The Real Story Behind Ariel (The Little Mermaid)

You probably grew up thinking The Little Mermaid was a sweet tale about a curious mermaid giving up her voice to be with a charming prince. But the original story by Hans Christian Andersen, published in 1837, is far darker and more disturbing than Disney would ever dare show.

In Andersen’s version, the mermaid is not just a playful, singing creature. She lives in the deep ocean, yearning for the human world. When she finally goes to the surface, she falls in love with a prince—but here’s the shocking part: unlike the Disney version, her love is completely unrequited. The prince doesn’t even know she exists as a person—he sees her as a beautiful, silent mystery.

To be with him, the mermaid trades her voice to a sea witch, but the cost is extreme: every step she takes feels as if she’s walking on sharp knives, and she will bleed with every movement. Unlike a harmless sacrifice, it’s excruciating physical pain, a form of suffering Andersen used to explore the idea that love and desire can demand immense personal cost.

But the darkness doesn’t stop there. The mermaid’s hope of marrying the prince fails completely, because he marries another. And according to Andersen’s original ending, she doesn’t just fade away happily. She is given a chance to earn a soul, but only after hundreds of years of good deeds as an ethereal spirit, never returning to her family or her ocean home. It’s a tale of loneliness, obsession, and unfulfilled longing disguised as a “romantic” story.

The story might seem fictional, but Andersen reportedly drew inspiration from a real tragedy. In Copenhagen, there were rumors about a young woman from a well-off family who drowned mysteriously in the harbor. Locals whispered that she had been in love with a man she could never marry, and she spent her last days dreaming of him while walking along the shore. Andersen, fascinated by her story, transformed her fate into that of the mermaid—a being caught between worlds, punished for her desires, and condemned to suffer in silence.

So next time you watch Disney’s Ariel sing and dance, remember: the original tale is not about love conquering all, but about pain, obsession, and the brutal costs of longing for a life you can’t have. The happy ending is Disney’s invention; the real story is a haunting meditation on mortality, sacrifice, and the impossibility of truly belonging.