Horror logo

One Night. One Rule. And One Secret Too Many.

A Mansion. A Secret. A Legacy She can't Escape.

By Gift Abotsi Published 9 months ago 3 min read



Emily thought it was just a simple babysitting job. One night. One rule. But the mansion she entered held secrets darker than she could imagine. A cursed legacy. A child lost to time. And a bloodline she couldn't escape.



Just one night.
That should do the trick—at least that’s what Emily thought as she packed for her one-night babysitting adventure.
$200 for a few hours? More than enough to clear a few bills.

Emily Hayes, 20, a third-year college student, had been browsing babysitting offers from wealthy families. The weight of student loans and rent hung heavy. She was kind, reliable, and honestly? A little desperate.

When she arrived at the mansion, she met the woman who hired her: Elara Whitmore.
Elegant. Composed. But something about her was…off.
Detached. Almost too rehearsed.

“Stay in the nursery after 8 p.m.,” she warned.
“No matter what.”

The house itself was cold, layered with dust like it hadn’t been touched in years.
She heard soft creaks on the staircase, like someone—or something—was following her.

“Old houses creak, right?” she whispered, forcing a laugh.

But nothing about this felt normal.

When Emily stepped into the nursery, everything in her screamed wrong.
The door was already open.
Portraits lined the walls, each face scratched out violently.
A dusty mobile turned lazily above an empty crib.
Old toys sat motionless... for now.

“Not a typical kid’s room,” she muttered.
She couldn’t shake the feeling that Elara was watching her.

But what unsettled her most was this:
There was no child.

Just aging toys, a cracked rocking horse, and a half-open music box that began to play on its own.

Then came the cry.
Faint at first—then louder. Louder. Impossible to ignore.

Shadows shifted unnaturally along the walls. Emily’s chest tightened. She reached for her phone to text her roommate, to joke about being in a horror movie.
No signal.
But this wasn’t some off-grid cabin—it was in town.

The nursery light flickered.
The toys began to move, slowly and rhythmically, like something was playing with them.
But when she looked away... they were back in place.

“How?”
She blinked. Again.
Everything seemed normal. Too normal.

Whispers filled her ears. A lullaby—soft and slow.
In the mirror across the room, a little girl stared back.
But it wasn’t Emily.

Panicking, she began to pack her things when she noticed the journal—aged and brittle—sitting on the bedside table.

She flipped through.

The mother.
Her words began normal, then spiraled into incoherent fear.
She described the toys moving, the girl in the mirror, the soft lullabies at night.


The exact same things Emily was experiencing.

The final entry?
“She never sleeps. And you’re next now.”

Emily's hands trembled. Was she losing her mind? Was she becoming like the mother?

The door slammed shut before she could escape.
Heart racing, she tore through drawers, shelves, anything that might help—until she found an old newspaper article.

Lilith Whitmore. Age 2. Died mysteriously in the home.
Thirty years ago.

Elara’s granddaughter.
Her mother diagnosed with postpartum psychosis.
The tragedy buried. Sanitized.

But what if it wasn’t madness?
What if the child had been murdered?
Locked away?

Was Emily connected to her?
She looked like the woman in the portrait.
Too much like her.

Adopted?
A descendant of Lilith’s brother?

Was this why she was hired?
Not to babysit—but to prove something.
A bloodline. A legacy. A curse.

A sudden growl broke her thoughts—deep and inhuman.
The nursery began to twist. Reality cracked.
The wall slid open, revealing a hidden playroom.
Dust-covered. Sealed. A cage.


Emily stumbled in. The air was thick with grief.
Visions flooded her—Lilith’s final moments, the screams, the silence.

And in that moment, Emily made a choice.
She had to confront Elara.
She had to end this.

But how?

Could Lilith be freed?
Could the curse be broken?

Or was this ritual already sealed—its next victim chosen?

Emily.

The next girl in the cycle.

Thanks so much for reading!
If you enjoyed this story, feel free to leave a comment and hit subscribe so you never miss the next one! ✨

psychologicalsupernaturalurban legendmonster

About the Creator

Gift Abotsi

From diving into the psyche to unraveling the secrets of longevity, and crafting everything from spine-chilling horror to mind-bending fiction—I write it all! Stay tuned for more twists, turns, and stories you won’t want to miss!

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.