What is the Best Toy to Give a Dog?

Ever stared at a pet store shelf jam-packed with colorful balls, chew bones, squeaky things, and weirdly-shaped rubber gadgets—wondering, “What is the best toy to give my dog?” You’re not alone. With countless options, choosing the perfect toy can feel more complicated than it should. But don’t worry—we're here to break it all down for you in a way that’s fun, simple, and totally dog-approved.

Why Toys Matter

Mental Stimulation

Dogs are smart—some scary smart. If they’re not challenged mentally, boredom kicks in. That’s when you start seeing torn-up furniture or mysterious holes in the yard. Toys like puzzles and treat-dispensers keep their brains busy and prevent destructive habits.

Physical Exercise

Just like us, dogs need to move. Toys that get them running, jumping, or tugging are perfect for burning off energy and keeping them fit.

Emotional Comfort

A soft plushie can be a dog’s version of a security blanket. For pups dealing with separation anxiety or stress, toys provide comfort and companionship.

Behavioral Training

Toys aren’t just for fun—they can be tools. Chew toys teach what’s okay to bite. Tug toys can help with commands like “drop it” or “take it.”

Choosing the Right Toy by Age

Teething Puppies

Those tiny shark teeth hurt! Puppies need soft, chewy toys that soothe their gums. Try frozen rubber toys or special teething rings designed just for them.

Energetic Adults

Adults usually have the stamina of Olympic athletes. They thrive on interactive toys—think tug-of-war ropes, fetch balls, or puzzles that reward them with treats.

Gentle Seniors

Older dogs may have weaker teeth or arthritis, so go for plush or softer toys. Gentle chews or stuffed animals are perfect cuddle buddies.

Dog Personality Types and Toy Matches

The Chewer

Got a destroyer on your hands? Look for ultra-durable toys like Benebone, Goughnuts, or the classic KONG Extreme.

The Thinker

Smart pups love a challenge. Puzzle feeders, treat mazes, and interactive games like the Trixie Activity Board are great picks.

The Cuddler

These dogs just want a snuggle. Go for soft plush toys—bonus points if they squeak.

The Hunter

Instincts kick in with squeaky toys, faux fur, or toys that mimic prey. Hide-and-seek toys work wonders.

The Fetcher

Balls, frisbees, and flying discs are must-haves. Look for toys that bounce, squeak, or glow in the dark for extra excitement.

Toy Categories Explained

Chew Toys

Built tough and designed to satisfy the natural need to chew. They’re great for dental health and calming anxiety.

Interactive/Puzzle Toys

Perfect for mental stimulation. These often involve solving a problem to get a treat.

Tug Toys

Ideal for playtime with humans or other dogs. Just remember to play safe and avoid super aggressive pulling.

Fetch Toys

Made for chasing and retrieving. Balls, sticks, or aerodynamic frisbees are all stars in this category.

Plush Toys

Soft and huggable. These toys are comfort items—especially good for gentle or nervous dogs.

Treat-Dispensing Toys

Kill boredom and hunger in one go. These toys keep dogs entertained as they work to earn their treat.

Safety Guidelines When Choosing Dog Toys

Materials to Avoid

Stay away from toys made with:

BPA

Phthalates

Thin plastic or cheap rubber

Natural rubber and food-grade silicone are safer choices.

Size Matters

A toy that’s too small? Choking hazard. Always choose a size appropriate for your dog’s breed and jaw size. Order the best dog toys!

Supervised vs. Unsupervised Play

Some toys are only safe with supervision—like plush toys or rope toys that can unravel. Others, like solid chew toys, can be left with your dog.

Top Recommended Toys by Vets and Trainers

KONG Classic

The gold standard. Durable, stuffable, and comes in sizes for every dog.

Nylabone DuraChew

Long-lasting and great for dental hygiene. Especially good for strong chewers.

Outward Hound Puzzle Toys

These keep dogs mentally sharp. Ideal for curious, problem-solving pups.

Chuckit! Ultra Ball

Super durable, bouncy, and great for fetch. Better than a regular tennis ball by miles.

Eco-Friendly Dog Toy Options

Want to help the planet while spoiling your pup? Brands like West Paw, Beco, and Planet Dog make toys from recycled or sustainable materials that are still super fun.

DIY Dog Toys That Are Safe and Fun

On a budget or love a good DIY? Try:

Braided t-shirt tug ropes

Muffin tin treat puzzles

Frozen peanut butter in an ice cube tray

Just be sure not to use anything dangerous like string, batteries, or sharp parts.

Conclusion

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to “what’s the best toy to give a dog?” It depends on your dog’s age, breed, chewing style, and personality. The key is finding a toy that’s safe, fun, and suits your pup’s unique play style. Once you’ve found that toy—the one they won’t put down—you’ll know it. Until then, explore, experiment, and most importantly—play together.

FAQs

1. What is the safest toy for aggressive chewers?

The KONG Extreme and Goughnuts toys are some of the safest and most durable options for heavy chewers.

2. Can toys help reduce destructive behavior?

Absolutely. Toys provide an outlet for energy and stress, which often leads to less chewing of shoes or furniture.

3. How do I know if a toy is too small for my dog?

If your dog can fit the toy entirely in their mouth, it’s too small and poses a choking risk. Always size up.

4. Are squeaky toys good or bad for dogs?

Good in moderation! Some dogs love the squeak, but if they obsess or get aggressive, consider switching to silent options.

5. What’s the best toy for indoor play?

Soft fetch toys, tug ropes, and interactive puzzles are all perfect for keeping playtime indoors and safe.