Criminal logo

The Confession Booth

He walked into a church to confess_but not to God

By Herbert Published 8 months ago 4 min read

The night was cold and wet. Rain fell in waves across Chicago’s empty streets, slicking the pavement with a silver sheen. Streetlamps flickered like dying candles. Somewhere in the distance, a siren wailed and faded.

At precisely 10:49 p.m., a man stepped through the heavy wooden doors of St. Augustine’s Cathedral. His coat clung to his frame, soaked through. His face was pale, eyes restless. A thin scar ran down his cheek—barely visible under the dim chandeliers.

His name was Michael Grant, but to the priest sitting inside the old confessional booth, he was just another troubled soul.

---

The Booth

The church was nearly empty, save for a few statues and the scent of extinguished candles. Michael moved without hesitation. The weight in his chest had grown too heavy, too dangerous to carry.

He knelt inside the booth, the ancient wood creaking beneath him. The lattice window slid open.

A calm voice greeted him.

“Bless you, my son. How long has it been since your last confession?”

Michael didn’t answer right away. Instead, he let the silence linger.

Then he whispered:

“I’ve never confessed before. But I have to now—because I won’t be alive tomorrow.”

---

The Truth Comes Out

He began his story like a man opening an old wound.

“I worked for the Cook County Crime Lab. Forensics. I processed blood, prints, fibers—truth, really. Until one day, I erased the truth.”

He explained how, twelve years ago, a fingerprint was found on a crime scene: a murder linked to Chicago’s drug underworld. The print belonged to Daniel Lake, a powerful real estate mogul with deep political ties.

“Lake’s print should’ve cracked the case. But my supervisor told me to delete it. No explanation. Just... do it.”

Michael had a newborn at home. He needed the paycheck. So, he did it.

And that decision haunted him ever since.

---

A Body Count Builds

“I told myself it was a one-time thing. A career misstep. But then men started dying—five in total, all tied to the same criminal ring.”

They were all ruled as overdoses or accidents. But Michael saw the signs: clean crime scenes, manipulated evidence, matching time gaps. It wasn’t coincidence. It was clean-up.

“I started keeping records. Secret backups, burner phones, call logs. If I couldn’t trust the law, I had to build a case myself.”

He paused, breath trembling.

“I never planned to go public. But last week... someone let me know they found me.”

---

The Warning

Three days earlier, Michael returned home to find his apartment slightly... off. Nothing stolen. But the drawers were open, a photo turned upside down, and a single message scrawled in red lipstick across his bathroom mirror:

“Confess. Or disappear.”

He checked the locks. The cameras. Nothing showed. But he knew exactly who had sent the message.

“Lake’s people. Maybe even someone I once worked with.”

That night, he packed a go-bag. He moved between hotels. Then he came to the church.

“I figured, if I’m going to die, someone should know what I died for.”

He slid a black flash drive through the booth’s partition.

“Everything’s on there—calls, names, photos. Enough to bring down half of City Hall.”

---

The Twist

A long pause followed. Michael waited for the priest to speak.

Then came a voice—not soothing, but cold. Measured.

“Michael... I admire your honesty.”

Click.

A faint metallic sound echoed through the wood—too soft for a gun. Too sharp for comfort.

“But I’m afraid I’m not a priest.”

Michael stiffened.

There was a soft pop, like air released from a valve.

Then... nothing.

His eyes blinked once. Twice. Then glazed over.

By the time his body hit the floor of the confessional booth, he was already gone.

---

Discovery

At 6:03 a.m., a janitor sweeping the chapel found the booth door ajar and a man slumped forward as if in prayer.

The police arrived minutes later. There was no sign of a struggle. No weapon. No flash drive. His wallet was missing, and the only item left in his coat was a torn piece of paper that read:

> “Father, forgive me.”

The coroner later found a puncture mark behind his left ear—no larger than a mosquito bite. He died from an exotic neurotoxin that paralyzed the lungs in under sixty seconds.

The death was ruled an overdose.

---

The Leak

Two weeks later, a journalist named Carla Voss received an anonymous package.

Inside: a flash drive.

The same kind Michael claimed to have.

It contained damning evidence—photos of backdoor meetings, bribes, burner phone recordings, and one chilling video clip: Daniel Lake, in a private lounge, casually saying:

“It’s not murder if no one sees a body fall.”

The file was signed “M.G.” at the bottom.

Carla went underground. One week later, Daniel Lake was found dead in his penthouse. Heart failure, the media said. The autopsy report? Sealed.



Legacy

St. Augustine’s Cathedral has since removed its confessionals. Too many strangers came afterward. Some just wept. Others left notes.

No one claimed to be the man behind the partition. No prints. No face. Just a memory—a whisper that truth might cost your life, but silence will cost your soul.

To this day, no suspect has been identified in Michael Grant’s murder.

But in Chicago’s darkest corners, a name circulates in hushed tones:

“The Confessor.”

capital punishmentfact or fictioninvestigationmovie review

About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments (1)

Sign in to comment
  • Rohitha Lanka8 months ago

    Beautiful and well written.

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.