BookClub logo

Book Review - Rebel Witch by Kristen Ciccarelli

A spellbinding conclusion to an UNFORGETTABLE Duology

By Dina GoodPublished 11 months ago • 5 min read
Book Review - Rebel Witch by Kristen Ciccarelli
Photo by Mark Tegethoff on Unsplash

click here to read "Rebel Witch" for free with a 30-day free trial

Spice Scale: 🌶️ (The story creates tension through its romantic storylines)

Kristen Ciccarelli closes the Crimson Moth duology with Rebel Witch which delivers an unforgettable reading experience leading listeners to complete breathlessness and obsessive fascination. When experienced via audiobook format this tale communicates itself through both hearing and emotional resonance. Auditory confession develops into whirlwind battles throughout this narrative as the storytelling draws listeners into a tempestuous story line that combines love and betrayal. My upcoming review declares its deep affection towards a story that now has permanent control over my heart.

A Symphony of Stakes and Swoon: The Plot of The story of Rebel Witch commences at the very point Heartless Hunter concluded since Rune Winters reunites with Gideon Sharpe—known as the Crimson Moth—via her execution by deadly human hunters. Demasque has brought Rune to execution but finds rescue from a single unexpected person: Cressida Roseblood who is revived after long being dead. The resurrection of Cressida creates political chaos when she aims to bring her sisters back from death to restore witch rule across the Republic. Rune and Gideon establish an unstable partnership to confront Cressida Roseblood because they must battle a maze of mutual distrust alongside passionate attraction while dealing with unwritable moral decisions. The plot contains tension at a professional level. Every page in the story explodes with constant threats ranging from attempted assassinations to magical battles and dramatic revelations that keep readers at edge of their seats. Ciccarelli takes readers through devastating narrative points starting with Rune discovering her relation to Cressida (oh my, it was a bombshell!) and Gideon facing a dreadful decision between giving Rune up for the world's salvation or letting her survive in its destruction. The constant quick pace of the tale finds its equilibrium through peaceful moments that showcase both deep friendships and personal love ties between the characters. The emotional climax left me inconsolable and subject to uncontrollable gestures as this was the perfect way to finalize a story.

Characters Who Steal Your Heart (and Stab It Repeatedly)

The discussion now shifts to Rune along with Gideon. Oh, Gideon Sharpe. Fans of brooding heroes who write poetry will experience absolute love and then deep anguish altogether. The writer Ciccarelli shows exceptional skill in creating their characters' relationships. The rebellious nature which defined Rune before becomes totally exposed in this story sequel. Her path from dispirited runaway to absolute leadership displays an authentic human experience which derives from her strength and makes her seek the connection between her identity and capacity. Gideon walks through life as an enigmatic mix of conflicting character traits because he hunts witches while battling his sense of guilt and his unextinguishable love. The hesitant moments when this couple shows their true vulnerable selves create the most powerful emotional impact.

And then there’s Cressida. Because of her complex nature, Cressida proves to be one of the most multidimensional villains readers have encountered. Due to her relentless ambition Cressida complements Rune and Gideon’s main characters through her horrific nature with every one of their beliefs facing challenge

The Audiobook Experience: Narration That Ignites the Imagination

The traditional printed pages held my interest but the audiobook version transformed the story into something magnificent. The narrator performs at a peak level by delivering Rune's rebellions alongside Gideon's deep growling tone along with Cressida's dangerous frosty voice in ways that closely emulate the characters for listeners. Audio presentation of these pivotal emotional moments inflicted powerfully strong emotional impacts on me since Gideon expressed "I love you, Rune Winters" with a soft whisper and Rune delivered "Come find me in the next world" in a tearful voice.

Pacing in the audio edition mimics the novel's fast forward narrative structure so essential moments stay extended effectively (for instance when Rune and Gideon share a bed together). Secondary characters from the story maintain individuality through their distinctive voice changes.

The novel delivers three deep messages about love alongside power and redemption.

The story presents a tale about romantic sacrifice which occurs when the world makes demands on true love. Throughout the story Rune and Gideon’s transformation from hateful adversaries to reluctant allies until they achieve a love that surpasses any possible explanation. He highly desired to demonstrate his weakness if weakness required such behavior. Apart from showcasing love's dual nature as saving and destructive power the main theme appears in "If this was weakness, he wanted to be weak. If this was sin, let him be damned to hell".

Just as powerful are the story’s three paths of power which span from magical forces to governmental influence and individual face-to-face interactions. In author Maggie Caulfield’s work Cressida’s power hungry nature parallels Rune’s habit of controlling her powers just as Gideon's internal conflict between moral duty and love questions whether past hurts can ever resolve fully

Critiques? Barely a Whispers in the Wind

Rebel Witch stands among the most faultless books in existence. The second part of the narrative received criticism from several reviewers because new characters appeared too quickly. As the primary plot captured my complete attention I paid no attention to its flaws though I could see myself loving a book focusing on Harrow's life after the war. I disagree with detractors who announced repetitive tension between the main characters due to the essential nature of this dynamic in their personal evolution. Time must pass for trust to develop since the person who both kills you and loves you simultaneously.

Final Verdict: A Masterpiece of Romantasy

The book Rebel Witch provides its readers with much more than typical literature because it serves as a unique adventure. Kristen Ciccarelli has written two books which skillfully combine gripping conflict scenes with poetic writing techniques and ethical ethos that will stay with readers forever. The immersive audiobook narration provides listeners with a perfect method to experience each gasp and growl and whispered confession.

To anyone who loves:

• Enemies-to-lovers with bone-deep yearning

The story features ingenious political situations together with inventive yet classic magic components

The quote "Then it'll be an honor to die at your side" seared itself deep inside me because it moved me to tears.

Character narrators enhance stories through their performance of voice

—this is your next obsession

In Conclusion:

Rebel Witch is a triumph. The story reminds listeners/readers why they love fantasy narratives while proving audiobooks possess their unique type of supernatural power that never fails to capture my imagination. Kristen Ciccarelli, take a bow. And Gideon Sharpe? Meet me after death in the following existence.

Audiobook Details:

• Narrator: (Unspecified in search results, but trust me—they’re incredible!)

• Length: Matches the novel’s 464-page intensity 6

• Perfect for: Fans of Serpent & Dove, From Blood and Ash, and The Witch Collector

Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’ll be replaying Chapter 27 on loop until my heart recovers. 🖤 click here to read "Rebel Witch" for free with a 30-day free trial

ReviewRecommendation

About the Creator

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.