Poker Face" Season Two: A Stylish Whodunnit That Nearly Cracks the Case for Greatness

Poker Face Season Two Review – Natasha Lyonne's Hilarious Detective Series Is Painfully Close to Being a Classic

There are very few shows in the streaming era that can juggle style, substance, and an old-school format with as much swagger as Poker Face. From the brain of creator Rian Johnson and starring eternally-watchable lead Natasha Lyonne, season one of Poker Face made a big splash—it was a postmodern-throwback homage to the "case-of-the-week" format made famous by such then-hits as Columbo and Murder, She Wrote. Season two of Poker Face hardly strays from that formula. It even ups the ante on everything season one did right. And yet, for all its humor, wit, and unmistakable personality, it still falls short of greatness.

The Return of Charlie Cale

Natasha Lyonne reprises the role of Charlie Cale, a root-ravin' voiceless human lie detector with above-average senses for a career cop. Her skill, which lets her detect lying even before other characters do, is the wry narrative tic of the series—but it's the performance itself by Lyonne that keeps matters humble. Half globe-weary, half determined principled, she stumbles into crimes as much a rootin'-tootin' Miss Marple but with a cigarette pack.

Season two continues with Charlie on the move, every episode dropping her in a new town, new job, and new murder mystery. The self-contained nature of every episode is newly welcome in our binge-saturated TV culture. You don't require a flowchart to keep up with what's going down, and the procedural nature provides room for fresh faces, feels, and locations in each episode.

A Better Handle on Tone and Direction

If season one of Poker Face was an exploration of what kind of show it was going to be, season two is more confident. Johnson and the rotating roster of directors (several of whom return from season one) have found a more even keel on pacing and tone. The scripts are tightened up, the jokes land better, and even the campier moments have a pay-off rather than just indulgence.

The look is still unique—rich camera work, mid-century design flourishes, and fashionably edited soundtracks provide the show with a retro appearance. It doesn't look like anything else currently on television. The off-center Americana atmosphere is more than skin-deep; it's part of the show's genetic makeup.

Star-Studded Guest Appearances

The most endearing aspect of Poker Face, perhaps, is its refusal to dominate the headlines for regulars. Season two is no exception, featuring a murderers' row of guest stars who are in their zone to play against type. Take Judy Greer playing a small-town grifter or Brian Tyree Henry playing an ethically compromised chef. The performers infuse the weekly whodunits with a certain life and make even the most rudimentary episodes sparkle.

However, this reliance on guest-star cameos is also one of the show's weaknesses. Certain episodes are quite simply better than others, and where the guest star fails, the episode does as well. Unlike more serial-driven shows, Poker Face goes up or down on the strengths of its weekly story. At its best, it's a ballad. At its worst, it's background noise more than a requirement for viewing.

Close, But Not Quite a Classic

What keeps Poker Face from being a true classic? Ironically, it's the very structure that makes it feel so new. The episodic style, while cute and vintage, at times hinders deeper character development. Charlie doesn't grow significantly over the course of, her transformation gradual and slight. Though effective thematically—Charlie's a loner, after all, so no shock—at times it leaves us yearning for depth, more in peril, more return emotionally.

Also, larger narrative regarding Charlie's hunters still feels incomplete. Season two promises bigger conspiracies and emotional resolutions, but they're kept mostly at arm's length. We wish there was more connective tissue, more closure for Charlie's arc beyond her role as a rogue sleuth with an appetite for justice.

A Show That Loves Its Audience

Despite its flaws, Poker Face is a seriously good time. It's a show that makes its viewers smart enough to appreciate character tic, slow burns, and retro aesthetic. In a world gone overproduced with spectacle fatigue and lore dumping ad infinitum, that is a radical kind of subtlety. Rian Johnson and Natasha Lyonne have crafted something smart but not arrogant, a good time that never feels lightweight.

Season two won't launch Poker Face into the TV pantheon yet, maybe, but it proves that the show is not one-hit wonder material. With a touch more narrative heft and emotional payoff, season three could well turn a near-classic into a real one.

Final Verdict:

Poker Face Season Two is a crazily watchable, stylish, and cleverly written show that continues to break the rules on television. It's not exactly a masterpiece—but it's only a heartbeat behind.

BUY Products