The Problem With Modern Horror Movies

Modern horror movies have faced criticism for several key reasons that many fans feel detract from the genre’s effectiveness. These issues range from over-reliance on certain tropes to a lack of fresh storytelling and character development. Here’s a breakdown of some of the most common problems:

1. Overuse of Jump Scares

One of the most common complaints is the overuse of jump scares. While an occasional jump scare can enhance a scene, modern horror films tend to rely on them heavily. This tactic can feel like a shortcut for genuine fear-building, as it startles viewers but doesn’t create a lasting sense of dread. Movies like Hereditary and The Witch have proven that subtle, atmospheric horror can be far more effective at unsettling audiences.

2. Predictable Tropes and Clichés

Modern horror films often recycle familiar clichés. For example, characters repeatedly making poor decisions (like splitting up in dangerous situations) or the all-too-common haunted house setting are predictable. These tropes have become so ingrained in horror that they sometimes make the plot feel formulaic, reducing suspense and surprise. Horror is most effective when it defies expectations, and the genre suffers when it falls back on overused tropes.

3. Focus on Franchises and Remakes

In recent years, studios have leaned heavily on sequels, prequels, and reboots of classic horror movies. While this can attract nostalgic fans, it also limits creativity in the genre. Audiences can often predict the direction of these films, which takes away from the sense of unknown terror that horror thrives on. The constant revisiting of Halloween, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, and The Conjuring franchise, for example, can overshadow original storytelling that brings fresh fear to viewers.

4. Lack of Character Development

Many horror movies focus on scares at the expense of character depth. Without well-developed characters, it’s hard for audiences to empathize or feel genuine concern for their fates. Classic horror films often made us care deeply about the characters before putting them in terrifying situations, which heightened the impact of the horror. A strong example is A Quiet Place, which gives enough background on its characters’ relationships and struggles that viewers feel invested in their survival.

5. Overemphasis on Visuals and CGI

Modern horror films tend to rely on special effects and CGI for monsters and gore. While this can add a certain visual appeal, it often detracts from the sense of realism. Practical effects and well-crafted settings can create a more immersive experience, as seen in The Thing (1982) or Alien (1979). The overuse of digital effects can sometimes make modern horror feel artificial or “safe,” reducing the visceral fear factor.

6. Straying from Psychological Horror

Horror has always been about exploring the unknown or the uncomfortable aspects of human nature. Modern horror often focuses more on supernatural or gory elements rather than psychological depth. Films that explore themes of grief, guilt, or existential dread can leave a longer-lasting impression than those that rely solely on supernatural horror. Movies like Get Out and Midsommar have been praised for exploring societal and psychological horror, which resonates more deeply with audiences.

7. Misuse of “Elevated Horror”

Recently, some horror films have been marketed as “elevated horror,” implying they have more artistic merit or intellectual depth than typical horror. This term can be dismissive of traditional horror and alienate fans who feel the genre doesn’t need to justify its existence. Great horror comes in many forms, whether it’s an artful exploration of trauma or a straightforward slasher film. The distinction can also lead filmmakers to focus on style over substance, resulting in films that feel pretentious or overly complex without delivering genuine fear.

8. Overly Long Running Times

Many modern horror movies have extended running times, which can dilute their impact. Horror is most effective when it’s tight and intense, maintaining suspense without over-explaining. Stretching out the plot with too much exposition or subplots can cause the narrative to lose focus, detracting from the horror elements. Films like The Ring and Paranormal Activity work well because they build tension without overstaying their welcome.

9. Not Taking Risks with New Ideas

Horror has always thrived on innovation and creativity, but many modern films play it safe, sticking to familiar structures and predictable endings. This lack of originality can make horror feel repetitive, failing to tap into new fears that could resonate with contemporary audiences. Films like It Follows and The Babadook stand out because they take creative risks, presenting new ways of exploring fear and horror.

Conclusion

Despite these issues, there are still many modern horror films that push boundaries and deliver fresh scares. Directors like Jordan Peele and Ari Aster have shown that there’s room for creativity and depth within horror. When filmmakers prioritize character, atmosphere, and innovative storytelling, they can create horror that leaves a lasting impact. Horror is at its best when it taps into universal fears and emotions, giving audiences something to think about long after the credits roll.