Horror logo

Unsolved Mysteries That Will Keep You Up at Night

Mysteries are all around us, from everyday oddities to baffling cases that remain unsolved. This list delves into some of the most perplexing and eerie mysteries that still defy explanation.

By THiNKPublished about a year ago 4 min read

Mysteries are all around us, sometimes in the most mundane places. Just the other day, I lost a hat at a crowded café. I left it on my seat while I went to the bathroom for two minutes, and when I returned, it had vanished. Despite a room full of people, no one saw a thing. While this is a light-hearted example, there are far more perplexing mysteries that remain unsolved. Today, I’ve compiled a list of some truly mind-boggling cases that, despite years of investigation, still have no explanation. And as always, the deeper you dive, the creepier it gets.

1. The Vanishing Wrecking Ball (1974)

Indianapolis, 1974: The Dowling Construction Company workers left their site at the end of a typical day, their equipment ready for the next morning’s work. Among their tools was a 5-ton steel wrecking ball, hanging from a crane 200 feet in the air. When the crew returned the next day, the ball was gone.

No one heard a thing. There were no tire tracks, no signs of tampering, and no crater indicating that the ball had fallen. The workers and the police were baffled. How do you steal a 10,000-pound wrecking ball without leaving any clues? Despite investigations, the wrecking ball was never recovered. To this day, it remains a bizarre theft case that many locals remember as both absurd and eerie.

Some theorists have suggested that an interdimensional event or time travelers could have played a role. However, the truth remains buried with the mystery, and we’ll likely never know who stole the wrecking ball or why.

2. Kidnapped by Sasquatch (1924)

In 1924, Albert Ostman, a logger and construction worker, set out for a vacation unlike any other. While most people today might opt for a beach getaway, Ostman ventured into the wilds of British Columbia in search of a rumored lost gold mine. His journey took an unexpected turn when he encountered something that still haunts him—Sasquatch.

According to Ostman, he was camping when a strange creature picked him up—still inside his sleeping bag—and carried him for hours. When he finally wriggled free, he found himself face-to-face with what he described as a Sasquatch family. The creatures, covered in hair and towering over seven feet tall, kept him in their valley for six days. Ostman was eventually able to escape, but his encounter left him shaken.

What’s fascinating about this story is that it occurred long before Sasquatch became a meme or a pop culture phenomenon. His detailed descriptions match similar reports from the same area, which surfaced years later. Whether he was truly kidnapped by Bigfoot or had some other strange experience, his story remains one of the most well-documented Sasquatch encounters in history.

3. The Disappearance of Brandon Swanson (2008)

Brandon Swanson’s case is one that chills the spine. On the night of May 14, 2008, 19-year-old Brandon was driving home from a party in rural Minnesota when he accidentally drove into a ditch. Unable to get his car out, he called his parents for help. They stayed on the phone with him as he attempted to walk to a nearby town.

Suddenly, during the call, Brandon exclaimed, “Oh, sh*t!” and the line went dead. His parents frantically tried to call him back, but there was no answer. Despite extensive searches, no one has seen or heard from Brandon since that night. His car was found, but there were no signs of foul play or evidence to explain his disappearance.

The last words on the phone still haunt those who investigate the case. What did he see? Why did he vanish so suddenly? To this day, no traces of Brandon have been found, and his disappearance remains an open mystery.

4. The YOGTZE Case (1984)

In 1984, Günther Stoll, a German food engineer, scribbled the letters "YOGTZE" on a piece of paper moments before his death. Earlier, Stoll had confided to his wife that he believed someone was after him, though he never explained who or why.

On the night of his death, Stoll suddenly jumped up from his chair, wrote the cryptic message, and left his home. Hours later, he was found fatally injured in his car, which had crashed into a ditch. According to eyewitnesses, two men were seen at the scene, but they were never identified.

What made the case even stranger was the discovery that Stoll had been hit by a car *twice*—once before the crash and again afterward. The meaning of “YOGTZE” has never been deciphered, and the identity of the mysterious men remains unknown. The case is one of the most bizarre unsolved mysteries in German history.

5. The Sodder Children Disappearance (1945)

On Christmas Eve, 1945, a fire consumed the home of George and Jennie Sodder in West Virginia. Five of their ten children were believed to have perished in the fire, but no remains were ever found in the ashes. The fire department concluded the blaze was caused by faulty wiring, but the Sodders were convinced their children had been kidnapped.

Over the years, the family received strange clues—a photograph of a boy resembling one of the missing children, mysterious phone calls, and reports of sightings. Despite decades of searching, the fate of the Sodder children remains a mystery. The case continues to captivate amateur sleuths and conspiracy theorists alike, as questions linger about what truly happened that night.

Unsolved mysteries like these challenge our perception of the world and leave us wondering just how much we really know. Whether it’s stolen wrecking balls, Sasquatch kidnappings, or cryptic messages like “YOGTZE,” these strange occurrences remind us that the world is still full of the unknown. And perhaps, the next mystery is waiting just around the corner.

footagemonsterpsychologicalsupernaturalslasher

About the Creator

THiNK

Think - Your go-to destination for exploring captivating mysteries, insightful psychology, intriguing facts, and the latest news. Our mission is to spark curiosity and inspire learning. Join us as we uncover the unknown!

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.