Backlash in CNC Machines: What It Is & How to Test for It

Backlash is a typical problem of CNC (Computer Numerical Control) machines that can cause considerable impact on accuracy and precision. It is an unsolicited little movement or clearance between machinery parts, for example, ball screws and lead screws, when the machine reverses direction. Backlash can cause dimensional errors, unsatisfactory surface finishes, and wasted material, leading to production cost wastes.

Based on industry statistics, backlash in CNC machines can vary from 0.001 to 0.01 inches based on machine type and maintenance regimes. Even small amounts of backlash can cause deviations and impact the precision machining applications' quality.

In this detailed guide, we will discuss:

• What backlash is and why it happens
• How backlash affects CNC machining
• How to effectively test to quantify backlash
• How to minimize or eliminate CNC machine backlash
• Preventive maintenance techniques to prevent backlash problems
• Improving machine components to reduce backlash

1. What is the Cause of Backlash in CNC Machines?

Backlash results from wear and mechanical gaps among drive elements. The most prevalent causes are:

1.1 Ball Screws and Lead Screws Wear and Tear

Ball screws and lead screws wear out over time because of continuous motion, causing gaps between the screw and nut.

• Lack of proper lubrication increases wear, thereby worsening backlash.
• Improper maintenance schedules result in excessive wear and premature backlash.

1.2 Incorrect Assembly or Installation of Machines

• Movement excess is created by loose linear rails, couplings, and bearings.
• Assembled machine components inaccurately result in gaps creating backlash.
• Wrong torque settings in fasteners allow system movement.

1.3 Thermal Expansion and Contraction

• Metal parts experience expansion and contraction due to varying temperatures, changing the system's tightness.
• This effect is greater in high-speed machining environments.
• Some CNC machines are fitted with thermal compensation systems to minimize backlash due to temperature changes.

1.4 Worn Bearings and Bushings

• Bearings and bushings that hold rotating elements wear out over time.
• Worn bearings cause play in the system, which increases backlash.
• Poor lubrication and contamination can hasten wear on these elements.

1.5 Belt-Driven vs. Direct-Drive Systems

• Belt-driven CNC machines are more likely to experience increased backlash with time due to belt wear and stretching.
• Direct drive eliminates belts and employs servo motors with precision feedback to minimize backlash.

2. Backlash Effects on CNC Machining

Backlash has a direct effect on machining accuracy and surface finish. Some of its most severe effects are:

2.1 Loss of Positional Accuracy

• If backlash gets beyond acceptable levels, the CNC machine cannot reposition to the right place, resulting in dimensional inaccuracies.
• It is particularly important for precision machining with high-tolerance applications, including aerospace and medical devices.
• It can produce rejected parts even with 0.002 inches of backlash in high-precision manufacturing.

2.2 Poor Surface Finish

• Backlash contributes to chatter and vibration, which result in rough or irregular surface finishes.
• It facilitates rework or scrap parts more likely.
• In CNC milling, backlash can lead to stair-stepping effects on contoured surfaces.

2.3 Inefficient Toolpath Execution

• CNC programs depend on exact movements. If there is backlash, there are toolpath deviations, decreasing efficiency and necessitating constant adjustments.
• In multi-axis machining, backlash can lead to synchronization errors between axes.

2.4 Increased Wear on Other Components

• Excessive backlash places extra load on motors, bearings, and linear guides, resulting in earlier wear and higher maintenance costs.
• With time, backlash can cause drive motor overheating and higher power consumption.

3. Testing for Backlash in CNC Machines

Accurate measurement of backlash is necessary to diagnose and solve the problem. The following methods are effective ones:

3.1 Dial Indicator Method

Tools Needed: Dial indicator, magnetic base

Procedure:

• Mount the dial indicator on a firm base close to the machine's moving part.
• Shift the axis in one direction and zero the dial indicator.
• Reverse the direction and note any deviation in the dial reading.
• The difference between the starting and ending readings is backlash.

Example: A CNC machine with 0.005 inches of backlash can be compensated for in the control system.

3.2 Laser Interferometry

• High-precision measuring method employed in high-end manufacturing shops.
• Measures small positional errors using laser reflections.
• Offers real-time feedback on machine motion deviations.

3.3 CNC Control Backlash Compensation Test

• Most CNC controllers include backlash compensation adjustments.
• Executing a programmed backlash test cycle can automatically diagnose and compensate for backlash.

4. Reducing or Eliminating Backlash

There are various mechanical and software modifications that can minimize backlash in CNC machines.

4.1 Ball Screw and Nut Adjustments

• Preloaded ball nuts can be tightened to minimize movement gaps.
• Double-nut systems installed eliminate backlash entirely.

4.2 Anti-Backlash Gears and Compensation Software

• Anti-backlash nuts provide tight control over lead screws.
• CNC controllers provide software backlash compensation, dynamically correcting for lost motion.

4.3 Going Direct-Drive with Motors

• Belt-driven systems are less likely to be backlash-prone.
• Direct-drive servo motors do away with mechanical gaps.

4.4 Regular Maintenance and Lubrication

• Ball screws, bearings, and linear rails are properly lubricated, which minimizes wear and backlash.
• Monthly precision checks made ensure long-term accuracy.

5. Best Practices Preventing Backlash

Prevention of backlash involves a mix of correct machine setup, regular maintenance, and quality components. The following is a preventive checklist:

• Adjust and check ball screws: Monthly
• Lubricate moving parts: Weekly
• Check bearings and bushings: Bi-annually
• Calibrate backlash compensation settings: Quarterly
• Replace worn nuts and couplings: As needed

Industry statistics indicate that well-maintained CNC machines have 30-50% less backlash than poorly maintained ones.

6. Conclusion

Backlash on CNC machines is an unavoidable circumstance, but backlash can be prevented or eliminated using proper testing, adjustment, and preventive maintenance. Periodic checking for backlash, making precise mechanical adjustments, and applying software compensation can reduce backlash and enhance the accuracy of a machine considerably.

For high-precision CNC machining businesses, backlash control is important to sustain product quality and minimize waste. Spending on good-quality components and frequent maintenance will help extend the life of machines and enhance machining efficiency.

Looking for a Reliable Used CNC Machine?

At MachineStation, we offer a wide range of high-quality pre-owned CNC machines that are thoroughly inspected for performance and accuracy. Contact us today to find a machine that fits your needs!