Chapters logo

The Fair Exchange - Part 2

The Choice

By John CoxPublished about a year ago Updated 11 months ago 3 min read

When I eventually regained consciousness, the air reeked of death and decay, the terrible stench so close at hand that it seemed to emanate from my own flesh, my limbs as stiff as if my muscles and skin had calcified to bone. With tremendous effort I finally managed to open my eyes to the faint light of individual flames moving slowly through the night, a blood moon weakly illuminating the surrounding stones.

A great host bearing votive candles marched toward me, their ranks filled with bent bodies and ragged skeletons, their ghastly faces gazing in fixed torment, as if the sufferings from their final minutes on earth had followed them into death. In the far distance flames licked the trees surrounding the cemetery as the wind scattered plumes of ash around my recumbent and petrified figure.

In the terror of the moment I believed I had died and reawakened in Hell.

Within their ranks an apparition as black as a moonless night appeared, its teeth and eyes faintly glowing. “Tis a cold night to be mother naked,” it rasped with a bare-toothed grin. I cowered in fear as it brought its dark and formless visage near mine, the smell of burning Sulphur overpowering my senses.

Grasping me roughly, it pulled me to my feet as I trembled with cold and dread. Wrapping a cloak around my shivering body it asked, “Do ye know us, Jamie?” But speechless with fear, I faintly nodded my head in answer.

It gestured to follow, the rustling of the ash beneath my bare feet the only sound disturbing the spectral calm. We stopped when the pathway split into two and diverged in the gloom, one path winding away into utter blackness and the other into the distant hope of light. It asked –“Which way will ye choose?” But long I stood staring first into the darkness and then into the promise of faraway light. When it finally rasped “Want a hint?” I nodded my head. Pointing to the left it asked— “What do ye see?”

“Na-nothing,” I replied, my teeth chattering with terror and cold.

“And if ye walked into that darkness, what would ye see then?

“Da-da-don know.”

“More nothing,” it replied with a burst of ghostly laughter. Pointing to the right it asked - “What do ye see out there?”

Staring into the distance the light began to grow. “Ta-town?”

“Come see.” We began to walk again, the light growing stronger till I found myself standing in the rear hallway of my school. Pushing through the students I saw a pair of boys squaring off to fight. But when the smaller one knocked his opponent to the ground I blinked in terror and disbelief. The one standing breathlessly over Joey was me.

My future unfolded before my eyes like a movie set on fast forward, weeks passing in the blink of an eye. One moment I witnessed myself desperately fighting the meanest kid in school and in the next joining the Marines. Time passed in a rickety blur: a combat tour in Vietnam, meeting Gretchen upon my return; marriage, babies born, our children marrying and raising children of their own. My future unfolded so rapidly that the promise and majesty of love seemed inseparable from the heartbreak of its loss, the strength and power of youth separated by no more than a whisper from its own decline and death. When we finally arrived at the end, we watched an old man struggling for his final breath and I knew without a doubt that man was me.

Standing at the headstone above my grave it whispered “These are but shadows of what might be. Ye can live a life where ye know whom ye will marry before wooing her. Ye can live a life knowing every joy and sorrow ye will ever face. Ye can live a life knowing in advance the last day ye will experience on this Earth.”

Or,” he giggled as if a riddle impossible to solve. “Or,” he said with the finality of the grave.

Placing his hand softly on my shoulder he finished with surprising gentleness.

“Or … ye can enter a story that was written for ye but cannot be known. It is your fate, Jamie Faust. Which will ye choose? Ye won’t find Gretchen out there,” it said pointing to the unexplored pathway. Choose well … ye will never stand at these crossroads again.”

His remembered words echo strangely in my thoughts as I wipe the tears from my cheeks. I have no recollection of ever consciously choosing this life. Yet I have lived it just the same, the feeling persisting that I never had a choice at all.

So why return home now?

____________________

The Fair Exchange - Part 3

FictionMagical RealismHorror

About the Creator

John Cox

Twisted teller of mind bending tales. I never met a myth I didn't love or a subject that I couldn't twist out of joint. I have a little something for almost everyone here. Cept AI. Aint got none of that.

Reader insights

Outstanding

Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!

Top insights

  1. Compelling and original writing

    Creative use of language & vocab

  2. Excellent storytelling

    Original narrative & well developed characters

  3. Masterful proofreading

    Zero grammar & spelling mistakes

  1. Easy to read and follow

    Well-structured & engaging content

  2. Eye opening

    Niche topic & fresh perspectives

  3. On-point and relevant

    Writing reflected the title & theme

Add your insights

Comments (18)

Sign in to comment
  • Euan Brennan9 months ago

    I don't know how many chapters there are, but I'll be sure to read the others (though not now as I should be getting back to work, lol). This story has intrigued me.

  • Caitlin Charltonabout a year ago

    I’m having the same feeling I had when I read the first poem of yours that led me to your page. I love the themes chosen for this story and the wisdom you’re passing on to us, the questions in our lives that you want us to think about. It’s a tough pick, the two options you gave to both your main character and your readers. To know everything about our life or to know nothing at all. Then the last sentence you hit us with, you knew exactly what you were doing there. I can’t move from the screen now. AND.. your words flow as if you have someone over you, giving them to you. Feeding your mind with magic and secret parables that even if you may not understand them now, your future stories find unfold them.

  • Heather Zieffle about a year ago

    Great storytelling here, John. I love how it's unfolding so far!

  • D.K. Shepardabout a year ago

    The turn to a more profound and metaphysical experience was an unexpected twist but a well orchestrated one! Great work, John!

  • Hannah Mooreabout a year ago

    Jesus, what a choice. THis is going to stay with me. What would I DO? I also love the way you condense the love and the loss, it feels so.... I cant really articulate it. THere is a familiarity and a dread and a comfort there all at once.

  • Andrea Corwin about a year ago

    Choose well… but do WE choose, really, or does fate lead us… 🤔 intriguing.

  • Kelli Sheckler-Amsdenabout a year ago

    oh, the crossroads!! The gravestone and the life still unlived...this is genius John...off for part 3

  • Gabriel Huizengaabout a year ago

    Wow, this took the story from a masterful psychological horror to an even better deeply philosophical, thought-provoking reflection on the nature of choices and human story!! Forgive my wordiness- just struggling to communicate all that I love about this! Brilliant work, John :)

  • Anna about a year ago

    Loved the beautiful thoughts in it😊

  • Mark Gagnonabout a year ago

    The Rafe sounds a wee bit Scottish. I like that he gets to view one future but not the alternate.

  • JBazabout a year ago

    Absolutely beautiful visuals, a horrid nightmare unfolding as we read. Your characters are as real as if I knew them.

  • Gerard DiLeoabout a year ago

    Little jewels like, "...their ghastly faces gazing in fixed torment, as if the sufferings from their final minutes on earth had followed them into death," and "... the strength and power of youth separated by no more than a whisper from its own decline and death." Beautiful flow. On to Part 3.

  • L.C. Schäferabout a year ago

    Love the graveside giggling bit, so creepy!

  • Rachel Deemingabout a year ago

    Jamie Faust. Nice touch. Right. Where next? I'm ready!

  • Lamar Wigginsabout a year ago

    -their ghastly faces gazing in fixed torment, as if the sufferings from their final minutes on earth had followed them into death.- Such a creepy feeling that line left me with. Great storytelling!!!

  • But like why is Jamie even being subjected to this? Omggg, sooo suspenseful! Can't wait for the next part!

  • Cathy holmesabout a year ago

    Oh damn. This is getting really interesting.

  • Latasha karenabout a year ago

    Nice article

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.