Criminal logo

The Perfect Alibi

A Detective Realizes All His Suspects Are the Same Man

By FarzadPublished 5 months ago 2 min read
The Perfect Alibi
Photo by Mimi Di Cianni on Unsplash

Chapter 1: The First Suspect

Detective Mark Riker knew something was wrong when the fingerprints matched three different people.

The first suspect was a mild-mannered accountant named David Kline—picked up for loitering near the latest victim's apartment. His alibi was airtight: security footage showed him at an all-night diner thirty miles away when the murder occurred.

But when Riker ran Kline's prints, they came back as belonging to a dead Marine named Vincent Cole.

"Must be a glitch," the tech said.

Then the DNA results came in.

Belonging to a third man.

One who didn't exist.

Chapter 2: The Pattern Emerges

By the third murder, Riker had a file full of contradictions:

Suspect #2: A homeless man with the retina scan of a retired ophthalmologist

Suspect #3: A female schoolteacher whose teeth matched a 1992 John Doe

Suspect #4: A teenager whose voiceprint was identical to the first victim's

All with perfect alibis. All innocent.

All sharing one eerie similarity—when asked about the murders, each replied with the exact same phrase:

"I couldn't have done it. I wasn't myself that night."

Chapter 3: The Missing Piece

The break came from an unlikely source—a pawn shop receipt found in Victim #4's pocket.

The item hocked? A vintage Rolex.

The shop's security footage showed the seller clearly: a man in his 60s with a distinctive spiderweb tattoo on his neck.

Riker's blood turned to ice.

That tattoo belonged to Harry Gaines—a small-time crook who'd been in Riker's custody the night of the first murder.

And every murder since.

Chapter 4: The Interrogation

Gaines smirked through the two-way mirror.

"You can't pin these on me, Detective. I've been right here."

It was true. Jail logs, guard reports, even Riker's own notes confirmed it.

Then Gaines leaned forward, his spiderweb tattoo stretching with the movement.

"Tell me something," he whispered. "When was the last time you really looked at your partner?"

Riker turned slowly.

His partner, Detective Alvarez, stood frozen—wearing a watch that matched the pawn shop receipt exactly.

A watch Riker had seen Gaines wear during booking.

Chapter 5: The Revelation

The files told the impossible truth:

Every suspect was Gaines.

Not copies. Not relatives. The same man appearing simultaneously across the city—different ages, different genders, different lives—all sharing one fingerprint.

The jailhouse Gaines was just another alibi.

Riker's hand shook as he pulled Alvarez's service record.

The photo showed his partner of twelve years... with Gaines's spiderweb tattoo.

Chapter 6: The Last Arrest

Riker stood over Gaines's bunk at 3:33 AM.

The prisoner's eyes snapped open—wrong somehow. Like looking at a mirror in a funhouse.

"You finally understand," Gaines croaked. "I'm everywhere."

Riker drew his revolver.

So did the four other versions of himself standing around the cell.

Fresh take on serial killer trope - Quantum criminal with perfect alibis

Police procedural twist - Cop vs. his own reality

Unreliable narrator elements - Detective can't trust his own eyes

Open-ended finale - Implies cyclical nature

cartelfact or fictioninvestigationbook reviews

About the Creator

Farzad

I write A best history story for read it see and read my story in injoy it .

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.