A Movie Review of "You're Not You"

"Discover Someone Who Gets You - The Ultimate Battle to Never Surrender"

The 2014 film, "You're Not You," follows a talented classical pianist, Kate (Hilary Swank), who is diagnosed with ALS and struggles with accepting help from others. However, a brash college student named Bec (Emmy Rossum) becomes her caregiver and the two form an unbreakable bond. The film highlights the effects of ALS and provides a message of hope and perseverance in the face of a debilitating disease.

One of the main draws of "You're Not You" is its powerful performances from Swank and Rossum. The film centers around their growing friendship and their impact on each other's lives. This dynamic is particularly interesting given their contrasting personalities. Bec is initially irresponsible and lacks maturity, but through her relationship with Kate she learns responsibility. On the other hand, Kate's approach to life is changed by Bec's carefree spirit. Rossum's performance as Bec is a stark contrast to her typical "good girl" roles in other films, making it a standout performance in her career. Swank's portrayal of Kate is equally impressive, as she physically and emotionally transforms to honor those affected by ALS.

The film also tackles the subject of relationships and the complexities of love. While Kate's husband Evan (Josh Duhamel) initially appears to be a loving and supportive partner, it becomes clear that he is hiding secrets and fails to understand the gravity of Kate's condition. This leads to frustration and anger from the audience, making Evan one of the most disliked movie characters in recent memory.

Unfortunately, the side characters in "You're Not You" are underdeveloped and do not contribute much to the film. For example, Marcia Gay Harden and Frances Fisher play conservative and overbearing mothers of the women, but their roles are not expanded upon and could have added a lot more depth to the film. The same can be said for John Ritter's character, Wil, who is introduced near the end of the film as Bec's love interest. While he has some impact on Bec's personal growth, his limited screen time makes it difficult to fully connect with his character.

The film's editing and cinematography are noteworthy, as they effectively convey the story without unnecessary fluff. Scenes are quick and to the point, and the use of silence in some scenes is a powerful technique used by director George C. Wolfe. However, one aspect of the film that may be difficult for audiences is the lack of subtitles when Kate becomes unable to speak. While it accurately depicts the struggles of communication for those with ALS, it can be challenging to understand what is being said.

"You're Not You" is an emotional journey that elicits a range of feelings. The film's raw and genuine performances, along with its powerful message, make it worth watching. It is a film that highlights the importance of finding someone who sees you and supports you through life's challenges. The film is not recommended for its sadness alone, but rather for the exceptional performances and meaningful message it conveys.

In conclusion, "You're Not You" is a poignant film that provides a glimpse into the lives of those affected by ALS and the relationships that are forged in the face of adversity. The film's strong performances and impactful message make it a must-watch for those who appreciate well-made, emotionally charged films. The film shows that, no matter what life throws your way, there is always someone who can make a difference and help you keep your head high. The greatest battle is never giving up, and this film is a testament to that truth.