Psyche logo

We’re All Performing: How Instagram Turned My Love Life into a Mental Health Spiral

When love becomes content, heartbreak becomes a rebrand. A raw look at how social media affects our relationships, self-worth, and healing.

By LilyPublished 9 months ago 2 min read

“If it’s not posted, did it even happen?”

I was once that person - the one who curated their love life like a photo gallery. Candid beach kisses. Couple’s yoga. A perfectly framed coffee date. The comments always rolled in: “Goals 😍”, “You guys are perfect!”, “Manifesting this energy.”

But behind every post was a panic attack.

The Pressure to Perform a Perfect Relationship

Social media has blurred the line between real love and the aesthetic of love. We don’t just date anymore - we brand our relationships. And it’s exhausting.

When I was dating my ex, the pressure to look happy often outweighed the actual happiness. If we argued? I’d still post a “Throwback Thursday” of us laughing under fairy lights. If we hadn’t spoken in two days? I’d share a cute memory with a sappy caption like “My rock 💫” just to maintain the illusion.

And honestly? That illusion felt more important than intimacy.

The Dopamine of Validation, The Hangover of Loneliness

Each like on a post was a hit of dopamine. But when the screen went dark, so did I.

I began measuring my relationship by engagement metrics instead of emotional connection. If he didn’t post me on his story, I spiraled. If we weren’t being “shipped” by mutuals, I questioned our compatibility. I started seeing our love through a filter - both literally and metaphorically.

I wasn’t building a relationship. I was building content.

When the Relationship Ended, My Identity Cracked

When we broke up, it wasn’t just the relationship that ended - it was the brand. The followers who once envied us now scrolled past my silence. I felt invisible. Embarrassed. Like I’d failed not just at love, but at keeping up the performance.

But here’s the raw truth: the grief that came after wasn’t just about missing him - it was about missing her. The version of me I had performed so well online.

The Real Healing Didn’t Look Good on Instagram

There’s nothing aesthetic about healing. No one double-taps photos of you ugly-crying on the bathroom floor or finally blocking your ex. But that’s where the real growth happens.

I stopped posting every feeling and started feeling them. I unfollowed people who made me question my worth. I went on dates without telling anyone. I relearned how to enjoy moments without needing to document them.

And most importantly, I stopped treating my life like it needed to be palatable for an audience.

From Perfection to Presence: A New Kind of Intimacy

Now? I want love that isn’t aesthetic. I want silence without awkwardness. Connection without Wi-Fi. Eye contact, not just screen taps.

I want someone who’s more interested in how I feel than how we look.

I’ve realized that intimacy is built in the quiet moments - not the public ones. The world doesn’t need to validate my relationship. I do.

Let’s Talk: Is Social Media Hurting Our Relationships?

I’m not anti-Instagram. But I’m pro-authenticity. And if you’ve ever felt like you were dating for your followers more than for yourself - I see you.

Let’s stop performing and start connecting.

💬 Have you ever felt pressure to “perform” your relationship online? How do you balance authenticity with sharing your life on social media?

Drop your thoughts below - let’s have a real conversation.

humanitysocial mediasupport

About the Creator

Lily

My name is Lily, and I've faced many challenges in life. People have often taken advantage of me, using me for their own gain. Now, I'm sharing the captivating stories and mysteries from my life, both personal and with those around me.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.