Horror logo

The Creepy Doll Contest Is Back—And It’s Time to Choose the Most Terrifying Toy

The Creepy Doll Contest Is Back—And It’s Time to Choose the Most Terrifying Toy

By Riaz hossin RafiPublished 9 months ago 2 min read
The Creepy Doll Contest Is Back—And It’s Time to Choose the Most Terrifying Toy
Photo by Erik Mclean on Unsplash

The Creepy Doll Contest Is Back—And It’s Time to Choose the Most Terrifying Toy

A dark room. A broken chair. And in the corner sits an old doll—its glassy eyes staring right at you, as if trying to say something. If you’ve ever felt even a little uneasy looking at an old, worn-out doll, then get ready for one of the strangest and spookiest events of the year: The Creepy Doll Contest is back!

Every year, people from around the world cast their votes to crown the most haunting, unsettling, and downright disturbing doll. The winner receives the title of “Creepiest Doll of the Year.” This contest is not just about horror—it's about laughter, nostalgia, and those eerie childhood memories etched into the silent faces of forgotten toys.

What Is the Creepy Doll Contest?

It all started at a local museum, which housed a unique antique toy collection. Among the items were a few dolls so bizarre and unsettling that the staff jokingly created a poll: “Which doll is the creepiest?”

The response was overwhelming. What began as a light-hearted game quickly turned into a viral tradition. Now, each year, new entries are put forward and the public is invited to vote—whether they’re horror fans, antique lovers, or simply thrill-seekers.

This Year’s Contestants—Faces of Fear

The 2025 lineup includes some truly nightmarish contenders that feel like they’ve stepped straight out of a horror film:

"Margaret the Watcher" – A Victorian porcelain doll with a slightly tilted neck and glassy, lifelike eyes that seem to follow your every move.

"Rusty Pete" – A metal clown toy with peeling paint and a frozen smile that never fades—though no one knows why.

"Lila in the Window" – Discovered in the attic of an old mansion. Locals say she would mysteriously appear by the window whenever it rained—without anyone placing her there.


Each doll comes with a backstory, a mysterious past, and secrets that make you wonder: are these just old toys… or something more?

How to Vote

If you’re brave enough to face these creepy contestants, head over to [official website] to view their photos and eerie descriptions. Every doll has a name, an origin story, and yes—close-up images of their haunting faces to help you make your choice.

You can vote once a day until [last date]. The winning doll will be announced in a special livestream event—where people will be laughing nervously while their skin crawls with fear.

Why Are We So Obsessed With Creepy Dolls?

Psychologists say dolls scare us because of a phenomenon called the "uncanny valley"—that psychological space where something looks almost human, but not quite. It’s familiar, yet disturbingly off.

And when a doll is aged—its face cracked, its eyes dulled, its clothes worn—it stops being just a toy. It becomes a story. An unsolved mystery. A lifeless companion holding not just memories, but maybe even secrets.

Your Vote Could Become Part of a Legend

So this year, don’t just be a spectator—be part of the legend. Cast your vote. The doll you choose could become the next horror short film star. Or maybe… it’ll appear in your dreams.

interviewhow to

About the Creator

Riaz hossin Rafi

t

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.