I Lied to Fit In — And It Worked Too Well

It started small, like most lies do.

I told a group of classmates in 7th grade that I loved a band I’d never listened to. They were obsessed, so I nodded along, memorizing the names they mentioned so I could Google them later and keep the act going. I went home, downloaded the songs, and tried my best to like them. I didn’t hate them. I just didn’t care.

But they cared. They looked at me differently after that day—like I had passed some invisible test. They started inviting me to things. I got a seat at lunch. I wasn’t invisible anymore.

And it felt good.

That was the beginning of it.

The lies got easier, faster, subtler. I learned how to be whoever the room needed me to be. If you liked books, I was suddenly a reader. If you played sports, I “used to play soccer but quit last year.” If you were into makeup, I watched tutorials at night and studied the products until I could speak your language. I mirrored people like a survival instinct.

And it worked.

I became the kind of person everyone liked. The funny one, the easy one, the reliable one. I was fluent in belonging, fluent in masking. But every now and then, in between the conversations and laughter, I’d feel something twist in my stomach—a strange kind of grief.

I wasn’t sure what I was grieving. Not then.

By the time I reached college, I had perfected it. I could shift seamlessly between versions of myself: the quiet intellectual in one class, the party-friendly roommate on weekends, the empathetic listener with friends. I had opinions, but only the agreeable ones. I had preferences, but they were flexible. I had limits, but I kept them soft, so they wouldn’t offend.

I told myself it was normal. That everyone did this, to some extent. That I was just adaptable.

But one night, my roommate walked in and saw me sitting on the floor of our shared bathroom, mascara-streaked and silent. She didn’t say anything at first—just sat beside me and passed me a tissue.

“What’s wrong?” she asked softly.

And for the first time in years, I said the truth:

“I don’t know who I am anymore.”

She blinked. “What do you mean?”

I tried to explain it, fumbling over the words. “I mean… I know what everyone thinks I am. But I’m not sure which parts are real and which parts I made up to be liked. And the worst part is—it worked. Everyone likes me. But I don’t even like me. Because I don’t know me.”

I expected her to laugh, or at least look confused.

But instead, she said, “That sounds exhausting.”

And I broke.

Because it *was* exhausting. Pretending to care about things I didn’t, laughing at jokes I didn’t find funny, agreeing to plans I didn’t enjoy, maintaining a reputation that didn’t reflect anything about my actual heart.

I had created a version of myself so polished, so easy to love, that even I forgot it was an act.

The lie had become my life.

And when I realized that, I also realized how lonely it had been. Because no matter how many friends I had, no matter how many people smiled when I entered a room—I wasn’t being seen. They liked the costume. The character. Not the person underneath.

I made a decision that night, sitting on a cold tile floor, wiping my eyes with the sleeve of someone else’s sweatshirt: I was done pretending.

I started small. I told a friend I didn’t actually like the show we always watched together. She laughed and said, “Finally. I thought you were faking it.” That was both mortifying and freeing.

I told someone else I didn’t want to go out that weekend. I stayed home, read a book I actually enjoyed, and felt more peace than I’d felt in years.

Little by little, I peeled back the layers. It wasn’t easy. Some people noticed. Some didn’t like the change. A few faded away. That hurt—but it also made space for the people who stayed, who saw the real me and didn’t flinch.

And most importantly, I started liking myself. Not because I was perfect or popular or impressive. But because I was finally honest. And that honesty, shaky as it was, felt like the beginning of freedom.

Now, when I meet new people, I don’t try to mold myself to them. I don’t fake interests or exaggerate stories. I don’t say yes when I mean no.

And if that means I don’t get the seat at the table—I build a new one.

It took me years to realize this, but I’d rather be alone as myself than loved as someone I’m not.

And weirdly enough? The more honest I became, the more I attracted people who liked the real me all along.

Turns out, I wasn’t too much. I wasn’t boring or difficult or wrong.

I just wasn’t giving people a chance to know me.

But now I am.

And I’m still learning. Still unlearning. Still making peace with the parts of me I once buried. But at least I know who I am now.

And she’s worth the wait.

---

Moral:

When you pretend to be someone else to belong, you may lose the one person who matters most—you. But it’s never too late to return to yourself, no matter how long you’ve been gone.