Criminal logo

18 Years of Perplexing Silence- Who Killed Alexandra Anaya? Part 2

The Sad Story of Alexandra Anaya

By Rare StoriesPublished 2 years ago 3 min read

To start with the autopsy. The pathologist determined that Alexandra still had undigested French fries in her stomach by the time she was brutally murdered. It is important to note that before her mother, Susan, left her with her twin sisters that morning, they ate French fries together. This autopsy finding shows that she died that same day.

However, despite the thorough work of the pathologists, they could not determine the exact cause of death.

Who Killed Alexandra Anaya?

Just a few months before her tragic disappearance, Alexandra had opened up to her mother to make a shocking revelation: Rudolfo Heredia, the father of her two twin half-sisters, and her mother's boyfriend had been sexually assaulting her since she was seven.

Alexandra Anaya

This broke Sandra's heart leading to her breaking up with Rudolfo. She wanted her gone from their lives, but he was so persistent, he became a nuisance.

He started stalking them:

  • He procured a spare key to the apartment and would go in when the family was not around.
  • He broke into their house multiple times and threatened them.
  • He called them repeatedly and harassed them.
  • He followed them around and showed up at their places of work and school.
  • He sent them letters and gifts with disturbing messages.
  • He vandalized their property and car.

The day before the disappearance of Alexandra, Rudolfo called the family multiple times.

Following the discovery of Alexandra's body, Rudolfo was arrested and charged with stalking and burglary. He was tried in a federal court and was found not guilty of both charges. Rudolfo was never named a person of interest in the case, despite the stalking charges against him and the fact that the body was found blocks away from his residence in Riverdale, Illinois. The investigators determined there was not enough evidence to tie him to the crime.

Alexandra's severed head, arms, and legs have never been found to date.

The FBI

After more than 18 years of unsuccessfully seeking information that would help solve this case, the FBI doubled the reward for any information in May 2023. The FBI doubled the reward to $20000.

"I am sure some people were scared, but time has passed. Maybe this will encourage them to come forward even more now" explained Alexandra's mother, Sandra Anaya. "She always lit up the room, she was the type who didn't just give you a wave, she gave you a hug and a kiss" Sandra continued.

" It is a devastating situation for any parents to face, and to not have a resolution for 18 years, it's unacceptable" an FBI agent stated.

The FBI urges the public to report any tips, even anonymously via this contact 1-800-CALL-FBI or visit tips.fbi.gov.

A true crime book.

Hello,

We have published the second volume of this book, "Horrific True Crime Stories." The book is available on Amazon and we believe it is a good read. We selected 17 stories that we believe are engaging and wrote on them.

Additionally, please leave an honest review on Amazon if you get this book.

This is the link to the book.

Horrific True Crime Stories Volume 2: 17 Terrifying and Unimaginable True Crime Cases

Horrific True Crime Stories Volume 2: 17 Terrifying and Unimaginable True Crime Cases

References:

Alexandra Anaya was adored by all who knew her. More than 15 years after her mutilated body was found, no one’s been held to account.

Hammond mother remembers unsolved death of daughter: ‘She would’ve been 27, but she’s not. She’s still 13.’

The FBI is part of a new effort to re-test evidence and find new witnesses and information into the gruesome murder and dismemberment of 13-year-old Alex Anaya.

investigation

About the Creator

Rare Stories

Our goal is to give you stories that will have you hooked.

This is an extension of the Quora space: Rare Stories

X(formerly Twitter): Scarce Stories

Writers:

C.S Blackwood

....xoxo

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.