Why Do I Struggle to Multitask Effectively, No Matter How Hard I Try?

**I Thought I Was Great at Multitasking – Until I Learned the Truth**

I have to admit, I’ve often been reminded that “men can’t multitask; only women can.” This has, at times, sparked heated discussions—ones I usually lost because I didn’t have the right arguments to debunk the myth.

The word “multitasking” wasn’t something I heard much growing up. Even in the early days of computing, multitasking wasn’t really possible. The first attempts at multitasking with computers happened in 1961, but back then, computers were far from common. As a result, the term “multitasking” wasn’t part of everyday language. It wasn’t until the rise of microprocessors in the 1980s that multitasking became a central feature of computing. That’s also when the word started to be used more often in a broader sense, meaning doing two things at once. And of course, people would say, “Men can’t do that—only women can.”

**Multitasking**

The word itself suggests efficiency. Who wouldn’t want to be the person who can do everything at once? For years, I was convinced I was a multitasking expert. I could work on multiple projects, answer messages while eating lunch, and jump between tasks throughout the day without hesitation. I felt productive, indispensable, and in control.

But then came a day that changed everything—a day when I realized this “superpower” I thought I had was actually my biggest weakness. Suddenly, I started noticing small mistakes, forgotten details, and even repeating tasks out of sheer confusion.

**The Myth of Multitasking**

We live in a culture and time that celebrates multitasking. From a young age, we’re encouraged to “make the most of our time” and stay busy. How often have you heard someone say, “You should be able to do two things at once!”? Technology also makes it easier—and more tempting—than ever to split our attention: a vibrating phone, a new email notification, or a message from a colleague on Teams. Everything demands immediate attention.

For me, multitasking became a way to prove I was “capable.” I thought working on several things at once made me more efficient. But research—and my own experience—has shown me that multitasking is an illusion. Our brains simply aren’t built to handle two demanding tasks at the same time. Instead, we switch focus back and forth, and this constant shifting reduces both efficiency and quality.

**The Moment the Bubble Burst**

Not long ago, I decided to make a list of everything I needed to do on a typical day. I had a main project to work on, but throughout the day, I also planned to respond to emails, organize meetings, update a blog post, review reports, and, of course, deal with minor “quick tasks” on my phone. I felt like a master organizer.

But at the end of the day, as I reviewed my list, I realized something: I had barely completed anything.

What was supposed to be a productive day felt like complete chaos. Not only that, but I had made mistakes on several tasks, which I then had to correct later. My brain felt overloaded, like an overworked hard drive, and I was exhausted. That’s when I began to question: Is this really a sustainable way to work?

**The Truth About Multitasking**

After that day, I started looking deeper into what actually happens when we multitask. Here are some key things I learned—and why I was feeling so drained and ineffective:

1. **The Brain’s Limitations**: The brain can only focus on one thing at a time when it comes to complex tasks. When we try to do multiple things, our brain quickly switches back and forth between them. This takes time and energy, making us less productive.

2. **More Mistakes**: Multitasking increases the risk of errors because we don’t give each task the attention it needs.

3. **Stress and Burnout**: Constant task-switching can lead to higher stress levels. We feel like we’re never getting anything done, creating a cycle of frustration and eventually burnout.

4. **Lost Time**: Studies show that multitasking can reduce productivity by up to 40%. Every time we switch focus, our brain needs time to “retrain” itself, and these small delays add up quickly.

**What I Was Doing Wrong**

Looking back, I can clearly see the mistakes I made:

• **I didn’t prioritize**: Everything felt equally important, so I tried to do it all at once.

• **I underestimated how long tasks would take**: A “quick” email or “small” update ended up consuming most of my day.

• **I worked without breaks**: I thought working nonstop would help me get more done, but it just left me tired and less effective.

• **I overloaded myself with information**: Between notifications, messages, and social media, my mind became a cluttered mess.

**How I Turned Things Around**

Breaking the habit of multitasking wasn’t easy. It’s a reflex, especially in a world where interruptions are constant. But I made a few changes that helped me work smarter and stay more focused:

**1. Focus on One Task at a Time**

Instead of trying to do everything at once, I started focusing on just one task at a time. I now use a method called **time-blocking**, where I dedicate specific time slots to individual tasks. During that time, I focus solely on that one thing.

**2. Create a “Do Not Disturb” Zone**

Notifications are multitasking’s worst enemy. I’ve turned off unnecessary alerts and put my phone on silent or airplane mode while I work. This has made a huge difference in my ability to stay focused.

**3. Take Breaks**

It might sound cliché, but taking breaks really does make you more productive. I now follow the **Pomodoro Technique**, where I work for 25 minutes and then take a 5-minute break. This helps me avoid burnout and keep my energy up.

**4. Say No to Unnecessary Tasks**

A big part of multitasking comes from trying to do too much. I’ve learned to say no to tasks that aren’t important or delegate them to others.

**5. Plan the Day the Night Before**

In evening, I make a list of the three most important things I want to accomplish the next day. This helps me start the day with clear focus and resist the urge to multitask.

**How You Can Avoid the Multitasking Trap**

If my story sounds familiar, it’s not too late to make changes. Here are a few tips you can try:

• **Start Small**: Dedicate just one hour a day to focusing on a single task without interruptions. See how it feels.

• **Analyze Your Habits**: Notice when you multitask the most, and try to figure out what triggers it.

• **Practice Mindfulness**: Mindfulness exercises can help strengthen your ability to focus on one thing at a time.

• **Use Technology to Your Advantage**: Apps like Focus@Will or Freedom can help limit distractions.

**What I’ve Learned**

Since I stopped multitasking, I’ve noticed big changes. My workdays feel less stressful, and I finish tasks faster. Not only that, but the quality of my work has improved.

I also have more time for what really matters. Instead of being stuck in a constant state of “doing,” I can now enjoy small moments—both at work and in my personal life.

**Conclusion: Multitasking Is an Illusion**

Multitasking might seem like a shortcut to getting more done, but the truth is, it costs us more than it gives. When we try to do everything at once, we end up doing less—and doing it poorly.

If you’ve felt trapped in the multitasking cycle, I hope my story inspires you to try something new. It takes effort to break the habit, but the rewards are worth it: more focus, better results, and a less stressful day.

So next time you’re tempted to do multiple things at once, pause and ask yourself: What’s the one thing I can do right now—and do it well? That’s the real path to success.

Feel free to click the heart button in this post so more people can discover it on Substack. Tell me what you think in the comments?

I will write to you a message if you subscribe to my newsletters.