Fiction logo

The Cost of Cake

Best in Town

By ChelceyPublished 5 years ago Updated 4 years ago 3 min read

Her spatula finished the final spread of pink frosting along the edge of the cake before stepping back to examine her work. Satisfaction filled her at the sight of the perfectly frosted two tiered cake.

"Absolutely perfect," she complemented herself as she began lining the tiers with fresh tulips, pink to be specific per the bride's request. Her mind pulled to the memory of the brides voice carrying into the kitchen - pink, pink, pink! I want everything pink!

A soft chuckle left her lips as she brought herself back to reality and placed another flower in the cake. Her attention was pulled to the door as it opened with the sound of a knock.

"We leave in five for the Dero wedding."

"Just finishing up," she placed another flower before stepping to the side to show her work, "How is it?"

"No wonder she was so adamant about you making her cake. You really do the best work in town," she complemented with a light laugh, "perfectly pink, just as requested. Let's get it in the van, shall we?"

They slowly drove past the front of the venue taking in the drapes of pink chiffon hung across the front of the building, confirming they had found the correct location.

She unloaded the cake and made her way to the kitchen as the van drove away. Placing the cake on the table, she turned it, checking for any shifts or imperfections.

She felt her heart stop at the sound of his voice behind her.

"I miss you."

A multitude of emotions swarmed the pit of her stomach before coursing through her - pain, anger, hope - all clawed viscously at her heart. She hadn't seen him since that day. She remembered every detail - his hair, his clothes, even how he smelt the day he walked in with his fiancé.

She straightened her shoulders as she pushed down her feelings and turned towards him with polite professionalism, "Mr. Dero, are you here to inspect your wedding cake?"

"Did you hear me? I said I miss you!" He repeated.

Her perfectly polished smile remained fixed as she responded, her voice professionally polite, "impossible Mr. Dero. You and I are strangers. We do not know each other. I most certainly do not know you and being as such, it would be insane for you to miss me. Perhaps you have mistaken me for your bride."

"I didn't know how to tell you." He attempted to explain.

"You didn't know how to tell me? Tell me what? That you had a fiancé? That our entire life was a lie? We lived together for three years..." Her voice began to take on heat, "and the entire time I was the other woman. Everything I thought I knew was a lie."

"I know. I'm sorry. I made a mistake. Please forgive me. I love you, I have always loved you. Can't that be enough?"

"Enough? Enough for what?" She took a deep breath and re-centered herself as her voice took on a politeness, "I apologize Mr. Dero, but the kitchen is for staff only. If you need help finding your way back to your wife, I would be happy to find an attendant to assist you."

"That won't be necessary."

"Perfect..." she turned her back as he began to leave, "congratulation on your wedding Mr. Dero."

She stood for hours, watching the events unfold exactly as scheduled. The crowd erupted in laughter as the bride and groom playfully smashed a piece of cake into each others mouth. Her eyes tracked each slice being cut and distributed until each person had their slice and were happily eating without complaint.

Her eyes met his, a smirk spreading across her face as he finished his last bite of cake. All laughter died out as it began to be replaced with the clinks of dropped forks and thuds of bodies.

The echoed sound of her foot steps bounded through the room as she made her way towards him, watching the fear in his eyes as his body fought to get air.

She cupped his face as she brought his watery, bulging eyes level to hers and spoke, "I didn't know how to tell you..." an exaggerated pout pursed her lips, "but I poisoned the cake. But don't worry, I have missed you and I love you, so that should be enough yes?"

She gently began setting his head on the table as his eyes began to close. "Just remember, you wanted your cake and to eat it too and now you have. I just hope the cost was worth the best chocolate cake in town. Goodbye Mr. Dero."

Short Story

About the Creator

Chelcey

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.