Michael Turney: The ‘Obsessive’ Stepfather Accused of Murdering Alissa Turney

On May 17, 2001, 17-year-old Alissa Turney left her high school in Phoenix, Arizona, and was never seen again. Her case remained a mystery for nearly two decades—an unresolved disappearance clouded by strange circumstances, unsettling evidence, and a stepfather whose obsessive control would later make him the prime suspect in her presumed murder.

A Controlling Father Figure

Alissa lived with her stepfather, Michael Turney, and her half-siblings after her mother passed away from cancer when she was young. By all accounts, Michael was an extremely strict and controlling parental figure. Friends and family noted that he kept Alissa on an unreasonably short leash—monitoring her phone calls, installing surveillance cameras in their home, and even picking her up from school unannounced to ensure she wasn't seeing boys.

Despite his overbearing nature, Alissa’s loved ones didn’t initially suspect anything sinister—until she vanished.

The Day Alissa Disappeared

According to Michael, he picked Alissa up early from school that afternoon after she called, complaining about wanting to leave. He claimed they had an argument about her newfound independence, and when he left to run errands, she stormed off, leaving behind a note stating she was going to California.

But almost immediately, red flags surfaced.

Alissa had left behind her belongings—including her cell phone, money, and clothes. There was no record of her ever leaving the state, no bus or plane tickets, and no contact with friends. More disturbingly, the only evidence of her alleged departure was a suspiciously convenient note that seemed out of character for her.

A Suspicious Man

For years, authorities treated Alissa’s case as a runaway situation. Michael Turney insisted she had fled to California to start a new life, claiming he received a phone call from her weeks later. But no solid evidence supported his version of events.

Meanwhile, Alissa’s half-sister, Sarah Turney, began to question Michael’s story. As she grew older, she started looking deeper into the case and uncovered chilling details.

Michael had surveillance tapes of their home—except for the day Alissa disappeared.

He withdrew a large sum of money after her disappearance and never used it to search for her.

He kept Alissa's cell phone but never handed it over to investigators.

He had an unnatural obsession with her—often speaking about her in ways that made others uncomfortable.

The Breakthrough: Stockpile of Weapons and a Murder Manifesto

In 2008, the case took a shocking turn. While investigating Alissa’s disappearance, police searched Michael Turney’s home—and what they found was disturbing.

Authorities discovered a massive stockpile of illegal weapons, explosives, and a manifesto detailing a planned attack on a local labor union, which he blamed for Alissa’s alleged disappearance. He was arrested and sentenced to 10 years in prison for weapons charges, but the most critical evidence related to Alissa’s fate remained elusive.

However, Sarah Turney refused to give up. She turned to social media, launching a relentless campaign to keep Alissa’s case in the public eye, using platforms like TikTok and podcasts to expose Michael’s inconsistencies and questionable behavior. Her advocacy ultimately led to a renewed investigation.

The Arrest: Justice for Alissa?

In August 2020, nearly 20 years after Alissa vanished, Michael Turney was arrested and charged with her murder. Prosecutors alleged that he had killed Alissa in a fit of rage, unable to accept her growing independence. However, the case was largely circumstantial—without a body, a murder weapon, or direct evidence linking him to the crime.

In 2023, the case went to trial, but due to a lack of concrete forensic evidence, Michael Turney was acquitted of the charges. The verdict was devastating for Alissa’s family, but Sarah vowed to continue fighting for justice.

A Case Still Open

Alissa Turney’s disappearance remains an open case. While Michael Turney may have escaped conviction, the overwhelming circumstantial evidence continues to point to him as the prime suspect.

Sarah Turney’s advocacy has kept Alissa’s name alive, ensuring the case remains in the public’s consciousness. Even though justice has yet to be fully served, one thing is certain—Alissa Turney has not been forgotten.

The story of Michael Turney and his obsessive, chilling control over Alissa serves as a stark reminder of how darkness can exist behind closed doors. And while the legal system has yet to officially hold him accountable, the search for truth continues.

Thank you for reading! If you finf this piece interesting, please leave a heart, comment, or even subscribe! Your support means a lot to me!