Paige DeSorbo Opens Up About Ex Craig Conover’s New Romance:

Paige DeSorbo, the beloved Summer House star, has finally shared her thoughts on ex-boyfriend Craig Conover’s new relationship with model Natalie Buffett. During an April 24 appearance on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, the 31-year-old reality TV personality made it clear she’s moved on—and she’s rooting for her ex’s happiness too.  

Paige’s Positive Reaction to Craig’s New Love

When asked about Craig’s romance, Paige didn’t hold back her support. “I love it, I’m so happy for him,” she told host Andy Cohen, shutting down any speculation of lingering bitterness . Her upbeat response comes just five months after the pair announced their split in November 2024, ending a three-year relationship that played out across Bravo’s Summer House and Southern Charm.  


While Paige has stayed quiet about the breakup until now, she emphasized that there’s no bad blood. “We had a great relationship, but sometimes things just don’t work out,” she hinted, reflecting on their time together.  

The Breakup: Texting Scandals and Miscommunication

Though Paige’s reaction to Craig’s new girlfriend is gracious, their split wasn’t without drama. During the Summer House Season 9 premiere in February 2025, Paige revealed she’d caught Craig texting other women during their relationship—a moment she described as a breaking point. “I caught you texting two bitches in the course of our relationship,” she told castmates Amanda Batula and Lindsay Hubbard, referencing an incident that occurred a year and a half before their official breakup .  


Paige admitted she should’ve ended things sooner but chose to give Craig “so much grace” because she loved him and even envisioned marriage. “Should I have broken up with him a year and a half ago when I saw him texting hearts to a girl? Probably,” she told *Vulture* in a recent interview . Craig, however, denied any cheating allegations, calling Paige’s claims “retaliatory” and insisting the texts were platonic

Paige’s Focus: Career Over Dating

Since the split, Paige has doubled down on her career. A source close to the star told Us Weekly in April 2025 that she’s “super motivated and career-focused” and “doesn’t want to be bogged down in a relationship right now” . Instead, she’s prioritizing her popular Giggly Squad podcast, fashion projects, and enjoying single life.  


“Paige wants to have a fun summer and is doing what she wants right now,” the insider added, noting that she’s become a “hot commodity” in the dating scene but isn’t rushing into anything serious . In an interview with Parade, Paige joked, “Honestly, men in general, I am so off them for a minute. I need a moment for myself” .  

Craig’s New Chapter with Natalie Buffett

Craig, 37, confirmed his relationship status during a March 27 episode of Watch What Happens Live, telling Andy Cohen he’s “really happy” with someone new. Though he didn’t name Natalie Buffett initially, rumors quickly linked him to the influencer, who previously dated NFL star Dak Prescott .  


The Southern Charm star hinted that timing played a role in their connection. “The universe works in crazy ways, but everything happens for a reason,” he said, adding that he prefers dating one person at a time . While neither Craig nor Natalie has publicly confirmed their romance, fans spotted her at his WWHL taping and noticed his Instagram likes on her posts .  

Post-Breakup Drama: Cheating Rumors and Clapbacks

The split hasn’t been entirely smooth. Paige faced backlash after Craig’s friend and Southern Charm costar Austen Kroll suggested she’d moved on with a new man just a month post-breakup. Paige fired back on Instagram, writing, “Ahhh yes a man I haven’t spoken to in 6 months knows exactly what I’m doing” .  


She also denied cheating rumors involving Saturday Night Live’s Marcello Hernandez, calling the claims “hilarious” and clarifying she’s single. “I did not cheat on my ex-boyfriend. Period,” she declared on her podcast .  


Meanwhile, Craig hinted at lingering tensions, accusing Paige and her friends of sending “vitriol” his way post-split. He also revealed he’d bought an engagement ring during their relationship, which Paige allegedly told him to keep for a potential “BravoCon wedding” .  

Why Their Relationship Ended

According to Paige, conflicting priorities and communication issues doomed the romance. She claimed Craig wasn’t fully supportive of her career, even calling him a “secret hater” in Summer House scenes filmed before their breakup . Craig, however, felt blindsided by the split and admitted he’d been ready to propose. “If it was up to me, we would’ve just gotten engaged,” he told costar Shep Rose .  


The distance between Paige’s life in New York and Craig’s in Charleston also strained the relationship. “One day she’d say, ‘Let’s build a farmhouse,’ and the next, ‘I love New York,’” Craig recalled, calling her indecision “confusing” .  

Looking Ahead: What’s Next for Paige?

Paige isn’t dwelling on the past. With her thriving podcast, fashion collaborations, and a packed summer schedule, she’s embracing independence. “It will take someone extremely special to tie her down,” a source shared .  


As for Craig, he’s focused on his sewing brand, Sewing Down South, and building a new romance. Both seem content with their paths—proving that sometimes breakups really are for the best.  .

Key Takeaways

1. Paige supports Craig’s new relationship: She publicly wished him well on WWHL.  

2. Texting drama fueled their split: Paige accused Craig of messaging other women; he denied cheating.  

3. Paige is prioritizing her career: She’s focused on work and staying single for now.  

4. Craig is dating influencer Natalie Buffett: The pair haven’t confirmed it, but signs point to romance.  

5. Post-breakup tensions linger: From cheating rumors to clapbacks, the exes aren’t fully at peace.  




For more updates on Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover, follow their journeys on Bravo’s Summer House and Southern Charm.