Where the Crawdads Sing
More like, "Where the Crawdads Sank," amiright?
Cons:
- Big “Not Like Other Girls” energy from the heroine ;
- Heavy lean on the “Magical Negro” trope;
- Some of the worst poetry ever written ;
- Imagine an interesting love-triangle/murder mystery. Take out what makes it interesting.
Pros:
- Your aunt probably loved it! Y’all can discuss it at holidays;
- Technically a book.
About the Creator
Helen Seder
Art doesn’t need to be “good.” It just needs to be.
Reader insights
Outstanding
Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!
Top insights
Expert insights and opinions
Arguments were carefully researched and presented
Eye opening
Niche topic & fresh perspectives
On-point and relevant
Writing reflected the title & theme
Keep reading
More stories from Helen Seder and writers in Critique and other communities.
Standing While Falling
Quotation from Friedrich Nietzsche "He who wrestles long with monsters should beware lest he himself become a monster. And if you gaze long into an abyss, the abyss also gazes into you. Man is not destroyed by suffering, but by the meaning he makes of it."
By LUCCIAN LAYTH9 days ago in Critique
Charleston White Responds As Viral Report Suggests A Shooting Has Left Him In Critical Condition
In this age of fake news, poor AI generated content, and outlandish rumors, it’s hard to keep up with the truth. That’s why Charleston White declared his existence on social media.
By Skyler Saundersa day ago in Critique
Comments (10)
Is it weird that I got all those vibes from NOT engaging in any of the hype? Lol. I love that you didn't like it. This is such a creative take on the challenge. Congrats on placing!
This is incredibly accurate and hilarious. Congrats!!
I got halfway through the film version a couple of days ago. So bland. Just stuck around for the setting and to find out the “mystery”..but started to lose interest fast, haha. I’m loved this mini critique. Great job!! And congrats on your runner up prize! 😊👏
Ooh loved the unique pro/con approach and biting analysis. Well done!
Okay this is amazing and hilarious. I've always been skeptical of this book but now I kinda want to read it just to see your cons come to life! Congrats, Helen!
The title has always put me off so thanks for confirming what would otherwise have been no more than prejudice on my part. Congratulations on your win.
I read this after hearing SUCH great things about it.... but I hated it! So thank you for showing me I wasn't crazy for telling my book club that I didn't see the appeal.
Yeah, I knew it was crap. Great review!
The "take out what's interesting" took me out! I haven't read it and I don't think I plan on reading it. I kept hearing mixed reviews about it so I decided not to.
"Technically a book" made me laugh way too hard.