffic Fell
It happened quietly.
One day, your website is humming along with leads, calls, and contact forms arriving like clockwork.
The next, something has shifted.
On a Wednesday morning in Tyler, Texas, Carla, a personal injury lawyer who had built her reputation on trust, results, and the security of a #1 Google ranking, opened her laptop.
Her analytics chart, once steady, now looked like the edge of a cliff.
Her reviews? Still five stars.
Her ads? Still running.
Her SEO report? Still #1 for “Tyler truck accident lawyer.”
She called her marketing consultant.
“Nothing’s broken,” he said. “You’re still number one.”
“Then,” she asked, “where did everybody go?”
When the Answer Arrives Before the Question Ends
Carla’s potential clients had not stopped searching for legal help. But in the spring of 2025, Google changed the way it answered them.
For twenty years, search worked like this:
- You typed in a question.
- Google gave you “ten blue links.”
- You clicked the most relevant one.
Now, with AI Overviews, the answer appears before you have even scanned the list.
The AI pulls from multiple sites, stitches the information together, and displays it in a confident paragraph above the results.
If your business is not mentioned in that paragraph, your hard‑earned #1 ranking might as well be invisible.
The Numbers Behind the Drop
The impact is not small.
- 34.5% drop in clicks to the top organic result when an AI Overview appears (Ahrefs)
- 15 to 30% declines in certain local service industries including law, plumbing, and wedding services (Search Engine Journal)
For businesses built on visibility, this is more than an SEO problem. It is a survival problem.
East Texas as a Test Case
Imagine someone in Longview searching for:
- Best personal injury lawyer in East Texas
- What to do after an 18 wheeler accident in Tyler
- How much is my truck accident case worth
A year ago, these searches meant a click to your site where your words, images, and trust signals could turn interest into a call.
Today, many of those answers live entirely in Google’s AI box.
If you are not in that box, the customer never sees you.
It is like showing up to the biggest networking event in town and being stuck in the hallway outside.
The New Game: AI Search Optimization
At Bailes + Zindler, we call this AI Search Optimization or Generative Engine Optimization (GEO).
Ranking is not enough. You have to become the source Google’s AI trusts enough to cite.
1. Knowing When You Appear
Audit your keywords. Do they trigger AI Overviews? Are you cited?
Our AI Search Optimization service includes tracking AI citation rates so you know exactly where you stand.
2. Writing for the Machine
Structure your content so AI can lift and display it:
- Use clear headings and short paragraphs
- Add FAQPage and LocalBusiness schema
- Write definition‑style answers and bullet points
Our SEO services include schema implementation and structured content strategies designed for AI extraction.
3. Owning Local Signals
Google’s AI relies heavily on Google Business Profiles, reviews, and consistent directory citations.
Weekly updates with fresh photos, offers, and hyperlocal posts make your profile a trusted source for AI.
4. Measuring the Right Metrics
Track more than rankings. Measure:
- AI citation rates
- Brand mentions in summaries
- Engagement from AI‑sourced visitors
Our East Texas SEO services are built to measure and improve these AI era performance signals.
Why Waiting Is a Losing Strategy
AI search is not going away. If you wait until your traffic drops 30%, the climb back is harder.
The winners will be those who appear twice, once in the AI box and again in the traditional results.
The last time Google made a change this big, during the mobile first indexing shift, early movers gained years of advantage.
Carla’s Climb Back
Carla adapted fast.
She added AI friendly content, implemented schema markup, and refreshed her local SEO strategy.
Two months later, her chart no longer looked like a ski slope.
It looked like a climb.
The Takeaway
In the AI Overview era, visibility is not just about ranking high. It is about being the voice the algorithm trusts enough to quote.
For East Texas businesses, that means thinking beyond the click and claiming your place inside the answer itself.
Start now with AI Search Optimization to make sure you are in the conversation when it matters most.
About the Creator
Bailes Zindler
Bailes Zindler helps businesses grow through high-converting websites, powerful SEO, and paid ads that deliver real ROI. Based in East Texas, we bring strategy, speed, and results to every digital move you make.
Keep reading
More stories from Bailes Zindler and writers in FYI and other communities.
From Flip Phones to Fluid Design: The Untold Story of Mobile Web Evolution
In the early 2000s, browsing the internet on a phone felt like decoding a riddle through a keyhole. Websites weren’t just slow—they were nearly unusable. Pages loaded agonizingly slow, navigation was a clunky afterthought, and the user experience was frustrating at best. Back then, mobile browsing was viewed as a niche—something for “on the go” or emergency use, far removed from the rich, interactive desktop experiences businesses carefully crafted.
By Bailes Zindler8 months ago in FYI
Comments
There are no comments for this story
Be the first to respond and start the conversation.