Horror logo

The Christmas Mirror

The McAllister family

By ModhilrajPublished about a year ago 4 min read
The Christmas Mirror
Photo by Marc-Olivier Jodoin on Unsplash

The McAllister family was thrilled to be spending Christmas in their newly purchased Victorian house. The old home, nestled on the outskirts of town, came with creaky floorboards and drafty windows but exuded an undeniable charm. This year’s holiday promised to be perfect, with snow gently falling outside and the scent of fresh pine wafting through the air.

On Christmas Eve, as the family gathered in the living room to exchange gifts, a deliveryman arrived at the door, carrying a large, rectangular package. The sender was anonymous, but the attached note read:

“For the McAllister's, to bring light to your Christmas. From a friend.”

Intrigued, they unwrapped the package to reveal an ornate antique mirror. Its gilded frame was adorned with intricate carvings of holly leaves and cherubs, and the glass shimmered faintly, even in the dim light of the room.

“It’s beautiful,” said Claire McAllister, the matriarch of the family. Her husband, David, frowned slightly.

“A bit old-fashioned, don’t you think?” he asked.

“That’s what makes it special,” Claire replied, already imagining where it might hang in their home.

The First Glimpse

The mirror was placed above the fireplace, becoming the centerpiece of the room. As the family settled in for the evening, Claire’s teenage daughter, Lily, couldn’t resist inspecting her reflection.

“It’s weird,” Lily said, tilting her head. “The reflection looks...off.”

Her brother, Max, rolled his eyes. “It’s just an old mirror. Chill out.”

But Lily’s unease deepened as she stared into the glass. For a moment, her reflection’s expression didn’t match her own. Instead, it grinned maliciously, its eyes glinting with malice. She gasped and stumbled back.

“Are you okay?” Claire asked, concerned.

“Yeah,” Lily said quickly, shaking her head. “I’m probably just tired.”

But as the night wore on, she couldn’t shake the feeling that the mirror was watching her.

Reflections of Fear

The next day, Christmas morning arrived, and the family gathered around the tree to open presents. The mirror remained silent and unassuming, its polished surface gleaming in the morning light. Yet, as the day progressed, strange occurrences began.

David, while passing by the mirror, caught a glimpse of himself in his work clothes, exhausted and defeated. On closer inspection, he saw himself older, gaunt, and entirely alone. The vision disappeared the moment he blinked, but it left him shaken.

That evening, Max peered into the mirror and froze. Reflected behind him was a shadowy figure, its face obscured, standing just inches away. Whipping around, he found no one there. But when he looked back, the figure remained in the glass, closer than before.

Claire, too, began to notice anomalies. In the mirror, she saw herself holding a lifeless body, her hands stained red. No matter how much she tried to convince herself it was a trick of the light, the image refused to fade.

The family’s unease grew with every passing hour, but they were too afraid to speak of it, each thinking they might be imagining things.

The First to Disappear

That night, as the family slept, Lily was drawn to the mirror by an invisible force. Her feet moved as if of their own accord, and despite her fear, she couldn’t resist the urge to look.

When she gazed into the glass, the reflection showed her standing alone in an endless void. Slowly, shadowy hands emerged from the darkness, reaching for her. She screamed, but no sound came out. The hands gripped her shoulders and pulled her backward—into the mirror.

The next morning, Claire found Lily’s bed empty. The family searched the house frantically, but there was no sign of her. It wasn’t until Claire glanced at the mirror that she saw her daughter’s face, pressed against the inside of the glass, her mouth open in a silent plea for help.

The Mirror’s Curse

Panic set in as the family realized the mirror was no ordinary antique. David tried to smash it with a hammer, but the glass remained unscathed. Instead, a deep crack formed—not on the surface, but within the reflection, spreading like a spiderweb.

“What does it want?” Claire whispered, tears streaming down her face.

That night, Max’s curiosity got the better of him. He approached the mirror, desperate to see his sister again. As he stared into the glass, Lily’s reflection appeared, her face twisted in fear.

“Help me,” she mouthed.

Without thinking, Max reached out. The moment his fingers touched the glass, the surface rippled like water, and he was pulled inside. His scream echoed through the room, then silence fell.

The Final Confrontation

Claire and David were beside themselves with grief. Determined to end the mirror’s reign of terror, they scoured the internet for answers. They discovered a legend about a cursed artisan who had crafted mirrors to trap the souls of the guilty. The only way to break the curse was to confront the artisan within the mirror’s world.

“We have to go in,” Claire said. “It’s the only way to save them.”

Hand in hand, Claire and David stood before the mirror. Together, they stepped forward, the glass swallowing them whole.

Inside, they found themselves in a labyrinth of reflections, each surface showing distorted versions of their lives. Shadows moved within the glass, whispering their deepest regrets and fears. At the center of the maze stood the artisan, his face hidden beneath a hood.

“Why are you doing this?” Claire demanded.

The artisan’s voice was cold and hollow. “I reveal the truth. Your family’s darkness brought you here.”

“Take us instead,” David pleaded. “Let our children go.”

The artisan considered this, then nodded. “A trade,” he said. “Your lives for theirs.”

Breaking the Curse

With a final glance at each other, Claire and David agreed. The artisan waved his hand, and the mirror’s surface shimmered. Lily and Max were ejected back into the living room, gasping for air. The mirror’s glass cracked violently, then shattered, leaving only the empty frame behind.

Lily and Max searched for their parents, but they were gone, their sacrifice ensuring their children’s safety.

The McAllister house remained quiet after that Christmas, the broken mirror a stark reminder of the price they paid. On cold winter nights, some say you can hear faint whispers near the empty frame—echoes of the parents who gave everything to save their family.

book reviewsfictionfootagehalloweenhow tointerviewmonsterpop culturemovie review

About the Creator

Modhilraj

Modhilraj writes lifestyle-inspired horror where everyday routines slowly unravel into dread. His stories explore fear hidden in habits, homes, and quiet moments—because the most unsettling horrors live inside normal life.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.