Need an ESA Letter in New York? Here Are the 5 Most Trusted Services (2025)

Searching for a legitimate ESA letter provider in New York? It's not as simple as typing "best ESA letter website" into Google. Many sites offer fast approvals or discounted rates, but cut corners on legal requirements—leading to rejected letters and housing headaches.

To help you avoid scams and invalid documentation, we reviewed the most reliable ESA letter services available in New York. Here are the five platforms that deliver legal, trustworthy, and timely emotional support animal letters.

Top ESA Letter Services in New York

Choosing the wrong provider can cost you time, money, and peace of mind—especially if your landlord rejects the letter. The five services below stand out for their compliance, customer satisfaction, and speed of delivery.

Fast ESA Letter – Best overall service for fast, compliant ESA letters in NY

ESA Doctors – Reputable provider using a form-based evaluation system

ESA Pet – Straightforward online process with licensed providers

Pettable – Premium option with thorough mental health assessments

Certapet – Detailed evaluations and state-specific compliance

Let’s break down what makes each of these providers worth considering.

1. Fast ESA Letter – Best Overall ESA Letter Provider in New York

Fast ESA Letter offers a quick and fully legal process to get an ESA letter through a live consultation with a licensed mental health professional. Most users receive their letter within 24–48 hours, and there's a 100% money-back guarantee if you’re not approved. The platform also offers therapist support for landlord disputes—a rare but valuable perk.

Pros:

• 24–48 hour turnaround time
• Fully compliant with FHA and HIPAA standards
• Real-time consultation with licensed providers
• Transparent pricing with no hidden costs
• 24/7 live chat support
• Full refund if not approved
• Ongoing therapist support for housing issues

Cons:

• Additional fees for multiple animals

2. ESA Doctors – Trusted ESA Letter Provider in New York

ESA Doctors uses a form-based system where you answer detailed questions before being matched with a licensed provider. While reliable, this method can be slower than real-time consultations. Support is limited to business hours, and expedited options come with extra fees.

Pros:

• Licensed in-state mental health professionals
• Offers expedited processing (additional cost)
• Good for users preferring a form-based evaluation

Cons:

• Slower approval times
• No 24/7 support
• Occasional delays in communication

3. ESA Pet – Easy Online Process for ESA Letters in NY

ESA Pet keeps the process simple. After filling out a short intake form, a licensed therapist evaluates your case based on New York regulations. Standard delivery takes a couple of days, but expedited options are available (for an extra fee). It’s a reliable service, although the added charges may not suit tight budgets.

Pros:

• Complies with FHA standards
• Licensed provider reviews and signs each letter
• Straightforward and user-friendly platform

Cons:

• Therapist support for disputes costs extra
• No round-the-clock customer service
• Only partial refunds if not approved

4. Pettable – Premium Mental Health Evaluations for ESA Letters

Pettable emphasizes thorough evaluations with a live consultation included. It’s one of the more expensive options on this list but comes with a money-back guarantee. However, users needing fast turnaround or landlord follow-up support might find it lacking in those areas.

Pros:

• ESA letters valid under federal housing laws
• Direct consultation with licensed professionals
• Full refund if not approved

Cons:

• $199 base price—higher than average
• Expedited delivery costs extra
• No post-approval therapist support
• Intake process can feel slow

5. Certapet – In-Depth ESA Screening for New York Residents

Certapet starts with a thorough mental health screening and connects you to licensed providers familiar with New York laws. While the process is entirely online, turnaround times vary depending on demand, and customer service isn't always immediately accessible.

Pros:

• Letters comply with Fair Housing Act
• Licensed professionals in every U.S. state
• Fully remote process, no in-person visits required

Cons:

• Processing fee deducted from refunds
• Delivery can exceed 48 hours during peak times
• Limited support hours and occasional tech issues

How We Chose the Best ESA Letter Services in New York

Not all ESA letter platforms are created equal. To ensure you're working with a provider that delivers legitimate, landlord-accepted documentation, we used the following criteria:

• Licensed mental health professionals based in New York
• Compliance with FHA and HIPAA standards
• Transparent, upfront pricing
• Delivery within 24–48 hours
• Accessible, reliable customer support

Fast ESA Letter emerged as our top pick due to its speed, compliance, and added therapist support—all at a fair price.

How to Get an ESA Letter in New York (Step-by-Step with Fast ESA Letter)

Step 1: Schedule a Consultation

Book an online audio or video call with a licensed mental health provider based in New York—no in-person visits required.

Step 2: Complete the Evaluation

During your consultation, the provider will assess your mental health and determine whether an emotional support animal would benefit your condition.

Step 3: Receive Your ESA Letter

If approved, you’ll get your ESA letter via email within 24–48 hours. If not, you’ll receive a full refund—making the process risk-free.

Final Thoughts

Getting an ESA letter in New York means choosing a service that connects you with licensed professionals and follows legal guidelines. While all five platforms reviewed offer valid letters, Fast ESA Letter stands out for its fast turnaround, transparent process, and ongoing support.

Choose the provider that best aligns with your urgency, budget, and support needs—and secure your housing rights with confidence.